Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

The latest sign that Republicans are abandoning even their most deeply held principles

Sen. Marco Rubio

Too many Republicans, including Sen. Marco Rubio, no longer have any problem with government imposing its will on society, so long as the "right" people are doing it "right."

Paul Hennessy/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

Goldberg is editor-in-chief of The Dispatch and the host of The Remnant podcast. His Twitter handle is @JonahDispatch.

The changing of the conservative mind in recent years could hardly be captured more pithily than in the headline of a recent op-ed: "Why I believe in industrial policy -- done right." So opined Sen. Marco Rubio for the Washington Post and, at greater length, for National Affairs.

Note that I'm not addressing the changing of the conservative heart. Calling lawfully convicted violent criminals such as the Jan. 6 rioters "hostages" speaks more to the sad and profound changes of heart on much of the right.

What I'm referring to, rather, are the ideas, arguments and principles that once defined conservatism intellectually, among them rejection of the kind of government intervention in the economy that the Florida Republican now apparently favors.


Modern conservatism -- the sort associated with Barry Goldwater, William F. Buckley, George Will, Thomas Sowell, Ronald Reagan and to some extent Rubio when he first came to Washington -- once regarded central economic planning and everything associated with it, including "industrial policy," to be dangerous folly. Buckley's 1955 mission statement for National Review declared: "Perhaps the most important and readily demonstrable lesson of history is that freedom goes hand in hand with a state of political decentralization, that remote government is irresponsible government." He also noted that the "competitive price system is indispensable to liberty and material progress."

This conviction can be traced back to Edmund Burke and Adam Smith, but it became a defining principle on the American right during the Cold War, against the backdrop of the rise of the Soviet Union as well as the domestic programs of Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal and Lyndon Johnson's Great Society.

There are many strands to the conservative argument against state efforts to shape the economy. One is the "knowledge problem," a phrase adapted from Nobel Prize-winning economist Friedrich Hayek's brilliant 1945 essay "The Use of Knowledge in Society."

The knowledge problem, simply put, is that society, including the market, is too complex and too dynamic for government experts to reliably direct it from afar. In a free market, prices capture information that even the best data-gatherers can't. The closer you are to the problem, the closer you are to the solution.

Public choice theory -- what another Nobel laureate economist, James M. Buchanan, called "politics without romance" -- adds another layer of reasons to distrust central planning. Government experts and regulators are often "captured" by the industries or activists most affected by their policies. Also, once politicians get involved, policy priorities multiply -- extending to boosting employment, expanding diversity, favoring certain states or districts, protecting specific industries and so on -- and the government's stated goals become pretexts for other motives. "Crises" -- pandemics, war, unemployment, environmental problems -- become excuses to reward favored constituencies.

Take President Biden's recent announcement that he would rebuild Baltimore's collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge both "as rapidly as humanly possible" and "with union labor and American steel." Well, which is it?

That brings us to Rubio. Take it from a longtime columnist, you can't always blame writers for the headlines mischievous editors put on our articles. But "Why I believe in industrial policy -- done right" perfectly captures the senator's argument and the trouble with the broader right-wing fad for central planning.

Oh, you want to do it right? Well, that changes everything!

I mean, if only someone had told Hayek and Buchanan that their objections could be answered by just "doing it right."

The change in the conservative mind goes beyond industrial policy. It's really about the use of state power generally. Too many Republicans no longer have any problem -- moral or otherwise -- with government imposing its will on society, so long as the "right" people are doing it "right." The knowledge problem, they seem to believe, is confined to the left wing.

This is the core conceptual failing of Rubio's argument, but there are others.

We used to say the left invented crises and distorted facts to justify expanding government. The same can now be said of the right. Rubio suggests that until very recently, America embraced "unfettered free trade." This is not only untrue but, as Reason's Eric Boehm suggested, a particularly strange assertion by a leading defender of Florida sugar subsidies.

Rubio also states that American manufacturing has suffered "decades of neglect" and that the "collapse of American manufacturing has ... done incalculable harm to our nation's social fabric." What collapse? While it's true that U.S. industrial employment has declined -- mostly thanks to automation, not trade -- industrial output has been increasing for a century.

I agree with Rubio that we should spend more on defense for national security purposes. But Rubio wants such spending to also mend the nation's social fabric and serve as a jobs program.

I don't share the senator's confidence that Washington could do that if only people like him were in charge.

First posted April 9, 2024. (C)2024 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Read More

Just the Facts: Trump Signs ‘Big Beautiful Bill’

U.S. President Donald Trump, joined by first lady Melania Trump, delivers remarks during an Independence Day military family picnic on the South Lawn of the White House on July 04, 2025 in Washington, DC. At the picnic President Trump signed the One, Big Beautiful Bill Act into law.

Photo by Samuel Corum/Getty Images

Just the Facts: Trump Signs ‘Big Beautiful Bill’

Washington — With pomp and circumstance, President Donald Trump signed the "big, beautiful bill" on Friday at an Independence Day ceremony at the White House.

“We made promises, and it’s really promises made, promises kept, and we’ve kept them,” Trump said. “This is a triumph of democracy on the birthday of democracy. And I have to say, the people are happy.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Tax Changes in the Federal Budget Bill Are a Disaster for Many American Families

A family together in their kitchen.

Getty Images, The Good Brigade

Tax Changes in the Federal Budget Bill Are a Disaster for Many American Families

Anyone raising children in the U.S. knows that it’s expensive. Many jobs – especially the service jobs that do essential work caring for our children and elders, bringing us food, cleaning our office buildings, and so much more – don’t pay enough to cover basic needs. From rising grocery costs to unaffordable housing, it’s becoming harder and harder for American families to make ends meet.

Unfortunately, if our leaders don’t step up, it will soon get even more difficult for families. That’s because the budget reconciliation bill passed by the U.S. Senate on Tuesday, now under consideration by the House of Representatives, includes critical tax changes that will leave many children, their families, and, ultimately, our communities in the lurch.

Keep ReadingShow less
People meeting with advisor, caseworker. Paperwork. Meeting.

Congress should recognize that caseworkers are subject-matter experts and put their knowledge to use.

Getty Images, Fotografía de eLuVe

Fixing Congressional Oversight Starts With Caseworkers

Congress writes laws but rarely follows up on how they are implemented. When things inevitably go wrong, it passes the buck to agencies, which often hire consultants to investigate the problem at great expense. However, Congress could do the job itself for free. Congress already employs a cadre of staff that knows the gory details of government programs—namely, caseworkers.

Caseworkers are staff employed by members of Congress to help their constituents navigate the federal bureaucracy. When the public has problems with federal agencies—everything from mishandled disability applications to poor postal service—caseworkers are the go-between to sort things out. In helping the public, caseworkers learn how the implementation of government programs can go awry.

Keep ReadingShow less
As DOE Redirects Funding for Puerto Rico’s Rooftop Solar, Experts Say the Change Could Strengthen Gas Systems

View of the LNG Terminal in San Juan, where most of Puerto Rico's natural gas resources are shipped to. The island currently imports 85% of its energy resources.

As DOE Redirects Funding for Puerto Rico’s Rooftop Solar, Experts Say the Change Could Strengthen Gas Systems

When President Biden first announced $1 billion in funding to install rooftop solar in Puerto Rico’s vulnerable communities two years ago, many Puerto Ricans felt it was cause for celebration. Federal officials have long sought to support rooftop solar in Puerto Rico, which could help the island's unstable energy grid become more energy-independent.

But under the leadership of President Trump — and with support from Puerto Rico’s newly elected governor, Jenniffer Gonzalez-Colòn — these federal dollars could end up going toward the island’s gas-heavy grid rather than renewable energy efforts.

Keep ReadingShow less