Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Supreme Court could shift significant regulatory power to judiciary

News

​Protesters gather outside of the Supreme Court to advocate for the Chevron doctrine

Protesters gather outside of the Supreme Court to advocate for the Chevron doctrine.

Nicole Norman/Medill School of Journalism

Norman is a graduate student at Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism.

Activists gathered outside the Supreme Court on a frigid January morning to advocate for one the most consequential legal doctrines that you’ve probably never heard of.

Participants, representing groups supporting everything from environmental policy to the rights of the disabled, braved the wind and snow-lined sidewalks of Capitol Hill to urge the justices to uphold the 40-year-old practice of courts deferring to federal agencies when they create regulations that reasonably interpret federal law.

The so-called Chevron doctrine has been used scores of times to justify agencies' decisions to fight pollution, protect workers’ rights and provide Americans with affordable access to health care. It has also been used to bolster conservative causes, most recently during Donald Trump’s presidency to roll back Obama-era environmental rules the Republican administration felt were overly restrictive.


Later that morning, the Supreme Court heard arguments in two cases that challenge the Chevron doctrine and the authority federal agencies have gained through it. The court, which is dominated by Republican-backed justices, can shift the balance of power from the president to the judicial branch.

The cases – Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo and Relentless Inc. v. Department of Commerce – both focus on Atlantic herring fisheries, which are regulated by the National Marine Fisheries Service. Under the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the agency required herring fishermen to pay for a mandatory at-sea monitoring program. Loper Bright and Relentless both sued, arguing that the fisheries service stretched the law beyond its original intention.

The demonstrators outside the Supreme Court said agencies’ interpretations of countless laws that protect people and nature are at risk in the case. Several protesters waved signs that read, “Stop the relentless power grab.” Across the way, a smaller group advocating for the court to strike down the doctrine stood silently. A few held signs saying, “It's time to stand up for the little guy.”

Erin Jackson-Hill, executive director for Stand Up Alaska, a nonprofit dedicated to increasing civic engagement, addressed the crowd.

“It is imperative that we remain vigilant and steadfast in our defense of this doctrine, as it plays a pivotal role in maintaining the balance of power and preserving the integrity of our legal system,” she said.

One demonstrator commented that she had never heard of the legal doctrine before the case went to the Supreme Court but now understands how important it has been.

The Chevron doctrine comes from the 1984 case Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resource Defense Council, Inc. The Supreme Court ruled that courts would defer to federal agencies when statutes are ambiguous. Such rule-making, the court said, is only appropriate when the agency’s interpretation is reasonable and Congress had not spoken directly on the issue.

In practice, Chevron allowed the Environmental Protection Agency to use the Clean Air Act, which had not seen any major changes since 1990, to propose stronger passenger vehicle emissions standards, including as recently as last year.

Chevron also allowed the Department of Housing and Urban Development leeway to implement the Fair Housing Act, which protects people from discrimination when renting or buying a home, or seeking a mortgage. Under Chevron, the department was able to set rules for how landlords and banks avoid discrimination.

If the justices overrule Chevron, they would give the courts much more power to challenge and direct the way that agencies implement policy, according to Devon Ombres, a senior director for the Center for American Progress, a liberal think tank.

In total, according to some experts, federal appellate courts have cited Chevron more than 5,000 times. Ombres predicts that if it gets overturned, industries would overwhelm federal courts with challenges to regulations.

The Supreme Court’s three liberal members underscored the importance of Chevron, saying it allows agencies to govern when the law “runs out,” as Justice Elena Kagan put it.

Kagan explained that members of Congress create laws knowing that there will be gaps in their knowledge as well as future advances. She used the example of Congress attempting to make laws regulating AI.

“Congress knows that this court and the lower courts are not competent with respect to deciding all the questions about AI that are going to come up in the future. And what Congress wants, we presume, is for people that actually know about AI to decide those questions,” she said.

She also peppered the attorney for Relentless, Roman Martinez, with hypothetical questions that could face courts if Chevron were to be overturned.

“Is a new product designed to promote healthy cholesterol levels a dietary supplement or a drug?” Kagan asked the attorney.

Martinez said it would depend on the “original understanding of the text of that statue read in context” and he would not directly answer the question.

The six conservative justices seemed to agree that, under Chevron, courts have been too deferential to federal agencies. (The Supreme Court has noticeably ignored citing the doctrine in cases where it would be relevant during recent oral arguments.) They discussed the consequences of rejecting or narrowing Chevron.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh criticized Chevron by pointing out that judges have no control over agencies ability to “flip-flop” their interpretations of laws passed by Congress.

“Chevron itself ushers in shocks to the system every four or eight years when a new administration comes in,” he said.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Neil Gorsuch suggested that a better model would be the ruling in Skidmore v. Swift & Co., which allowed a federal court to determine the appropriate level of deference. But Kavanaugh was skeptical of the deference courts could give federal agencies under Skidmore.

It was unclear how the court would move forward, but it seems unlikely to both defenders and opponents of Chevron that the doctrine will continue to have the same sway over U.S. policy that it has had for 40 years. The likely outcome will shift power away from the executive branch and give more to Congress and the courts.

“The least likely thing to happen is for the court to just leave Chevron as it is,” said Adi Dynar, an attorney and separation of powers expert for Pacific Legal Group.


Read More

two cars on a highway
Cars drive on a highway next to a river

Why Your Town’s Roads Run Through Washington: Unpacking Transportation Infrastructure Funding

Introduction

Access to reliable transportation is a critical part of most Americans’ daily lives. In 2022, Americans took an average of 2.28 trips per day, traveling 28.55 miles on average — figures including every mode of transportation and every purpose, for the full population. However, little attention is paid to transportation infrastructure until there are obvious problems like potholes or broken sidewalks linked to sharp decreases in road safety and quality of life for nearby residents. Given widespread reliance on transportation infrastructure makes examination of the governance structures underpinning its funding an important area of consideration.

Process-Shaping Priorities and the Federal Level

At the federal level, transportation infrastructure is primarily governed by the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT), an executive branch agency split into nine main operating administrations overseeing a specific part of the national transit system. USDOT then uses this oversight to distribute federal funding and ensure that individual transit outlets comply with national policy and safety standards. Distributed federal funding is drawn from the Highway Trust Fund, a dedicated federal fund financed through taxes on gas and other transportation costs, and distributed to states through formula-based approaches or competitive grant programs based on spending caps established by Congress. While federal funding plays an important role in transportation infrastructure, it only represents one-quarter of all public spending on roads and highways. The remaining three-quarters of long-term financing and associated maintenance is provided by state and local governments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol Building in Washington, DC
white concrete building under blue sky during daytime

The Public Is Demanding Ethics Reform. Will Congress Listen?

At the end of the 2026 midterm elections, “corruption” emerged as a central issue in the campaign. The public outrage had been building for years. In a September 2026 Gallup poll, 89 percent of Americans agreed that corruption is “widespread throughout the government,” an all-time high. Allegations that members of Congress use insider information for stock trading have become a common belief. Additionally, a raft of sexual harassment and sexual assault scandals has shed light on the inadequate protections in place for congressional employees. As the 120th Congress convenes in January, Congress must respond to this national cry for ethics reform in the legislative and executive branches.

Historically, Congress has always needed a scandal to act. The Honest Government and Open Leadership Act of 2007 – famously proclaimed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi as an act to “drain the swamp” – was passed as a result of the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal involving illegal gifts and favors to members of Congress. It appears the swamp was harder to drain than anticipated.

Keep ReadingShow less
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

America Adrift—Our Future Depends on Returning to American Principles and Standards

The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.

It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Getty Images

Who Benefits When the Process Fails?

In my previous article, I wrote about TK, a lawful permanent resident who has lived in the US for 61 years and now faces possible deportation. I questioned whether immigration enforcement could coexist with fairness, compassion, and respect for the lives people have built in this country.

Since then, I have learned something equally troubling. The legal proceedings are only part of the ordeal. What happens outside the courtroom can be just as devastating.

Keep ReadingShow less