Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Say a prayer for the pretender

Say a prayer for the pretender

Jackson Browne


Gijsbert Hanekroot
/ Contributor /Getty Images

It has been two months since we launched The (New) Fulcrum. At that time we committed to continuing coverage of news, politics, policy and public affairs as they relate to democracy and bridge building. We also committed to new coverage of culture, deepening and discovering our shared interests and common destinies, highlighting our similarities.

The response to our writings and videos that include all the creative arts has been overwhelmingly positive. Thank you.


As we continue to explore the connection of the arts to democracy, we realize that it is also an exploration of ourselves, of our dreams, of the changes that happen as the years pass by, of our place in our community, our nation and the world.

Yet so much of politics today is about competing narratives of the truth and alternate interpretations of how policies will be implemented. Those in power resort to intense lobbying to win the war of ideas; for the heart and soul of America. We are all caught up in a never ending cycle of dysfunction and tribalism that threatens our democracy.

But perhaps the most important thing we can do is to look away from the political circus and instead turn inward. It's vital to ask ourselves: What is our role in shaping the destiny for our children, our grandchildren and, yes, perhaps even our country? As I recently listened to "The Pretender," a song written over 45 years ago by American rocker Jackson Browne, I started this exploration for myself.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

In a 1997 interview, Browne said of "The Pretender":

"It is two things at once. It's that person in all of us that has a higher ideal, and the part that has settled for compromise — like Truffaut says, there's the movie you set out to make, and there's the one you settle for."

Browne goes on to say:

"The Pretender is about '60s idealism, the idea of life being about love and brotherhood, justice, social change and enlightenment, those concepts we were flooded with as our generation hit its stride; and how, later, we settled for something quite different. So when I say 'say a prayer for the pretender,' I'm talking about those people who are trying to convince themselves that there really was nothing to that idealism."

These reflections by Browne from the Pretender ring true in this refrain:

I want to know what became of the changes

We waited for love to bring

Were they only the fitful dreams

Of some greater awakening?

I've been aware of the time going by

They say, in the end, it's the wink of an eye.

As you listen to Browne's The Pretender ask yourself if our nation is a macrocosm of what inevitably happens to us as individuals. Are the dreams of our nation fading away similarly to the fading away of our personal idealism? Has a national ethos of democracy, rights, liberty, opportunity and equality for all vanished as the realities of the political circus consume us all?

Or perhaps the idealism of E Pluribus Unum (out of many, one) has been replaced by belief in demagoguery. This adherence to political dogma demonizes our differences and causes us to refuse to believe people acting and deliberating in good faith could rationally differ from their vision of who we are as Americans, and make room for us all.

"Are you there? Say a prayer for the pretender, who started out so young and strong only to surrender"

Please share with us your ideas by writing to us at pop-culture@fulcrum.us.

Read More

A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood screenshot
Sony Pictures Entertainment

Movies that show us at our weaving best

The Aspen Institute’s Weave: The Social Fabric Project tackles the problem of broken trust that has left Americans divided, lonely and in social gridlock. Weave connects and invests in grassroots leaders stepping up to weave a new, inclusive social fabric where they live. This is part of an ongoing series telling the stories of community weavers from across the country.

With the weather getting colder across the northern hemisphere and some holiday time with family and friends coming up, you might want to kick back with a movie. We’ve got you. Here are some movies that will give you hope, leave you smiling and maybe inspire you to get out and rebuild social trust in your community in 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less
The role of theater in fostering constructive political dialogue
Tom McGrath/TCMcGPhotography

The role of theater in fostering constructive political dialogue

While it may seem like our country is more politically divided than ever, political division has been a recurring theme throughout American history.

The Revolutionary War, the Civil War, the struggle for civil rights, the protests surrounding the Vietnam War and similar events highlight how deeply divided opinions can become. Each of these periods had its own complex set of issues and emotions, and they shaped the nation in significant ways.

Keep ReadingShow less
Megan Thee Stallion in front of an audience waving "Kamala" signs

Singer Megan Thee Stallion performs at a Kamala Harris rally in Atlanta on July 30.

Julia Beverly/Getty Images

Do Charli XCX’s and Kid Rock’s endorsements make a difference? 19% of young people admit they might.

Longoria is an associate professor of political science at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley.

British pop star Charli XCX sent many young people’s group text chats and social media feeds wild when she endorsed Kamala Harris by playing off a term she coined in a song, and posted on X, that “kamala IS brat.”

While this endorsement, which happened in July 2024, likely means very little to most adults who don’t follow the singer’s music, it is considered high praise among young people. Harris’ campaign astutely embraced Charli XCX’s support – temporarily changing the background of its X profile to the same shade of lime green that Charlie XCX favors.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ariana Grande

Ariana Grande

Sarah Morris/WireImage/Getty Images

Ariana Grande for Harris. Kanye West for Trump. Does it matter?

Nevins is co-publisher of The Fulcrum and co-founder and board chairman of the Bridge Alliance Education Fund.

It didn’t take long after Joe Biden dropped out of the presidential race and Kamala Harris became the odds-on favorite to be the Democratic Party's nominee for the celebrity endorsements to follow. Within a few days, Ariana Grande, Cardi B and John Legend all publicly announced their support for Harris.

Of course, not all celebrities are Democrats and Donald Trump has his share of celebrity support as well — people like Ye (Kanye West), Jason Aldean and Kid Rock, who endorsed Trump in the past and are likely to endorse him once again.

Keep ReadingShow less