Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Drowning in a lake two feet deep (on average)

Helping a person who is drowning
splendens/Getty Images

Radwell is the author of“American Schism: How the Two Enlightenments Hold the Secret to Healing our Nation” and serves on the Business Council at Business for America. This is the ninth entry in a 10-part series on theAmerican schism in 2024.

In a previous article, I reflected on how our country’s 40-year pursuit of economic globalization has left so many Americans behind. Even worse, the leadership of both political parties has disregarded and even shown contempt for the suffering of generations of upstanding, working class Americans, leading to the cratering of trust in our democratic institutions.

So what is the solution? In my book, I outline a range of mindset and structural changes required to begin healing theAmerican schism. On the economic front, the empirical data has proven time and again that “free market”-based economies provide (hands down) a more efficient allocation of scarce resources compared to alternatives. The market-based economic model has enabled the realization of faster aggregate human prosperity growth over the last 200 years than in the prior 2,000 years. So, on average, all inhabitants of the planet are far better off today. But indeed averages are funny things (one can drown in a lake that is on average two feet deep).

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter


But the superiority of the market-based economic model does not imply that the government should leave the economy to itself. Over the last 100 years, economists from Hayek to Friedman and politicians from Reagan to Clinton have made this specious inference. In fact, the laissez faire version of modern day economics that has achieved cult-like status is quite a far cry from Adam’s Smith’s “invisible hand” framework. A genius of the Scottish Enlightenment, Smith demonstrated how orderly competition stimulated self-interested entrepreneurs to create win-win situations for the entire society by pursuing their own profits. In simple terms, an entrepreneur reaps profits by providing products or services that consumers value over those provided by competitors. Yet that same competition is vital since it ensures that consumers receive that value at a competitive price.

But a fundamental principle in Smith’s model says entrepreneurs need to play fairly, by a set of agreed rules. (Imagine sport games without regulations in which everyone cheated to win.) Furthermore, modern-day economists’ consensus dictates that for efficient outcomes, certain conditions must be met. In fact, the entire field of microeconomics centers around delineating these major caveats, as well as providing solutions for “market failures” that mandate correction by the state. While almost all economists agree that such market failures are plentiful, they vigorously disagree in their prescription of optimal correcting mechanisms (usually around the level of required state intervention).

So contrary to the myth that governments should leave the economy alone, in any high functioning capitalist economy the government has specific and vital roles to play to ensure the competition is fair and to promulgate correction of market failures. Most importantly, it is only with these conditions that the competition underlying the capitalist model efficiently drives innovation and creates surpluses for consumers and producers alike.

As Martin Wolf, chief economics commentator for the Financial Times, outlines in his recent book,The Crisis of Democratic Capitalism,” Smith’s concept was markedly different from the “rentier” capitalism that has come to dominate today’s economy. This latter type of free enterprise is hardly based on fair competition. Ironically, it depends on the precise opposite: unfairly advantaged producers raising structural obstacles to quash the very competition that benefits consumers. In Wolf’s own words, “a relatively small proportion of the population has successfully captured rents from the economy and uses the resources it has acquired to control the political and even legal systems, repressing real competition.” According to Wolf, the crisis of legitimacy within Western democratic regimes comes precisely from this lamentable situation where the rich get much richer by putting a stranglehold on the rulemaking process.

The consequences of this type of capitalism is that instead of delivering prosperity and steady progress, it precipitates soaring inequality, dead-end jobs and macroeconomic instability. The failures of our global economic framework have precipitated the erosion of social status and living conditions of large parts of the population. And as the globalization economy has left so many behind, the level of distrust and disdain among honorable working class Americans who play by the rules has skyrocketed. Wolf insists that as a society, we must acknowledge the tight linkage between our economic and political systems if our core values of freedom, democracy and the Enlightenment are to survive.

Wolf not only pinpoints the key failures in our modern capitalist economy — he offers a roadmap of concrete solutions for each.

Here are three examples of market failures prominent in today’s economy:

  1. Lopsided access to information. The efficient market is based on equal access to the information required for consumers to make rational decisions. An alphabet soup of regulatory bodies (e.g. FDA, FTC, SEC) exist to provide equal information access and prevent “insider trading.”
  2. Externalities. As I wrote in a recent article, businesses live by a simple equation: They grow profits and keep their shareholders happy by increasing the margin between revenue and costs. But what if a tangible set of their costs goes unaccounted for or is borne by society at-large (like carbon emissions)? This represents not only a moral failure of accountability, but a huge missed opportunity. If firms were required to account for these external costs, the power of the capitalist innovation engine would be unleashed to incentivize competitors to lower emissions (lower costs). The winner amongst rivals providing a good or service, ceteris paribus, would be the one with the lowest carbon emissions. With a flip of the regulatory switch, the very capitalist system impugned by so many environmentalists becomes the roadmap to a safer planet. (I concede the details are messy, but has that stopped us from tackling big problems before?)
  3. Adequate provision of public goods. A public good is a commodity or service that every member of society can use without reducing its availability to others. These are as diverse as infrastructure, clean air and water, parks, national security, and emergency services. My favorite example is broad access to quality public education at every level. No investment in history has ever paid larger dividends to society than a more educated population, with more productive citizens and lower safety net costs.

While seemingly contradictory, a profit-driven economic system should simultaneously provide for the public good. But absent a level playing field, if we allow dominant players to evade the costs of the externalities they produce whilst concurrently hijacking the political system’s rulemaking apparatus, the interests of the top 1 percent deviate from those of the society at large, even as the overall economy grows. Without correction and proper balance, this divergence can accelerate to a point of no return. After all, what good is achieving a rising GDP per capita while so many are drowning?

Read More

U.S. President Donald Trump holds up a signed executive order as (L-R) U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum look on in the Oval Office of the White House on April 09, 2025 in Washington, DC.

U.S. President Donald Trump holds up a signed executive order as (L-R) U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum look on in the Oval Office of the White House on April 09, 2025 in Washington, DC.

Getty Images, Anna Moneymaker

President Trump Invokes Emergency Powers for New Tariffs

In his April 2 executive order on tariffs and previous orders announcing tariffs on Chinese, Canadian, and Mexican imports, President Trump used the National Emergencies Act of 1976 (NEA) and the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977.

This raises two important questions: Do the National Emergencies Act and IEEPA allow the President to set tariffs, and is the current economic state actually an emergency? (We also covered some tariff history on our full post here, and here on the projected impact, Trump's rationale, and Congress's response.)

Keep ReadingShow less
Innovative Local Solutions Can Ease America’s Housing Crisis
aerial photography of rural
Photo by Breno Assis on Unsplash

Innovative Local Solutions Can Ease America’s Housing Crisis

Across the country, families are prevented from accessing safe, stable, affordable housing—not by accident, but by design. Decades of exclusionary zoning, racial discrimination, and disinvestment have created a housing system that works well for the wealthy but leaves others behind. Even as federal cuts to public housing programs continue nationwide, powerful, community-rooted efforts are pushing back and offering real, equity-driven solutions led by local voices.

Historically, states like New Jersey show what’s possible when legal advocacy and grassroots organizing come together. In 1975, the New Jersey Supreme Court’s Mount Laurel ruling established that every municipality in the state has a constitutional obligation to provide its fair share of affordable housing. This landmark legal ruling reshaped housing policy and set a national precedent. Today, organizations like Fair Share Housing Center continue to defend and expand this right, ensuring that local governments are prohibited from using zoning laws to exclude working-class families or people of color.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trump Welcomes Salvadoran President, Continuing To Collaborate With Far-Right World Leaders

WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 14: U.S. President Donald Trump meets with President Nayib Bukele of El Salvador in the Oval Office of the White House April 14, 2025 in Washington, DC.

(Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)

Trump Welcomes Salvadoran President, Continuing To Collaborate With Far-Right World Leaders

WASHINGTON D.C. - President Donald Trump on Monday said that he would try to deport “as many as possible” immigrants or criminals to El Salvador. Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele met with Trump at the White House to discuss the ongoing deportations of MS-13 and Tren de Aragua gang members to El Salvador’s notorious Center for Terrorism Confinement (CETOC).

Trump has now deported 238 individuals to El Salvador under the 1879 Alien Enemies Act without notice or due process of law. President Bukele has agreed to help Trump with his deportation goals and received $6 million from the White House to continue these efforts.

Keep ReadingShow less
Quiet Death of Dissent
woman in black hijab holding white and black printed board
Photo by Justin Essah on Unsplash

Quiet Death of Dissent

There is something particularly American about the way we're dismantling our democracy these days – we are doing it with paperwork. While the world watches our grand political theater, immigration agents are quietly canceling visas, filling out deportation orders, and reshaping the boundaries of acceptable speech without firing a single shot.

I think about Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian activist and Columbia graduate who committed no crime beyond speaking his mind. I think about Rumeysa Ozturk, a doctoral student at Tufts whose academic career hangs by a thread. I think about the estimated 300 international students whose visas are under review or already revoked for daring to participate in First Amendment exercises on campus across the United States. These stories are not just about immigration status but about who is American enough to participate in its democracy and under what conditions.

Keep ReadingShow less