Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

'Hillbilly Elegy': A memoir of disadvantage or, perhaps, advantage?

J.D. Vance

Vice presidential candidate J.D. Vance was not a part of the underclass and his inability to make that discernment is deeply problematic, writes Strong.

Li Rui/Xinhua via Getty Images

Thiele Strong is a sociology professor at San José State University and a public voices fellow at the The OpEd Project.

Republican vice presidential candidate J.D. Vance’s memoir, “Hillbilly Elegy,” resonated with me in many ways. My father went by Papa, pronounced Pawpaw, and my stepmother is Mawmaw. I grew up in a household with more than a couple of ACEs. Like Vance, I certainly can relate to the cultural shifts one experiences when entering elite spaces. He spit out sparkling water. I chewed the outside shell of edamame, thinking I would be able to eventually wear it down. I didn’t; it didn’t. I spit it out.

Like him, when I entered graduate school, I thought I had come from nothing. I knew I had overcome odds. However, as I read and analyzed my way through the work of hundreds of social scientists, I realized that while my upbringing had been difficult socio-economically, I was not a part of the underclass. Neither was Vance, and his inability to make that discernment is deeply problematic.


His family lineage is what he names hillbilly royalty, a force that ruled the hills. If his relatives who engaged in the violence he describes had been Black, Latino or non-Hillbilly royalty, they would have surely been jailed or killed. History shows that the advantages of being white as opposed to being a person of color allowed his family to persist without having to bear the just consequences of their malefactions. His relatives were able to use their power to either physically or verbally threaten people into submission and this ability seems to be an aspect of his heritage of which he both seeks to overcome and is the most proud.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

In his book Vance unabashedly gives several examples, including:

“When the driver — nicknamed Big Red because of his size and hair color — repeated the insult, Uncle Pet did what any rational business owner would do: He pulled the man from his truck, beat him unconscious, and ran an electric saw up and down his body. Big Red nearly bled to death but was rushed to the hospital and survived. Uncle Pet never went to jail, though.”

As social scientists know, advantage begets advantage. And J.D. Vance, while he had obstacles, also had tremendous advantages. His grandparents owned property. His great-grandparents owned property. Currently, in the United States, home ownership hovers around 66 percent.From 1890-1940, it stayed under 50 percent. He connects his lineage to the infamous Hatfield-McCoys. He describes a large and supportive family, many of whom succeeded in the high-stakes, highly competitive life chances race.

His current political orientations are disconnected from the most compelling experiences he describes in his memoir. And still, I, someone who feels that Donald Trump is ill equipped to serve as president of our nation, find Vance’s story compelling and perhaps even a bit hopeful. But, more than anything, I am concerned.

It’s not only the wanton victim-blaming that comes so easily to Vance that worries me. It’s also the way in which he too easily makes a victim of his own life. His narrative is that of someone really “making it,” a person at the bottom, rising to become a wealthy person, at the top. But he is not from a place where ladders are non-existent. He is not even from the bottom of the ladder. He is from the top of a ladder of one contingent of the white working class — and these distinctions matter. This tendency, to understate the many ways he had the deck stacked for him, is something he and Trump have in common. This lack of understanding and empathy disturbs me.

Vance would do well to gain more sociological insight. If he could better grasp and learn from our history of racism, patriarchy and violence, if he could really learn about the class struggle from those who had less than him, he could be as big an advocate for those who really are from the bottom as he is for those he views as like himself. He could be a powerful force for good in our nation instead of perpetuating the past. And that expansion of intellect could make J.D. Vance a true paradigm shifter, part of the legacy of the FDR New Deal — which his ancestry supported.

Until then we are left with a Vance who capitalizes on the narrative that he came from nothing, while part of a ticket whose legacy andfuture plans include expanding loopholes for the most advantaged in our nation.

When I was young, growing up in Missouri, my dad told me that in America anyone can be president. And we have seen presidents, such as Barack Obama, and presidential candidates, such as Kamala Harris, who give credence to this notion.

However, it is not enough to gain power. To do good, to create a society that is socially and economically just, one must use that power to raise the voices and empower those among us who are the least resourced. By aligning with the Trump dynasty, Vance’s message of overcoming hardship and anyone can succeed is lost to the reality that both he and Trump render significant contingents of the American public as the enemy. Data from Pew Research shows that the growth in income in recent decades has tilted dramatically to upper-income households while the share going to middle-and lower income households is falling.

We need political leaders who will unapologetically reverse this trend.

Read More

Donald Trump
Brandon Bell/Getty Images

How to approach Donald Trump's second presidency

The resistance to Donald Trump has failed. He has now shaped American politics for nearly a decade, with four more years — at least — to go. A hard truth his opponents must accept: Trump is the most dominant American politician since Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

This dominance unsettles and destabilizes American democracy. Trump is a would-be authoritarian with a single overriding impulse — to help himself above all else.

Yet somehow he keeps winning.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump and his family on stage

President-elect Donald Trump claimed a mandate on Nov. 6.

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Elections don’t tell leaders what voters want. 2024 was no exception.

Interpreting the meaning of any election is no easy task. In a democracy, the results never speak for themselves. That is as true of the 2024 presidential election as it has been for any other.

This year, as is the case every four years, the battle to say what the results mean and what lessons the winning candidate should learn began as soon as the voters were counted. But, alas, elections don’t speak for themselves.

Keep ReadingShow less
Young people cheering

Supporters cheer during a campaign event with Vice President Kamala Harris at Temple University in Philadelphia on Aug. 6.

Demetrius Freeman/The Washington Post via Getty Images

The youth have spoken in favor of Harris, but it was close

For many young voters, the 2024 presidential election was the moment they had been waiting for. Months of protests and demonstrations and two political conventions had all led to this — the opportunity to exercise their democratic rights and have a say in their future.

While Donald Trump won the election, Kamala Harris won among young voters. But even though 18- to 29-year-olds provided the strongest support for Harris, President Joe Biden did better with that cohort four years ago.

Keep ReadingShow less
Hand-drawn Pilgrim hat with the words "Happy Thanksgiving"
mushroomstore/Getty Images

This Thanksgiving, it's not only OK but necessary to talk politics

This Thanksgiving, do not follow the old maxim that we should never discuss politics at the dinner table.

Many people's emotions are running high right now. Elections often bring out a wide range of feelings, whether pride and optimism for those who are pleased with the results or disappointment and frustration from those who aren’t. After a long and grueling election season, we need to connect with and not avoid one another.

Keep ReadingShow less