Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Ask Joe: Why are so many Americans phobic about mental health and illness?

Ask Joe: Why are so many Americans phobic about mental health and illness?

Correction: The name of the National Alliance on Mental Illness was corrected.

Joe,

Why are so many Americans phobic about mental health and illness? Why did we miss a paranoid psychotic and make him president and are now misunderstanding and underestimating Vladimir Putin’s messiah complex?

Before you write me off as mentally ill, give this question serious thought. Of course, in my paranoia I question whether you will ever see this question. It depends on who reads it and/or what algorithm your A.I. is using to screen such information.

Paranoid


Hello Paranoid,

Just to let you know, I see your question, I respect your question, I welcome your question. Whether you are mentally ill is hard for me to say not knowing you, but I would honestly say the question you ask, and the way you ask it, would indicate to me that you are a person of insight, passion, and deep concern for where we are going as a nation and as a global community. Yes, mental health and wellness is a critical issue of our time. The National Alliance on Mental Illness has reported that the percentage of Americans suffering from severe depression and despair rose from 36.4 percent in 2020 to 41.5 percent in 2021, based on a survey from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

I am not a licensed behavioral health care provider, but I will offer answers to your questions based on my experience and cultural observations. Having lived for 18 years outside of the United States and working internationally for 30, I’ve had plenty of time to observe, analyze and posit the workings of American culture from a distance and to compare it to other cultures. So, let’s start. But before asking why so many Americans are uncomfortable, or as you say “phobic,” about mental health issues, I think a better place to start is to ask why Americans are generally so phobic about a broad range of social and cultural issues.

When I lived in a northern European country, I experienced how it felt in my body when the general social and political approach was to look out for one another. This was reflected in how the government was set up to both encourage its citizens to excel and financially thrive as well as provide support when they needed it. I can’t say that this is the only reason for this, but I can say, from direct experience, my nervous system is able to settle there in a way it doesn’t when I’m in the United States. My conclusion is that, in a system like the U.S. where one of the cultural mottos is “everyone can and should pull themselves up by their own bootstraps” and receiving support is perceived as weakness, the personal and collective nervous systems of most, if not all, Americans are in a constant fight-flight-freeze response. This creates high levels of anxiety and perceiving anything that is different as a threat, resulting in a trauma response or patterns of phobia.

Another layer of the “sink or swim, every person for themself” mentality manifests in a deep-seated stigma we have around asking for help. Deriving pride from letting people know we did it on our own, and with a deep fear of losing individual freedom, we turn opportunities to cooperate or heal into a hostile win-lose situation. Most boys are taught to toughen up and most girls are taught to endure hardships, giving us a false sense of power that gets expressed with brute force and opposition. Therefore, discussing and getting help for our mental health becomes a direct threat to this image we feel we have to hold on to in order to survive.

So, why are leaders like the ones you mention able to succeed? Because they represent a type of power and leadership that many of us still believe to be the most effective way to succeed. And this transcends party and political beliefs. I believe we didn’t “miss this,” as you say; they actually are emblematic of a system many are still holding on to.

However, I believe this is changing. More of us are recognizing that for us to succeed, all of us need to thrive. Win-win. And from the Fierce Civility perspective, by mustering up the courage to reach out for help and creating a culture of mutual empowerment, it is possible to both maintain a sense of individual freedom and also do the messy task of working together.

One of the foundational principles of the Fierce Civility approach is that it is in your vulnerability that your true power is revealed. This is a new kind of empowerment and leadership, where you recognize that creating safety and trust is a far more effective and profitable long-term strategy than instilling fear. And part of stepping into a deeper level of authentic, resilient power is investing time and energy in your physical, mental and emotional health.

I believe we have reached a tipping point. Two years of this pandemic, and the ongoing uncertainty and anxiety, has resulted in more people welcoming the discussion around seeking support with their mental wellness. NAMI has reported that its helpline specialists went from supporting 3,543 people per month in 2019 to 5,550 per month in 2021. World athletes and public figures are speaking openly and publicly about their mental health, modeling for us this new kind of leadership and holistic approach to wellness and thriving.

So, Paranoid, keep asking the questions. We need to keep each other sharp, and also offer compassion – to ourselves as well as others,

Joe

Ask Joe is dedicated to exploring the best ways to transform tensions and bridge divides. Our resident advice columnist and conflict resolution specialist, Joe Weston, is here to answer your questions in order to resolve tension, polarization, or conflict.

Learn more about Joe Weston and his work here. Make sure to c heck out Joe’s bestselling book Fierce Civility: Transforming our Global Culture from Polarization to Lasting Peace, published March 2023.

To Ask Joe, please submit questions to: AskJoe@Fulcrum.us.

Read More

From Vision to Action: 
Remaking the World Through Social Entrepreneurship
blue and brown globe on persons hand
Photo by Greg Rosenke on Unsplash

From Vision to Action: Remaking the World Through Social Entrepreneurship

Social entrepreneurs are people who launch ventures aimed at promoting positive change in their community and in the world. I am such a person. In 1982, I founded a nonprofit organization called Search for Common Ground (informally known as “Search”). My bottom line was not financial gain but making the world a better place.

My credentials as a social entrepreneur grew out of my hands-on involvement in building Search from zero into the world’s largest nonprofit group involved in peacebuilding. My partner and closest collaborator wasand ismy wife, Susan Collin Marks. By the time we stepped down from Search’s leadership in 2014, we had a deeply committed staff of 600 employees working out of offices in 35 countries. In 2018, Search was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bruce Springsteen Speaks Out: Rise With Us and Raise Your Voices

Bruce Springsteen and Max Weinberg perform during the first night of 'The Land of Hopes and Dreams' tour at Co-op Live on May 14, 2025 in Manchester, England.

Getty Images, Shirlaine Forrest

Bruce Springsteen Speaks Out: Rise With Us and Raise Your Voices

During Bruce Springsteen’s recent Land of Hope and Dreams tour in Europe, the legendary musician drew the ire of President Trump at a concert in Manchester, England, on May 14, 2025. Springsteen openly criticized the Trump administration, calling it "corrupt, incompetent, and treasonous" and urging the audience to stand against authoritarianism.

He expanded on his concerns during the introduction to My City of Ruins, delivering a powerful statement on the state of democracy. Addressing the crowd, he declared: "There’s some very weird, strange, and dangerous shit going on out there right now. In America, they are persecuting people for using their right to free speech and voicing their dissent. This is happening now. In America, the richest men are taking satisfaction in abandoning the world’s poorest children to sickness and death. This is happening now."

Keep ReadingShow less
Navy Midshipmen’s Win Inspires Trump’s Vision of Strength

President Donald Trump honored the Navy Midshipmen football team in the East Room of the White House during a ceremony presenting the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy, Tuesday, April 15, 2025, in Washington.

Photo by Matthew Shea/Medill News Service

Navy Midshipmen’s Win Inspires Trump’s Vision of Strength

WASHINGTON – With grit and team camaraderie, the Navy Midshipmen football team marched into the White House Tuesday, ready to hoist the Commander-in-Chief Trophy for winning the series in December against the Army and Air Force academies.

Their performance, both on and off the field, mirrored the kind of resilience and relentless spirit Trump said he wanted to see across the entire U.S. military.

Keep ReadingShow less
The White Lotus Politics: Is Hollywood Storytelling Shifting Right?

Premiere of HBO Original Series "The White Lotus" Season 3 at Paramount Theatre on February 10, 2025, in Los Angeles, California.

(Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images)

The White Lotus Politics: Is Hollywood Storytelling Shifting Right?

As HBO's The White Lotus nears its season three finale, Mike White's dark exploration of the human condition through privilege and class has not only continued to seep into our cultural conversations but has increasingly woven itself into our political ones. The series, which has always been inherently political, made it more overt this season through the friendship of three women with clashing political views (played by Michelle Monaghan, Carrie Coon, and Leslie Bibb)—that culminated in a now-infamous dinner scene that captured the current political malaise defining so many of our American interactions today.

For an entertainment industry long viewed as American culture's most progressive stronghold, this show exists at a time when the Trump administration is censoring museums and muzzling news organizations, all coinciding with a swell of conservative voices gaining more visibility within the broader culture. Take NBC's Saturday Night Live, which, this March, invited country singer Morgan Wallen to perform for a second  time, years after a video surfaced of him using a racial slur outside his Nashville home in 2021.

Keep ReadingShow less