Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Why ‘stolen valor’ political fights are so intense — and misplaced in the cases of Walz and Vance

Tim Walz speaking at a rally

Democratic vice presidential nominee Tim Walz delivers remarks during a campaign event at the Liacouras Center at Temple University in Philadelphia.

Demetrius Freeman/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Page is an American journalist, syndicated columnist and senior member of the Chicago Tribune editorial board.

While the saying may be true that candidates for vice president usually don’t make much of a difference in the ultimate success of presidential candidates, they do give us plenty to argue about.

That’s particularly true of the current contenders.

Vice President Kamala Harris seemed to barely have gotten the name of her chosen running mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, out of her mouth before the Republican vice presidential nominee, Sen. J.D. Vance from Ohio, raised allegations of “stolen valor” against Walz. “Stolen valor” is a colorful, colloquial and yet often appropriate term for an old and sometimes illegal offense — false claims about rank, honors or service in combat by military imposters.


Carrying echoes of the “swift boating” campaign against John Kerry, the 2004 Democratic presidential nominee who was accused of lying about his Vietnam service and decorations, the Trump campaign accused Walz of retiring from the military months ahead of his unit’s deployment to Iraq just to avoid combat.

As Vance, who served as a Marine press officer in Iraq, campaigned in Michigan on Wednesday, he questioned whether the timing of Walz’s departure from the military amounted to “stolen valor garbage.” “Do not pretend to be something that you’re not,” Vance said. “I’d be ashamed if I was saying that I lied about my military service like you did.”

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

But Walz did serve a total of 24 years in various units and jobs in the Army National Guard before retiring in 2005. Republicans have charged that he knew his unit might soon be deployed to Iraq. Vance was ramping up for a congressional bid that year. But even if he retired in order to run for Congress, he already had enough years in service to make that decision legally.

Republicans also have suggested Walz inflated his credentials by calling himself a “retired command sergeant major.” While he did serve in that rank for a time, he reverted back to the rank of master sergeant when he left the military because he had not completed coursework for the higher rank. A day after that story broke, the Harris campaign updated its online biography to correct the rank.

But now Vance also has been called “an imperfect messenger” in a report by CNN’s Brianna Kellar for using his correct job title of “combat correspondent,” since, like Walz, he did not experience actual combat.

That infuriated Vance, and I can understand. Since I conducted similar duties in the Army as a “public information specialist,” I’m not going to quibble about anyone who served honorably. In my view, both Walz and Vance fall in that category.

There’s a reason political campaigns fight these battles so intensely over military records. Americans have a long tradition of elevating their military leaders to positions of political power. Ulysses S. Grant, Teddy Roosevelt, Dwight D. Eisenhower and John F. Kennedy, among others, benefited from this effect.

Since I have been reporting and commenting on “stolen valor” controversies for years, I called a leading specialist on the topic, Doug Sterner, a decorated Vietnam veteran and author who launched the Home of Heroes website to document the real heroes and campaign against false claims. He also was a prominent backer of legislation to put an end to stolen valor claims.

”From the LEGAL standpoint, there is no Stolen Valor here” in the examples regarding Walz, he wrote in an email exchange. “When the Stolen Valor Act was struck down by the Supreme Court in 2012, the revised Stolen Valor Act covered only false claims of wearing CERTAIN (not all medals) and had to have a financial benefit to be prosecutable.”

That’s not too surprising, considering the Supreme Court’s efforts to safeguard free speech. One person’s “stolen valor” can be another person’s “war stories,” in which fact-checking is almost nonexistent.

The internet and the proliferation of media dedicated to partisan causes rather than objective fact-finding make sorting through the various claims all the more difficult. For all of us, a healthy dose of skepticism — whether in reaction to claims of bravery and heroism in battle or to critics asserting that those claims are lies — is in order.

The attacks on Walz and Vance, centered as they are on what frankly are quibbles, hardly seem worthy of so much airtime and consideration. Walz served honorably for 24 years. He should be proud of that. Vance volunteered for military service in a time of war and he should be proud of that. Let’s move on.

©2024 Clarence Page. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Read More

Why toddlers are motivating an early school educator to vote

Maira Gonzalez works with students in the preschool and after-school program associated with First United Methodist Church in Fort Lauderdale, Fla.

Mark Macias

Why toddlers are motivating an early school educator to vote

Macias, a former journalist with NBC and CBS, owns the public relations agency Macias PR. He lives in South Florida with his wife and two children, ages 4 and 1.

The Fulcrum presents We the People, a series elevating the voices and visibility of the persons most affected by the decisions of elected officials. In this first installment, we explore the motivations of over 36 million eligible Latino voters as they prepare to make their voices heard in November.

Florida is home to the third largest population of Hispanics, Latinos. In a recent survey of Florida Latino voters by UnidosUS 2024, Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris(47%) leads Republican Donald Trump (42%).

__________

Maira Gonzalez vividly remembers the 2000 presidential election in Florida, and today, she sees many similarities.

“I see a pattern between Bush and Trump,” Gonzalez said. “It’s not fair what they were doing years ago and now. I understand there is a lot of crime with immigrants, but they’re blaming it all on Latins. They’re all being lumped together. Just like we have good Americans and bad Americans, it’s the same with Latins. I’m bilingual, so I see both sides, but you can’t blame Latin immigrants for everything.”

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

Keep ReadingShow less
Hulk Hogan tearing off his shirt

Hulk Hogan was part of a testosterone-fueled script for the Republican National Committee.

Jason Almond/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Manhood is on the ballot, as if politics isn't crazy enough

Page is an American journalist, syndicated columnist and senior member of the Chicago Tribune editorial board.

In case you somehow haven’t noticed, manhood is on the ballot.

Even before President Joe Biden stepped aside to let Vice President Kamala Harris step up to be the Democrats’ presidential nominee, insiders from both parties were calling this the “boys vs. girls election.”

And even before the Republican National Convention opened in Milwaukee in July, spokesmen for Team Trump were telling reporters they hoped to contrast “weak vs. strong” as their social media message — and present a stage show as testosterone-fueled as a Super Bowl.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stethoscope, pile of hundred dollar bills and a calculator
IronHeart/Getty Images

In swing states, D's and R's agree on how to lower health care costs

As the price of health care continues to rise faster than wages, a new public consultation survey by the Program for Public Consultation finds bipartisan majorities of Americans in six swing states, as well as nationally, support major proposals for lowering health care costs.

This survey is part of the “Swing Six Issue Surveys” series being conducted in the run-up to the November election in Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin on major policy issues. Unlike traditional polls, respondents in a public consultation survey go through an online “policymaking simulation” in which they are provided briefings and arguments for and against each policy. Content is reviewed by experts on different sides to ensure accuracy and balance.

Keep ReadingShow less
Donald Trump at a podium

Former President Donald Trump's campaign exploits racist dog whistles, demonizing immigrants and endorsing white nationalist rhetoric, writes Johnson.

Adam J. Dewey/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Contending with whiteness in 2024

Johnson is a United Methodist pastor, the author of "Holding Up Your Corner: Talking About Race in Your Community" and program director for the Bridge Alliance, which houses The Fulcrum.

The 2024 presidential campaign is shaping to be a racial reckoning for America.

With Vice President Kamala Harris positioned to shatter the glass ceiling as the first woman and person of color in the Oval Office and Donald Trump's candidacy fanning the flames of racial hatred, the election is laying bare the nation's ongoing struggle with whiteness and racial justice. As a pastor and advocate for racial reconciliation, I believe this moment will test our democracy's commitment to liberty and justice for all.

Keep ReadingShow less
The Latino voting bloc: Young, growing and complex
Photo by Element5 Digital

The Latino voting bloc: Young, growing and complex

Sugrue is vice president of research at the Latino Policy Forum.

The Fulcrum presents We the People, a series elevating the voices and visibility of the persons most affected by the decisions of elected officials. In this first installment, we explore the motivations of over 36 million eligible Latino voters as they prepare to make their voices heard in November.

Keep ReadingShow less