Fact checking theory about protestor Martin Gugino

Top Stories

Home>
Fact Check>

        Claim: The 75-year-old Buffalo protester seriously injured by police is part of antifa. Fact check: False
    
play icon
Buffalo video: Officers suspended after 75-year-old man pushed down, cracking head | ABC7
www.youtube.com
By Kelly CannonJun 09, 2020
Kelly Cannon
Kelly Cannon, Medill School is a contributor for The Fulcrum, a nonpartisan publication dedicated to strengthening democracy by fostering informed civic engagement and elevating diverse perspectives.
 See More Writings by author 

President Trump tweeted a baseless theory that 75-year-old Martin Gugino, seriously injured while peacefully protesting in Buffalo, N.Y., following the death of George Floyd, could be "an ANTIFA provocateur." Trump offered no evidence to support the claim — only referencing a report from One America News Network by Kristian Rouz, formerly of Russian state media Sputnik News. The OANN story cited an article on a blog called the "Conservative Treehouse" that had been written by an anonymous person who published the piece under a pseudonym. 
Gugino's attorney denied Trump's claim in a strongly worded statement given to Law&Crime, writing Gugino had always been a peaceful protester and "[n]o one from law enforcement has even suggested anything otherwise." The tweet has received backlash from lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, as well as former Vice President Joe Biden. 
Gugino has been released from intensive care but remains hospitalized following the incident.

Join a growing community committed to civic renewal.
Subscribe to The Fulcrum and be part of the conversation.

        Confirm that you are not a bot.
      

        ×
      
Latest news
Ethics & Leadership
        Donald Trump’s Midterm Delusion: Why a Red Wave Turned Blue
    
Hugo Balta
17h
Rule of Law
        Just the Facts: Trump, DOJ and the Legal Process
    
David L. Nevins
17h
Governance & Legislation
        I Believe in Immigration Enforcement. But, What Happened to TK Should Concern Us All.
    
Spencer Ross
17h
Governance & Legislation
        Flock Cameras and ALPR technology: We shouldn't trade privacy for the false promise of public safety
    
Christopher Rivera
17h

Read More
Michelle Martinez, the inaugural director of the Tishman Center for Social Justice and the Environment at the University of Michigan (U-M)
Michelle Martinez

        At the University of Michigan, Environmental Justice Starts With Who Gets to Decide
    
Val Amiel Vestil
Nov 05, 2026
When Michelle Martinez talks about climate change, she does not begin with temperatures, emissions, or models and projections.
She begins with people. For Martinez, the inaugural director of the Tishman Center for Social Justice and the Environment at the University of Michigan (U-M), climate change is already being experienced through the housing, economic, and political crises confronting communities today. And that makes climate justice inseparable from a more basic civic question: Who has the power to decide what happens to a community?
Keep ReadingShow less
Recommended
Glossary
        Redistricting
    
The Fulcrum
01 January 2025
Democracy
        Balance – The Golden Mean
    
Amy Lockard
19 May 2025
Governance & Legislation
        Trump's and Hegseth’s Officer Firings Put Pentagon Stability at Risk
    
Steve Corbin
11 May
Governance & Legislation
        What Will It Take To Truly Negotiate Paid Leave? Getting to "Yes" on Three Questions
    
Vicki Shabo
09 May
Democracy
        Independents and Republicans May Hold the Power in Los Angeles – If They Actually Vote
    
IVN Editorial Board
27 April
Civic Engagement & Education
        Older Americans Who Vote Live Longer Than Those Who Don’t – New Research
    
Sara Konrath
Femida Handy
13 May
Scarcity drains mental bandwidth and can depress voter turnout. Explore the research and how human ecology education can build civic knowledge and agency.
AnnaStills/Getty Images
    

        Material Insecurity and the Foundations of Democratic Participation
    
Sandra Ericson
Nov 05, 2026
The Path From Survival to CitizenshipAccess to food, stable housing, healthcare, and socioeconomic security shapes more than daily life. Material insecurity can also limit the time, attention, and stability people need to follow public issues, evaluate candidates, organize, and vote. Research on scarcity and political participation helps explain these connections.
In a 2014 American Psychological Association article, the authors of the book Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much, Eldar Shafir and Sendhil Mullainathan, suggest that scarcity consumes mental bandwidth, leaving fewer cognitive resources for planning and problem-solving. The article reports that this cognitive burden can produce ongoing deficits and reinforce self-defeating behavior.
Keep ReadingShow less
Close Up Hand of Man Pointing to an I Voted Sticker Place on His Shirt

        Getty Images
    

        Voters Want Results. The Midterms Made That Clear.
    
Hugo Balta
Nov 04, 2026
The 2026 midterm elections were never going to be a referendum on one person. They were always a test of whether Americans believed their leaders were addressing the issues affecting their daily lives.
Voters delivered a clear message in the midterm elections. The results were historic. Democrats not only reclaimed control of the House of Representatives, but also captured a majority in the U.S. Senate. 
Keep ReadingShow less
Uber drivers participate in a rally outside of the Uber Headquarters on January 05, 2023 in New York City. Uber drivers in NYC participated in a 24-hour strike outside of the company's NYC headquarters
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images
    

        21st-Century Gig Workers Need Portable Benefits
    
Steven Hill
Nov 04, 2026
In recent years, the US labor force has been undergoing a fundamental transformation. In today’s "Uber economy," gig workers, freelancers, contractors, temps, permatemps, remote workers after COVID, and so-called “independent workers” have been championed by Silicon Valley and Wall Street as the “new way to work”—the wave of the future, especially with AI changing the nature of work itself. 
Many US consumers have driven in an Uber taxi, but don’t realize that most drivers earn below minimum wage after accounting for vehicle expenses, gas, maintenance, and unpaid time waiting for passengers. Those drivers are so-called “independent contractors,” so the billion-dollar Uber is not responsible for providing healthcare, Social Security contributions, workers' compensation, or unemployment compensation, not to mention sick leave or vacation pay. 
Keep ReadingShow less
Load More