Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

A Republic, if we can keep it

Part V: National supremacy

Opinion

Illegal immigrants detained in Texas

A Kinney County, Texas, sheriff's deputy arrives on the scene in March 2023 as Operation Lone Star officers arrest a driver for smuggling and detains immigrants who entered the country illegally.

Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Breslin is the Joseph C. Palamountain Jr. Chair of Political Science at Skidmore College and author of “A Constitution for the Living: Imagining How Five Generations of Americans Would Rewrite the Nation’s Fundamental Law.”

This is the latest in a series to assist American citizens on the bumpy road ahead this election year. By highlighting components, principles and stories of the Constitution, Breslin hopes to remind us that the American political experiment remains, in the words of Alexander Hamilton, the “most interesting in the world.”

We could all use a strong dose of John Jay in our current political brew.

Not known as an idealist, the New York diplomat and jurist nevertheless penned a rousing defense of America’s experiment in energized national government. “This country and this people,” he wrote in the second Federalist paper, “seem to have been made for each other, and it appears as if it was the design of Providence, that an inheritance so proper and convenient for a band of brethren, united to each other by the strongest ties, should never be split into a number of unsocial, jealous, and alien sovereignties.”

His point? That the United States is a divine and unique polity, one where the land and people are conjoined, forged by the bonds of injustice, and strengthened by a shared history of tenacity.


Of course, he was writing on the heels of the American Revolution, when most Americans experienced first-hand the violence and heartache associated with an international, and very public, divorce from Great Britain. He was trying to inspire. He was also trying to convince his fellow countrymen to ratify the proposed new plan of government and to reject the notion that “alien sovereignties” — states, in other words — were more equipped to protect our fundamental liberty. To be sure, his words were meant for a different generation of Americans.

Even so, they resonate just as powerfully today. Or at least they should, if we stop for a moment and consider how the current political landscape looks. I think it is fair to say that we are witnessing the most “unsocial” and “jealous” period of federal-state relations since the civil rights period of the 1960s.

Consider the bedlam at the southern border, one of the most intractable, and politically charged, issues of our lifetime.

Illustration No 1: the border feud between Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and the Biden administration. Abbott, a Republican, recently closed a large public park along the Rio Grande, refusing to allow federal Border Patrol agents access to roughly 2.5 miles along the U.S.-Mexico border. Through Operation Lone Star, Abbot wants to take control of the immigration problem, to strip away as much as possible the federal presence and to apply far more draconian measures on those seeking entry.

Abbott justified the action by citing the state’s “constitutional right to self-defense.” The problem is that immigration has historically fallen under federal jurisdiction. Denying federal Border Patrol agents entry into areas popular with immigrants is the equivalent of ignoring long-standing legal conventions that, for sound and good reasons, relegated state authority. And yet Republican governors around the country, as well as members of the GOP congressional caucus, are applauding Abbott’s rogue moves.

Illustration No. 2: Left-leaning governors are blatantly defying federal authority too. Six Democratic governors and two progressive Republican state leaders resisted President Donald Trump’s 2018 order to send National Guard troops to the southern border, say the White House’s policy of separating children from their parents was morally disqualifying.

Trump’s authority to activate National Guard troops was clear; it derived from several congressional statutes that permit presidents to “federalize” guard troops. Both Barack Obama and George W. Bush successfully used state guard troops. And yet when Trump tried to do so, these eight governors refused to abide by the orders. Oregon Kate Brown even took to Twitter to announce her defiance. “I have no intention of allowing Oregon’s guard troops,” she insisted, “to be used to distract from [Trump’s] troubles in Washington.”

This is a problem. When governors resist certified and widely accepted federal authority, they tatter the very fabric of American distinctiveness, what Jay referred to as the “strongest ties” that unite us. We succumb to those “unsocial jealousies” that he feared would be divisive. The entire plan for the American government is turned on its head. Doubtless, the same will be said when officials in Washington run roughshod over state jurisdiction, but those occasions are far more palatable because of the nature of our political design. Here’s how:

The Constitution mandates that the federal government is supreme. Not always and not in every instance. But mostly. Article VI, Clause 2 — the supremacy clause—as well as the 10th Amendment (which proclaims that states are only left with powers not already delegated to the federal government) went a long way towards shifting the locus of power from the states (under the abandoned Articles of Confederation) to the national government (under the Constitution).

That shift was crucial; from now on, the Founding generation agreed, the federal government will maintain command over those in the statehouses and the governor’s mansions. Those “alien sovereignties” are thus, by design, subordinate.

We can live with that hierarchy, of course, because our republican design for government encourages participation in federal elections: We can change the trajectory of policy in Washington through the ballot box, but we have no power to do so in states in which we do not reside. In other words, We the People collectively determine our national destiny. We decide, through our representatives in Washington, what direction we want to proceed, on immigration and most other policy areas. The same is not true when states outwardly challenge federal authority. Those who live outside Texas have no recourse when Abbott resists our collective will; the 90.1 percent of Americans who reside outside of Texas cannot vote him out of office. Federal supremacy has an inherent logic to it.

We are a divided nation, and some may find relief in the actions of these insolent governors. But history has shown that more unites us than divides us. Even during the late 18th century, the country was a pluralist amalgamation of distinctive identities. The South was very different from the North; the rural farmer was very different from the urban merchant; the Italian immigrant was very different from the Irish one; the Methodists were very different from the Anglicans. And yet for the most part Americans of all identities shared a similar birth narrative, and a common cause in the enduring quest for freedom, justice, and peace. Politics was present then — it has always been present. But party affiliation wasn’t the uniform worn by the enemy and governors didn’t defy federal power for name recognition and electoral posturing.

If we could recover just a portion of Jay’s optimism, just a small sense that the country and its people were “made for each other,” we would emerge in a far better place. If we could put regional differences aside and embrace the ideal that, in the national sense, we are a “band of brethren,” we would honor the splendor that is the American political experiment. Our vitality, John Jay precisely declared, is found in our unity.


Read More

Newly elected Democratic Senators in his office in the U. S Capitol Building

U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer poses for a photo with newly elected Democratic Senators in his office in the U. S Capitol Building on Nov. 9, 2026, in Washington, D.C. Schumer posed for a photo with U.S. Sen.-elect Sherrod Brown, U.S. Sen.-elect James Talarico, U.S. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, U.S. Sen.-elect Josh Turek, U.S. Sen.-elect Roy Cooper, U.S.

Getty Images

Democrats need to level set with voters

It’s been two weeks, but many Americans are still reveling in the Democratic tsunami that swept the country on Election Day, brimming with excitement, teeming with hope for the future, and gloating from the ass-whooping Republicans just took.

After 10 long years of Donald Trump’s brute dominance over our political system— whether he was in office or lurking menacingly outside of it — MAGA, the nativist, nationalist, nihilistic movement he created, was finally beaten back. And not just in the expected places — but on new frontiers like Texas, Mississippi and South Carolina.

Keep ReadingShow less
two cars on a highway
Cars drive on a highway next to a river

Why Your Town’s Roads Run Through Washington: Unpacking Transportation Infrastructure Funding

Introduction

Access to reliable transportation is a critical part of most Americans’ daily lives. In 2022, Americans took an average of 2.28 trips per day, traveling 28.55 miles on average — figures including every mode of transportation and every purpose, for the full population. However, little attention is paid to transportation infrastructure until there are obvious problems like potholes or broken sidewalks linked to sharp decreases in road safety and quality of life for nearby residents. Given widespread reliance on transportation infrastructure makes examination of the governance structures underpinning its funding an important area of consideration.

Process-Shaping Priorities and the Federal Level

At the federal level, transportation infrastructure is primarily governed by the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT), an executive branch agency split into nine main operating administrations overseeing a specific part of the national transit system. USDOT then uses this oversight to distribute federal funding and ensure that individual transit outlets comply with national policy and safety standards. Distributed federal funding is drawn from the Highway Trust Fund, a dedicated federal fund financed through taxes on gas and other transportation costs, and distributed to states through formula-based approaches or competitive grant programs based on spending caps established by Congress. While federal funding plays an important role in transportation infrastructure, it only represents one-quarter of all public spending on roads and highways. The remaining three-quarters of long-term financing and associated maintenance is provided by state and local governments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol Building in Washington, DC
white concrete building under blue sky during daytime

The Public Is Demanding Ethics Reform. Will Congress Listen?

At the end of the 2026 midterm elections, “corruption” emerged as a central issue in the campaign. The public outrage had been building for years. In a September 2026 Gallup poll, 89 percent of Americans agreed that corruption is “widespread throughout the government,” an all-time high. Allegations that members of Congress use insider information for stock trading have become a common belief. Additionally, a raft of sexual harassment and sexual assault scandals has shed light on the inadequate protections in place for congressional employees. As the 120th Congress convenes in January, Congress must respond to this national cry for ethics reform in the legislative and executive branches.

Historically, Congress has always needed a scandal to act. The Honest Government and Open Leadership Act of 2007 – famously proclaimed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi as an act to “drain the swamp” – was passed as a result of the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal involving illegal gifts and favors to members of Congress. It appears the swamp was harder to drain than anticipated.

Keep ReadingShow less
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

America Adrift—Our Future Depends on Returning to American Principles and Standards

The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.

It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.

Keep ReadingShow less