• Home
  • Fact Check
  • Sections
  • Quizzes
  • Opinion
  • About Us
  • Glossary
  • Events
  • Election Dissection
  • Business & Democracy
  • Civic Ed
  • Bridging & Common Ground
  • Directory
  • Pop Culture
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Inclusion & Diversity
  • Media & Technology
  • Corruption
  • Civic Engagement & Education
  • Electoral Reforms
  • Ethics & Leadership
  • Governance & Legislation
  • Subscriptions
Leveraging Our Differences
  • news & opinion
    • Bridging & Common Ground
    • Business & Democracy
    • Civic Engagement & Education
    • Corruption
    • Electoral Reforms
    • Ethics & Leadership
    • Governance & Legislation
    • Inclusion & Diversity
    • Media & Technology
    • Pop Culture
  • events
  • About
      • Mission
      • Advisory Board
      • Staff
      • Contact Us
Sign Up
  1. Home>
  2. Electoral Reforms>
  3. census>

States can't sue to speed census finale, judge says, assuring gerrymander chaos

David Hawkings
March 25, 2021
Census mailings
Smith Collection/Gado/Getty Images

States eager to start redrawing their congressional and legislative districts have no right to force the Census Bureau to make up for problems delaying detailed population numbers until the fall, a federal judge has decided.

Ohio and Alabama have sued the federal government, demanding the required data for redistricting by the end of this month. Ohio's lawsuit was dismissed Wednesday by Judge Thomas Rose of Dayton, who said there was no way to compel census officials to do the impossible.

The ruling amplifies a wave of fresh anxiety about one of the main stressors on a functional democracy: Partisan gerrymandering, or drawing maps for maximum advantage rather than for competitive elections in compact communities, looks to be more egregious than ever this decade — a consequence of confusion and compressed timetables thanks to delays spawned by both nature and politics.


The first year of every previous modern decade began with the Census Bureau announcing how many House seats each state will have based on population gains or losses, followed soon thereafter with an ocean of granular data — how many people live in each neighborhood, by age, race and ethnicity — needed for drawing district lines. The reapportionment report has now been delayed to the end of April, with all the detailed population figures not following until the end of September.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

Many states have laws requiring maps to be finished by then. And in the last nationwide redistricting, about half the 435 congressional districts had been drawn by October 2011 — mainly in the states with deadlines to accommodate candidate filing deadlines by the end of the year and primaries early in the new year.

The regular timetable is now in shambles. Politicians nationwide are unsure which constituents they should be appealing to. Legislatures are debating bills giving themselves an extension or asking courts to give them leeway. Some states are already considering postponing all the dates on their election calendars.

Several are contemplating a reliance on earlier population estimates in order to meet their deadlines. The Commerce Department has signaled support for this approach, as did the judge in the Ohio case. But knowingly using outdated head counts could subject those maps to legal or even constitutional challenges, spawning even more delays and electorate confusion ahead of the 2022 midterms.

Stresses are particularly acute in states that stand to gain or lose congressional seats, including the two that have sued. Ohio is destined to have to make one of its 16 districts disappear because of modest growth, and Alabama is within a few thousand people of seeing its delegation shrink from seven to six.

Like a plurality of states, redistricting in both of those is in the hands of Republican-majority legislatures, but the Ohio process is further complicated by the overlay of a partially independent commission. Both are among those required to have maps done before the Census Bureau says it will be able to provide the final data.

Only eight states will be using a process that is comprehensively free of partisan control, Colorado and Michigan for the first time relying entirely on independent commissions. Virginia's new system puts such a commission in the driver's seat with partisan players as a backstop, and New Mexico will have a system in with a commission making recommendations to the Legislature, which can amend the maps.

Republican Attorney General Dave Yost said Ohio would appeal. "If the state does not have standing to challenge the Census Bureau's decision to arbitrarily ignore a statutory deadline, no one does," Yost said in a statement.

The Census Bureau now says much of the population detail can be sent to state capitals by August and all the numbers can be delivered in a more user-friendly format by the end of the next month.

The two states' lawsuits were opposed by a coalition of cities, counties and civil rights groups, who sued the Census Bureau last year to prevent it from ending the 2020 census early, fearing such a premature finish would mean an undercount of Black, Hispanic and impoverished communities.

The Census Bureau said it needed the extra time because of delays caused by Covid-19 as well as a spike in hurricanes and wildfires, the civil unrest over systemic racism last spring and data processing problems. In addition, the bureau's work was whipsawed by the Trump administration's effort to supplement the census — and shape the apportionment numbers — with a supplemental headcount of people in the country illegally. As one of his first acts, President Biden rescinded that apportionment order.

The census data are used not only to determine congressional seats and Electoral College votes but also the distribution of $1.5 trillion in federal spending each year.

From Your Site Articles
  • Coronavirus ends last Illinois redistricting reform effort - The Fulcrum ›
  • New Jersey may keep current legislative maps two extra years - The ... ›
  • Evictions plus pandemic could spell disaster for voters - The Fulcrum ›
  • Democrats take step toward partisan gerrymandering in N.Y. - The ... ›
  • Redistricting lawsuits seek to get ahead of partisan fights - The Fulcrum ›
  • Census undercounted Black, Hispanic, Native American people - The Fulcrum ›
Related Articles Around the Web
  • Census Bureau Statement on 2020 Census Data Collection Ending ›
  • Census Bureau Missed Dec. 31 Deadline For Apportionment Counts ... ›
census
Top Stories
People speaking in front of the Capitol

Democrats take another crack at federal election reform

David Meyers
25 March
Wordcloud in the shape of the United States

Here are the political terms Americans like

Amy McIsaac
22 March
Marjorie Taylor Greene

Why Trump's running mate is less likely to be Marco Rubio than Marjorie Taylor Greene

Jonah Goldberg
28 March
Man holding a sign that reads, "Vote Uncommitted"

The uncommitted ballot: Voting as a form of civil protest

F. Willis Johnson
18 March
Rolling Stones in concert

When it comes to political news, I can’t get no satisfaction

Sam Daley-Harris
18 March
Ripped MAGA sign

Ask Rich: Think MAGA members are unintelligent and uncouth? They’re not.

Rich Logis
22 March

Related

The worst gerrymandered districts can go away

Want to write
for The Fulcrum?

If you have something to say about ways to protect or repair our American democracy, we want to hear from you.

Submit
Get some Leverage Sign up for The Fulcrum Newsletter
Confirm that you are not a bot.
×
Follow

Support Democracy Journalism; Join The Fulcrum

The Fulcrum daily platform is where insiders and outsiders to politics are informed, meet, talk, and act to repair our democracy and make it live and work in our everyday lives. Now more than ever our democracy needs a trustworthy outlet

Contribute
Contributors

Can they play Bach? Why bias in classical music must be dismantled.

Rochelle Sennet

American business needs a strong democracy, not political retribution

Daniella Ballou-Aares
John Pleasants
Peter Brack

The U.S. is at its best when it learns from its mistakes

Kevin Frazier

A milestone in the bridge-building movement

Kristina Becvar

What gives me hope? Logan County, Ohio.

Rich Harwood

Navigating uncertainty: Can philanthropy be the good ancestor we need?

Suzette Brooks Masters
latest News

Congress needs fixing, but it got some advice from an unexpected source

Bradford Fitch
29 March

Democracy and the information ecosystem are inextricably linked

Kevin Frazier
29 March

Two aspects of our nation's original self-contradiction

Dave Anderson
29 March

Bridging divides in a multiracial democracy

Kristina Becvar
29 March

Our differences are magic

Palma Joy Strand
28 March

Why Trump's running mate is less likely to be Marco Rubio than Marjorie Taylor Greene

Jonah Goldberg
28 March
Videos
Who is the new House Speaker Rep. Mike Johnson?

Who is the new House Speaker Rep. Mike Johnson?

Our Staff
Video: Jordan bully tactics backfire, provoke threats and harassment of fellow Republicans

Video: Jordan bully tactics backfire, provoke threats and harassment of fellow Republicans

Our Staff
Video Rewind: Reflection on Indigenous Peoples' Day with Rev. F. Willis Johnson

Video Rewind: Reflection on Indigenous Peoples' Day with Rev. F. Willis Johnson

Our Staff
Video: The power of young voices

Video: The power of young voices

Our Staff
Video: Expert baffled by Trump contradicting legal team

Video: Expert baffled by Trump contradicting legal team

Our Staff
Video: Do white leaders hinder black aspirations?

Video: Do white leaders hinder black aspirations?

Our Staff
Podcasts

Podcast: Dr. F Willis Johnson in rich conversation with Steve Lawler

Lennon Wesley III
29 November 2023

Podcast: Dr. F. Willis Johnson in a rich conversation with Patrick McNeal

Our Staff
14 November 2023

Podcast: Better choices, better elections

Our Staff
23 October 2023

Podcast: Are state legislators really accountable to their voters?

Our Staff
06 October 2023
Recommended
US Capitol

Congress needs fixing, but it got some advice from an unexpected source

Governance & Legislation
Fake vs. Fact

Democracy and the information ecosystem are inextricably linked

Media & Technology
Cartoon depicting slavery

Two aspects of our nation's original self-contradiction

Governance & Legislation
people running with an American flag

Bridging divides in a multiracial democracy

Inclusion & Diversity
People separated into different groups

Our differences are magic

Bridging & Common Ground
Marjorie Taylor Greene

Why Trump's running mate is less likely to be Marco Rubio than Marjorie Taylor Greene

Ethics & Leadership