Fact checking theory about protestor Martin Gugino - The Fulcrum

Top Stories

Home>
Fact Check>

        Claim: The 75-year-old Buffalo protester seriously injured by police is part of antifa. Fact check: False
    
play icon
Buffalo video: Officers suspended after 75-year-old man pushed down, cracking head | ABC7
www.youtube.com
By Kelly Cannon, Medill SchoolJun 09, 2020
Kelly Cannon, Medill School
 See More Writings by author 

 —  (@)
        
President Trump tweeted a baseless theory that 75-year-old Martin Gugino, seriously injured while peacefully protesting in Buffalo, N.Y., following the death of George Floyd, could be "an ANTIFA provocateur." Trump offered no evidence to support the claim — only referencing a report from One America News Network by Kristian Rouz, formerly of Russian state media Sputnik News. The OANN story cited an article on a blog called the "Conservative Treehouse" that had been written by an anonymous person who published the piece under a pseudonym. 
Gugino's attorney denied Trump's claim in a strongly worded statement given to Law&Crime, writing Gugino had always been a peaceful protester and "[n]o one from law enforcement has even suggested anything otherwise." The tweet has received backlash from lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, as well as former Vice President Joe Biden. 
Gugino has been released from intensive care but remains hospitalized following the incident.
Latest news
Democracy
        Trump 2028—A Test of Constitutional Resolve
    
Hugo Balta
2h
Governance & Legislation
        Who’s Pulling Trump’s Strings? Inside Project 2025 and the 7 Think Tanks Reshaping America
    
Steve Corbin
2h
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
        Charlie Kirk’s White Christian Nationalism Tent Wasn’t Big Enough for Gays
    
Andrew  Jolivétte
2h
Governance & Legislation
        Despite infighting, Democrats can still unite around one common goal
    
Jonah Goldberg
2h

The Top 5

Discover More

— (@)

President Trump tweeted a baseless theory that 75-year-old Martin Gugino, seriously injured while peacefully protesting in Buffalo, N.Y., following the death of George Floyd, could be "an ANTIFA provocateur." Trump offered no evidence to support the claim — only referencing a report from One America News Network by Kristian Rouz, formerly of Russian state media Sputnik News. The OANN story cited an article on a blog called the "Conservative Treehouse" that had been written by an anonymous person who published the piece under a pseudonym.

Gugino's attorney denied Trump's claim in a strongly worded statement given to Law&Crime, writing Gugino had always been a peaceful protester and "[n]o one from law enforcement has even suggested anything otherwise." The tweet has received backlash from lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, as well as former Vice President Joe Biden.

Gugino has been released from intensive care but remains hospitalized following the incident.

Related Articles Around the Web

Read More
From New York to San Francisco, millions of Americans are expected to hit the streets to voice their anger over President Donald Trump's policies at nationwide "No Kings" protests. 

        (AFP via Getty Images)
    

        Lessons from history
    
Cal  Thomas
Nov 01, 2025
People who are protesting and complaining that President Trump is behaving like a dictator apparently skipped history classes or took them at liberal universities where professors have re-written the subject to conform to their worldview.
Someone who is doing what history teachers used to do may surprise you. He is Mark Levin, who hosts a daily syndicated radio program and weekend programs on Fox News Channel. Watch and listen if you are skeptical.
Keep ReadingShow less
Recommended
Glossary
        Redistricting
    
The Fulcrum
01 January
Democracy
        Balance – The Golden Mean
    
Amy Lockard
19 May
Business & Democracy
        Just the Facts: Canadian Tariffs
    
David L. Nevins
09 March
Governance & Legislation
        Just the Facts: Canada-U.S. Tariff Update- What’s Changed Since March 2025?
    
David L. Nevins
30 August
Rule of Law
        The Legal Costs and Risks of Trump’s 328 Lawsuits
    
Steve Corbin
21 May
Business & Democracy
        Just the Facts: 2025 Canada vs. United States Tariff War
    
David L. Nevins
13 March
With millions of child abuse images reported annually and AI creating new dangers, advocates are calling for accountability from Big Tech and stronger laws to keep kids safe online.

        Getty Images, ljubaphoto
    

        Parents: It’s Time To Get Mad About Online Child Sexual Abuse
    
Erin Nicholson
Oct 31, 2025
Forty-five years ago this month, Mothers Against Drunk Driving had its first national press conference, and a global movement to stop impaired driving was born. MADD was founded by Candace Lightner after her 13-year-old daughter was struck and killed by a drunk driver while walking to a church carnival in 1980. Terms like “designated driver” and the slogan “Friends don’t let friends drive drunk” came out of MADD’s campaigning, and a variety of state and federal laws, like a lowered blood alcohol limit and legal drinking age, were instituted thanks to their advocacy. Over time, social norms evolved, and driving drunk was no longer seen as a “folk crime,” but a serious, conscious choice with serious consequences. 
Movements like this one, started by fed-up, grieving parents working with law enforcement and law makers, worked to lower road fatalities nationwide, inspire similar campaigns in other countries, and saved countless lives.
Keep ReadingShow less
Defund Brutality sign

        Credit: Nathan Dumlao, Unsplash
    

        African American Roundtable: Building Power and Liberation
    
Hugo Balta
Oct 31, 2025
In the heart of Milwaukee, the African American Roundtable (AART) is reshaping civic engagement and community power through a bold, Black-led vision of liberation. Founded to serve as a political home for Milwaukee’s Black residents, AART is a transformative force—organizing, nurturing, and amplifying leadership to challenge systemic inequities and reimagine public policy.
AART’s mission is clear and unapologetic: to build power in service of Black liberation.  Rooted in values of authentic relationships, love, organization, and community transformation, the group envisions a Milwaukee where Black people thrive in interconnected, joyful communities. Their work spans grassroots organizing, participatory budgeting, food access campaigns, and cultural programming—all designed to center Black voices and shift decision-making power into the hands of those most impacted.
Keep ReadingShow less
Kendra Sullivan staged a lone No Kings action in Beckley, West Virginia. 

        Courtesy Kendra Sullivan
    

        The Lone Woman Who Staged a ‘No Kings’ Protest in Small-Town West Virginia
    
Amanda Becker, The 19th
Oct 31, 2025
When Kendra Sullivan woke up on Wednesday, the 43-year-old West Virginian was surprised to see that she’d gone viral overnight — in a good way.
The night before, more than 40,000 people had joined YouTube for a what’s-next meeting following the 2,700 “No Kings” pro-democracy demonstrations on Saturday attended by as many as 7 million across the country. The livestream was organized by the same broad coalition of good-government, religious and advocacy groups that arranged the protests. Ash-Lee Woodard Henderson, an Appalachian activist and the first Black woman to serve as co-executive director at the Highlander Research & Education Center, a social justice leadership school in Tennessee that dates back to before the Civil Rights Movement, revved up participants by showing photos they’d submitted of Saturday’s events. 
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More