Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

How voter perceptions of celebrities, politicians shape trust, respect

Kamala Harris speaking at a podium

"It is clear that though any individual’s choice to vote for Donald Trump or Kamala Harris in November may be about their policies, it is undoubtedly also tied to their sense of identity — to a much higher degree than it would have been decades ago," writes Becvar.

Aaron J. Thornton/WireImage

Becvar is co-publisher of The Fulcrum and executive director of the Bridge Alliance Education Fund.

In August, The Fulcrum and Fidelum Partners joined to develop the 2024 US Celebrity & Politician Warmth & Competence Study. Building upon similar studies conducted by Fidelum in 2016 and 2020, the report offers updated insights into voter perceptions of political candidates and similar evaluations of celebrities.

The research is rooted in the social psychology approach known as the Stereotype Content Model, founded on a belief that the combination of perceived warmth and competence leads to different emotions and behaviors toward those social groups. Perceptions of warmth reflect friendliness or trustworthiness, and perceptions of competence reflect capability or effectiveness.


Universal drivers of human behaviorTrends in Cognitive Sciences

That premise was applied to consumer and brand research and interpersonal relationships by Fidelum Partners, leading to the Brands as Intentional Agents Framework. They concluded that humans perceive, interact, and become loyal to companies and brands like we do other people — based on their warmth and competence.

One of the co-researchers on the development of the framework, Susan Fiske, applied the model to an analysis of effective communication around climate change science. The literature and research confirmed that perceptions of warmth and competence were accurate indicators of determining trusted messengers. The evaluations of scientists as high in competence show that the public largely respects scientists — however, the low evaluations of warmth manifest as trustworthiness.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

Figure of rankings of perceptions of warmth and competence among professions, indicating scientist and researchers to be in the high-competence, low-warmth sector.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

In both cases, the dimensions of perception and belief — whether in the context of brand marketing or climate research — are central to influencing attitudes, behaviors, and decisions. How do those perceptions give us insight into celebrities and politicians?

Emotional perceptions have shifted the American electorate from voting based on personal interests to voting based on their perceived inclusion on a social “team.” The type of partisan-ideological sorting played out in recent decades has led to the feeling that every aspect of the social world around us can be divided into supporting one of those teams. Social science researchers have established a deep body of research on the effects of polarization on partisanship. It is clear that though any individual's choice to vote for Donald Trump or Kamala Harris in November may be about their policies, it is undoubtedly also tied to their sense of identity — to a much higher degree than it would have been decades ago.

Similarly, it is reasonable to consider whether the well-established indicators of trust and capability have become more influential to voters than policy positions or social issues.

This shift poses a thought-provoking question: As we move toward the 2024 election, could public figures outside of traditional politics start to wield even more significant influence on voter sentiment? And more importantly, what does it say about the electorate when celebrities are perceived as more competent leaders than those running for the highest office in the land?

The 2024 map shows substantial changes in public perceptions of Joe Biden, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris since 2020.2024 US Celebrity & Politician Warmth & Competence Study

In the first analysis of the 2024 study on celebrities and politicians' warmth and competence, both perceptions have decreased for Joe Biden, while evaluations of both have increased for Harris and Trump. However, none of the three showed up in the quadrant of high warmth and competence either in 2020 or 2024 — the highest rated in both qualities among politicians remains Barack Obama. However, Obama is considered less warm and less competent than both Kelly Clarkson and Taylor Swift.

Does that mean that in an open ballot, our first female president could be President Clarkson? It's safe to say that isn't the case. In a head-to-head evaluation, 11 percent of people would vote for Clarkson, while 37 percent would vote for Harris. Clearly, voters haven't completely foregone considering policy in favor of feelings.

While warmth and competence dominate the election landscape, social and political beliefs about economic fairness, immigration, and corporate profits are not insignificant. Thirty-six percent (36%) of Trump's and 37 percent of Harris's support stems from such issues.

However, the politician who would receive the highest percentage of votes among survey respondents, Obama, tells us that warmth and competence perceptions are also necessary to seal the deal.

data tableThe 2024 results of respondent likelihood to vote for politicians and celebrities.2024 US Celebrity & Politician Warmth & Competence Study

Read More

Women voting
Edmond Dantès

Voters are no less anxious about elections now than they were in 2020

Reid-Vanas is a clinical therapist at, and founder of, Rocky Mountain Counseling Collective.

New research by Rocky Mountain Counseling Collective reveals that American voters are already experiencing more election anxiety in 2024 than they did on Election Day 2020 (typically the day of highest election anxiety). The findings come from analyzing the Household Pulse Survey, a collaboration between the Census Bureau and federal agencies.

At the height of the 2020 election, just over half (51 percent) of surveyed Americans reported experiencing anxiety.

Keep ReadingShow less
Hispanic family

Rafael Mendez and his family.

Courtesy Rafael Mendez

U.S. Hispanic voters: Breaking the monolith myth

Macias, a former journalist with NBC and CBS, owns the public relations agencyMacias PR.

The Fulcrum presents We the People, a series elevating the voices and visibility of the persons most affected by the decisions of elected officials. In this installment, we explore the motivations of over 36 million eligible Latino voters as they prepare to make their voices heard in November.

According to the Census Bureau, the Hispanic, Latino population makes up the largest racial or ethnic minority group in America. But this group is not a monolith. Macias explores providing a more accurate and nuanced understanding of this diverse population.

Several new political polls examine how Hispanic voters view former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris. Not surprisingly, the polls are all over the place, even though they were taken around the same time.

Keep ReadingShow less
ballot envelope

Close-up of a 2020 mail-in ballot envelope for Maricopa County, Ariz.

Smith Collection/Gado/Getty Images

Election Overtime Project kicks off state briefings in Arizona

The worsening political polarization in America is creating deep anxiety among voters about the upcoming 2024 elections. Many Americans fear what disputed elections could mean for our democracy. However, close and contested elections are a part of American history, and all states have processes in place to handle just such situations. It is critical citizens understand how these systems work so that they trust the results.

Trusted elections are the foundation of our democracy.

Keep ReadingShow less
People protesting with a large banner that reads "Voters Decide"

Protesters in Detroit rally to support the 2020 election results and other causes.

Why the cost of water for poor Black Detroit voters may be key to Kamala Harris winning – or losing – Michigan

Ronald Brown is a professor of political science at Wayne State University. R. Khari Brown is a professor of sociology at Wayne State University.

The threat of violence was in the air at the TCF Center in Detroit on Nov. 5, 2020, after former President Donald Trump claimed that poll workers in the city were duplicating ballots and that there was an unexplained delay in delivering them for counting.

Both claims were later debunked.

Emboldened by Trump’s rhetoric, dozens of mainly white Republican Trump supporters banged on doors and windows at the vote-tallying center, chanting, “Stop the count!”

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman speaking at a podium

Shirley Chisholm speaks at the 1972 Democratic National Convention.

Bettmann/Getty Images

A reflection: How Kamala Harris is carrying the torch

Johnson is a United Methodist pastor, the author of "Holding Up Your Corner: Talking About Race in Your Community" and program director for the Bridge Alliance, which houses The Fulcrum.

As the 2024 presidential campaign season heats up, with Vice President Kamala Harris emerging as a formidable contender, it's a moment to reflect on the enduring power of the feminist mantra that has shaped generations of women in politics: "The personal is political."

This potent idea, popularized by trailblazers like Shirley Chisholm and bell hooks, continues to resonate through women's leadership actions today. It's particularly relevant in the context of the 2024 election, as we witness Harris' campaign and the unmistakable impact of her personal experiences on her political vision.

Keep ReadingShow less