Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Spread the word: Americans do not want political violence

Hands waving small American flags
LeoPatrizi/Getty Images

Coan is the co-founder and executive director of More Like US.

When it comes to political polling, a couple of percentage points in either direction can easily change our thinking about potential outcomes.

But I want to address the other extreme: polling showing gaps of roughly 40 or 50 percentage points.


Americans dramatically overestimate the share of people in the other political party who support politically motivated violence. Data from the Polarization Research Lab shows that Americans on average think 40 percent to 50 percent of those in the other political party support politically motivated violence, but the real figures are in the low single digits.

It is vital during and after the election to make it clear to the public that the vast, vast majority of Americans do not support political violence. Otherwise, many fellow Americans can seem like potential violent threats, when in reality they overwhelmingly would not support such actions. It is vital to frequently repeat these statements throughout civil society, a step the organization I run, More Like US, will take during and after the election.

For those who want to get into the details, the Polarization Research Lab surveys roughly 1,000 Americans each week, asking a series of questions about support for increasingly intense and highly specific situations concerning cross-partisan violent actions. For a couple of these questions (on assault and murder), Americans are also asked about their perceptions of the share of those in the other party they think would support such actions.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

The results are stark and essentially symmetrical, with Republicans and Democrats equally misperceiving each other. According to the data, only 3 percent to 4 percent of both Republicans and Democrats would support cross-partisan assault, yet Americans in each party think roughly half of those in the other party would support this. (The question asked is specific about someone convicted of throwing rocks at peaceful protestors from the other party, resulting in a man with a head wound but no serious injuries.)

The gaps are broadly similar for politically motivated murder, with 1 percent to 2 percent of those in each party actually supporting such actions, but those in each party think about 40 percent of those in the other party would support it. (In this case, the question asked is specific about someone convicted of stabbing a prominent member of the other party to death.) Results have been stable for two years of asking these questions weekly.

Some who are familiar with other data are probably aware of other figures that suggest greater support for political violence. However, those questions tend to be much more general. Once specifics are added, actual support for violence plunges.

Correcting misperceptions ideally happens before violence breaks out. As the Polarization Research Lab data shows, the vast majority of Americans do not support random acts of political violence. Concerningly, Americans are much more supportive of actions defending themselves, if those in the other political party first initiate cross-party violence. Luckily, that research also shows correcting inaccurate violence perceptions of those in the other party can reduce support for political violence itself.

If violence has already broken out, research among Israelis and Palestinians promisingly shows, correcting misperceptions of violence during a violent outbreak is still helpful.

Clearly any amount of support for violence is troubling, but it is much better to have a situation in which a small fringe of a few percent of Americans support it, rather than roughly half of Americans. And compared with the few percent who may express support, even fewer will ever seriously think of committing an act themselves. For the few who are violent, thankfully there are groups such as the Prevention Practitioners Network to keep Americans safe.

I encourage you and your organizations to broadcast this message. It can be as simple as saying very few Americans support political violence. It is possible to share existing resources, such as a video from All We Share and Common Ground USA highlighting political violence misperceptions and the 99.99 percent of Americans who do not choose violence. Over Zero has a media guide series about how journalists should cover political violence, essentially boiling down to providing context, highlighting the right actors (victims and problem-solvers) while not platforming perpetrators, and being specific with up-to-date information. Though time is running out to create new content, More in Common has great advice to show a “journey of persuasion,” in this case, telling the story of people going on a “journey” from thinking many on the other side support political violence, to ultimately realizing that few actually do.

America can have a peaceful transition of power. Let’s not let distorted perceptions of each other get in the way.

Read More

Road sign that says "Tariffs just ahead"
gguy44/Getty Images

In swing states, R’s and D’s oppose big tariff increases

Kull is program director of the Program for Public Consultation. Lewitus is a research analyst at Voice of the People.

As major proposals to change U.S. trade policy have come into the discourse, a new public consultation survey finds bipartisan majorities of Americans in six swing states, as well as nationally, support the United States maintaining low tariffs with other countries so long as they abide by agreed-upon rules. At the same time, bipartisan majorities approve of the increased tariffs that have been imposed on China in response to its alleged violations of international trade rules.

Keep ReadingShow less
Two people walking along railroad tracks

Migrants cross into United States from Mexico via an abandoned railroad line near San Diego.

Qian Weizhong/VCG via Getty Images

Survey: Majorities favor path to citizenship over mass deportation

Kull is program director of the Program for Public Consultation. Lewitus is a research analyst at Voice of the People.

As immigration figures prominently in campaigns across the country, a new survey by the Program for Public Consultation in six swing states and nationally finds numerous policies on which majorities of Americans agree, including, in most cases, majorities of both Republicans and Democrats.

With millions of undocumented immigrants living in the United States, a majority in every swing state and nationally prefer offering them a path to citizenship — provided they meet several requirements — over mass deportation.

Keep ReadingShow less
Flag of Ukraine alongside flag of United States

Flags of Ukraine and the United States

Alex Wong/Getty Images

In swing states, D’s and R’s agree U.S. should continue aid to Ukraine

Amid debates about U.S. international engagement, a new public consultation survey conducted in six swing states by the University of Maryland’s Program for Public Consultation found widespread bipartisan support for the United States continuing to provide military and humanitarian aid to Ukraine.

Majorities of both Republicans and Democrats support the U.S. upholding the principle of collective security by helping to protect nations that are under attack; continuing to be a member of NATO; and continuing to abide by the longstanding international ban on nuclear testing.

Keep ReadingShow less
Red and blue fingers pointing at each other
PM Images/Getty Images

Maybe America needs a mom to call a time out

Klug served in the House of Representatives from 1991 to 1999. He hosts the political podcast “Lost in the Middle: America’s Political Orphans.”

All of us have had that moment. An innocent comment over coffee with a friend, at a family dinner or while riding an elevator with a coworker. Everyone is at edge over politics. Nerves are rubbed raw. Civility has seemingly vanished.

When asked to rate the level of political division in the country on a scale of 0-100, where 0 is no division and 100 is the edge of a civil war, the mean response is 71, according to the Georgetown University Institute of Public Service. A similar share of Americans tell Pew they worry about political disagreements triggering more violence.

Keep ReadingShow less