Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Cheer on the left’s looming love affair with nuclear power

Cheer on the left’s looming love affair with nuclear power

Pacific Gas and Electric's Diablo Canyon Power Plant, the only operating nuclear powered plant in California

Getty Images

Jeff Garzik serves as the founder and chairman of the policy institute Washington Power and Light. Before co-founding Bloq, he spent five years as a Bitcoin core developer and ten years at Red Hat. His work with the Linux kernel is now found in every Android phone and data center running Linux today.

Ralph Benko serves as co-founder and general counsel to Washington Power and Light. He is the co-founder and general counsel for F1R3FLY.io and has worked in or with 3 White Houses, two executive branch agencies, and the Congress as well as many political and policy institutes. He is an award winning columnist.


Determined to cut greenhouse gasses as the climate change culprit? Committed to equitable prosperity as a staple of global justice?

Want both? The gold standard of any technology is years of field testing.

To paraphrase Linus Torvalds, the real world is the best test lab in the world. There are two types of technologies:

1. Tech such as nuclear that survived real world field testing.

2. High risk, unproven “hopium” tech.

It is a bad idea to pin the well-being of humanity – based on delivering cheap, reliable, non-greenhouse gas emitting electricity at scale -- on magical thinking about unproven technology. What is needed is good hearted hard-nosed pragmatism… after squandering decades in political hopium-smoking.

Dispelling myths will inhibit Uncle Sam from misallocating tax dollars to pie-in-the-sky energy projects unsupported by engineering data. Congress recently authorized, per the White House, hundreds of billions of dollars on unproven technologies (cue the deep sigh).

This money could be used, instead, to build gigawatts of real, cheap, zero-emission generating capacity. Yes, nuclear.

We are not representatives of or shills for nuclear power companies. Our mission, at the newly founded policy institute Washington Power and Light, is to eliminate the obstacles that cause nuclear power construction to go far over budget, behind schedule ( bankrupting Westinghouse, for example), becoming unaffordable. We are all for replacing the nuclear energy dinosaurs, corporate and government.

It would be politically suicidal for an elected official to say she was intentionally choking off cheap, reliable energy. Do you believe C02-induced climate change is an existential threat? Well, breaking the political logjam may depend on a role-reversal: the left taking the lead on nuclear energy.

The growing consensus on the non-magical thinking left is that nuclear energy is essential to our survival … and is safe, reliable and cheap. Solar and wind would double or triple (as in Europe and elsewhere) our electricity costs … for a non-solution. Solar and wind are appropriate in some sunny and windy locales, but renewables do not offer a comprehensive solution.

Praise to California Governor Gavin Newsom, a charismatic center-left leader who could ride nuclear energy all the way to the White House. Per “ Doomberg:”

“To Newsom’s credit, he worked behind the scenes to extend Diablo Canyon’s license to operate, spending significant political capital to do so. He won overwhelming support in the California State Legislature, collaborated with the Biden administration to help offset the costs, and faced down opposition from the most extreme elements of the state’s notoriously radical environmental movement.

“‘ Have no doubt, President Biden is serious about doing everything possible to get the U.S. to be powered by clean energy,’ Assistant Secretary for Nuclear Energy Kathryn Huff told attendees at a nuclear energy assembly in Washington, D.C., earlier this summer. ‘ Nuclear energy is really essential to this,’ she said.

With near-unanimous bipartisan support and backed by the full weight of the Presidency, surely this was a done deal, right? Wrong.

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission initially denied the application to extend Diablo Canyon’s license. Yikes! Yet take heart. The Commission then reversed course and offered a path to keep it operating through the end of the decade.

Elected officials trump bureaucrats. And a nonpartisan consensus is emerging, even on the left, that it is safe to generate nuclear power with waste recycled into new fuel or reliably contained for a million years.

Is such pragmatism politically practical? Indeed yes. The arc of history is often bent toward justice… by the deft use of political judo.

Saul Alinsky subtitled his magnum opus, Rules for Radicals, “ a pragmatic primer for realistic radicals.” Pragmatism and idealism are complementary, not contradictory, values.

It was the Democrats (Rostenkowski, O’Neill, Bradley, Gephardt, including the young Senator Joe Biden) who led cutting the top marginal income tax rates back in the 80s from 70% to 50% to 28%, the latter by a 97-3 majority in the US Senate. Not Reagan.

Deregulation’s most successful champion was President Jimmy Carter. Not Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush, Bush or Trump. Consider the craft beer renaissance that Carter unleashed!

So kudos to Governor Newsom and other pragmatic center-left thought leaders.

Ezra Klein: “Smaller, modular nuclear reactors could make new miracles possible, like cars and planes that don’t need to be refueled or recharged. This is a world progressives, in particular, should want to hasten into existence. Clean, abundant energy is the foundation on which a more equal, just and humane world can be built.”

Bill Gates’s advisor Ken Caldeira. Per Reuters, “A former anti-nuclear activist, he has aligned with scientists who believe nuclear power – which doesn’t emit greenhouse gasses – could help wean ourselves off fossil fuels.”

NASA’s James Hansen: “’It’s very hard to see a pathway out of this without a significant role for nuclear power,’ said the pioneering American climatologist James Hansen….”

The politically ambidextrous Jonathan Rauch in The Real Obstacle to Nuclear Power: “Nuclear power is in a strange position today. Those who worry about climate change have come to see that it is essential. … To be sure, environmentalists do not love nuclear power. They much prefer solar and wind. But as Babbitt told me, ‘They’re all coming around. The attitudes in the environmental community are perceptibly changing.’ Although only a handful of the mainline environmental organizations are openly ‘nuclear inclusive’ … many quietly accept that nuclear power can be part of the climate solution, and perhaps a necessary part.”

The consensus, as summed up by Rauch and the scientists whose work he reports, and as exemplified by Caldeira and Gates and Hansen is settling on field-tested nuclear technologies.

Let the Democrats fall in love, Republicans in line, with nuclear power: friend to working people and the environment.

The future is a pragmatic energy policy connected to molecular reality.

Read More

Is Bombing Iran Deja Vu All Over Again?

The B-2 "Spirit" Stealth Bomber flys over the 136th Rose Parade Presented By Honda on Jan. 1, 2025, in Pasadena, California. (Jerod Harris/Getty Images/TNS)

Jerod Harris/Getty Images/TNS)

Is Bombing Iran Deja Vu All Over Again?

After a short and successful war with Iraq, President George H.W. Bush claimed in 1991 that “the ghosts of Vietnam have been laid to rest beneath the sands of the Arabian desert.” Bush was referring to what was commonly called the “Vietnam syndrome.” The idea was that the Vietnam War had so scarred the American psyche that we forever lost confidence in American power.

The elder President Bush was partially right. The first Iraq war was certainly popular. And his successor, President Clinton, used American power — in the former Yugoslavia and elsewhere — with the general approval of the media and the public.

Keep ReadingShow less
Conspiratorial Thinking Isn’t Growing–Its Consequences Are
a close up of a typewriter with the word conspiracy on it

Conspiratorial Thinking Isn’t Growing–Its Consequences Are

The Comet Ping Pong Pizzagate shooting, the plot to kidnap Governor Gretchen Whitmer, and a man’s livestreamed beheading of his father last year were all fueled by conspiracy theories. But while the headlines suggest that conspiratorial thinking is on the rise, this is not the case. Research points to no increase in conspiratorial thinking. Still, to a more dangerous reality: the conspiracies taking hold and being amplified by political ideologues are increasingly correlated with violence against particular groups. Fortunately, promising new research points to actions we can take to reduce conspiratorial thinking in communities across the US.

Some journalists claim that this is “a golden age of conspiracy theories,” and the public agrees. As of 2022, 59% of Americans think that people are more likely to believe in conspiracy theories today than 25 years ago, and 73% of Americans think conspiracy theories are “out of control.” Most blame this perceived increase on the role of social media and the internet.

Keep ReadingShow less
Why a College Degree No Longer Guarantees a Good Job
woman wearing academic cap and dress selective focus photography
Photo by MD Duran on Unsplash

Why a College Degree No Longer Guarantees a Good Job

A college education used to be considered, along with homeownership, one of the key pillars of the American Dream. Is that still the case? Recent experiences of college graduates seeking employment raise questions about whether a university diploma remains the best pathway to pursuing happiness, as it once was.

Consider the case of recent grad Lohanny Santo, whose TikTok video went viral with over 3.6 million “likes” as she broke down in tears and vented her frustration over her inability to find even a minimum wage job. That was despite her dual degrees from Pace University and her ability to speak three languages. John York, a 24-year-old with a master’s degree in math from New York University, writes that “it feels like I am screaming into the void with each application I am filling out.”

Keep ReadingShow less