Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

There are no simple answers on affirmative action

Opinion

Affirmative action protest at Supreme Court

Proponents of affirmative action in higher education rally in front of the Supreme Court on Monday, as the justices prepare to hear two cases on the divisive issue.

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Oral arguments begin today on a case that will determine whether colleges and universities can employ policies and practices seeking to enroll minority groups with differing standards.

Harvard University is being sued for allegedly discriminating unlawfully against Asian applicants because, as stated by the plaintiffs, the school has an unwritten quota against such applicants. The plaintiffs argue the school determined Asians would disproportionately be represented in the Harvard student body because of their outstanding academic qualifications.

This case cuts to the core of an important issue that separates us as Americans: Should qualifications for enrollment at universities be adapted for minority students? To date, the argument has been that minorities have been discriminated against for generations, and thus minorities have been underrepresented at universities.


The core questions seem to be:

  • Are universities a microcosm of the larger society, and as such, should efforts be made to ensure a diverse student body?
  • Are universities a merit-based education system where we select the best and brightest, regardless of economic or demographic diversity?
  • Or is there another way to balance the needs of our changing culture?

As a young white man in college in the late 1960s I fully supported different standards for minority students given the history of discrimination in our country. I believed that the passing of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was a powerful law. I also believed that eliminating legal discrimination could not undo the harm done by centuries of discrimination against people of color. I didn’t recognize any contradiction in my thinking; it never crossed my mind as an ardent supporter of anti-discrimination laws that affirmative action was clearly discriminatory. And if I did, I surely would have thought it was justified.

The issue is an emotional one indeed with passions running high on all sides. I believe, we have a moral necessity to understand and correct the stain on the history of our nation that was slavery, yet I am not as certain as to the solution as I was 50 years ago.

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act clearly states:

No person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.

The Civil Rights Act intended to legally ensure that race was not a factor in American life, yet political, educational and business leaders realized that if we really wanted equal opportunity for all we need to do more. And thus the debate arose that continues today. The very term “affirmative” means different things to different people. Does it mean merely doing the best we can, without accountability, to bring inclusion and diversity to our schools, businesses and communities? Or does it mean providing preferential treatment to truly level the playing field?

A decade ago I inadvertently addressed the issue of affirmative action at my alma mater when I made a gift to the school. The gift was to support scholarships for minority students through the creation of the Nevins Diversity Scholarship Fund, with the goal of promoting diversity within the student body at the Penn State Smeal College of Business. I was thinking of economic disadvantage and not the disadvantage resulting from centuries of discrimination. Thoughts of affirmative action were not on my mind.

I thought about my grandparents who came to the United States in the early 1900s from Russia with no money or possessions, who blessed my parents with the desire to educate themselves and to attain the American dream. And I thought about my parents, who were able to provide me with the resources to attend Penn State.

I also understood that there were many thousands of parents who desperately wanted to help their children achieve a better life, but financial circumstances made it impossible. And I thought about the necessity of providing the foundation for students from every race, religion and creed to achieve their dreams as I was able to do as a young man.

There is no shortage of talented and qualified students from underrepresented backgrounds. Young people need the resources to attend the many great universities across the country. Recipients of the Nevins Scholarship have the same academic abilities and qualifications that all students have.

The meaning of “diversity” today has certainly changed in the 10 years since the Nevins Diversity Scholarship was announced. Economic, racial/ethnic, ideological and gender diversity are all important. One thing remains the same then as it does now: It will always be important to nurture a college community that is inclusive and reflective of the diversity that is America.

I fully understand that divisive discussions laden with rhetoric from both sides will be in abundance as the Harvard case before the Supreme Court is being adjudicated. Both sides will be triggered by discussions of diversity, inclusion, equity and opportunity. As with so much in our country today, the discussions related to the Supreme Court case on affirmative action will be filled with soundbites, harsh rhetoric and a general lack of critical thinking.

With some deep reflection and with an openness of the complexities of the racial history and racial future of our nation, I am hopeful that we can as a people co-create a sense of social cohesion through the development of dialogue that leads to understanding. A dialogue that delves deeply into the scars caused by racial discrimination while at the same time searching for the best way to offer opportunities to underrepresented groups in our county.

It is almost 60 years since the passage of the Civil Right Act and I am still in a quandary as to what else we must do. I understand that racial diversity simply will not happen on its own, yet understand the complexity of words like goals, targets and quotas that seemingly impede upon the rights of individuals.

It is in our best interest as a nation to see diversity as an operating system, not a quota. How to legislate that until our hearts and minds catch up is our challenge today. The motto of our nation – e pluribus unum: out of many one – must become a reality.

Let us fulfill this dream.


Read More

​New Hampshire Republican Senate candidate John Sununu accompanied by his wife Kitty, speaks to supporters at his primary election night watch party on September 8, 2026 in Manchester, New Hampshire

New Hampshire Republican Senate candidate John Sununu accompanied by his wife Kitty, speaks to supporters at his primary election night watch party on September 8, 2026 in Manchester, New Hampshire

CJ Gunther/Getty Images

The Responsibilities of an Inherited Political Name

A familiar surname lets a candidate begin a campaign with part of the introduction already done. The difficult question is which introduction voters have heard. They may know the candidate’s record, trust a relative’s judgment, or have a different person in mind. Those possibilities can produce the same answer to a pollster while describing very different political choices.

New Hampshire’s Senate race makes the distinction unusually visible. John E. Sununu is a former senator whose father, John H. Sununu, and brother Chris both served as governor. Several careers enter a contest for one office through the same surname. The voters must decide how much of that accumulated reputation belongs to the man seeking their vote.

Keep ReadingShow less
U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche

U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche at the Robert F. Kennedy Department of Justice building on September 30, 2026 in Washington, DC.

(Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Trump’s Weaponization of the DOJ Threatens Democratic Governance

The dust from the November 2026 midterm elections has barely settled, yet a familiar, toxic chorus of political warfare is already drowning out the clear message from American voters.

With Democrats securing majorities in both the House and Senate, voters signaled a desire for checks, balances, and a focused effort on the pressing economic issues squeezing everyday families. Instead, President Donald Trump has chosen to meet the incoming legislative branch not with an open hand, but with a weaponized Department of Justice.

Keep ReadingShow less
​U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX)

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) on October 23, 2026 in Locust Grove, Georgia.

(Photo by Abbey Cutrer/Getty Images)

Ted Cruz’s “Darkest Before Dawn” Melodrama Misses the Message of the Midterms

Texas Senator Ted Cruz wants you to believe Texas has just plunged into deep, inescapable darkness. Cruz took to his podcast and social media to deliver a characteristically apocalyptic sermon. “It is dark right now,” Cruz lamented, “but it is always darkest before the dawn.

It is a remarkably self-indulgent framing. Senator Cruz is projecting his own partisan melancholy onto an electorate that didn’t lose a game—they cast a ballot. What Cruz views as a grim twilight is, for millions of Texans, a breath of fresh air and a long-overdue dawn. By treating a democratic election like a tragedy, Cruz reveals a fundamental disconnect from the very people he is elected to represent.

Keep ReadingShow less
Democratic Presidential candidate U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) holds his first presidential campaign rally at Brooklyn College on March 02, 2019 in Brooklyn, New York.

A lobbyist who worked for both Bernie Sanders and Fortune 500 clients explains what democratic socialist wins mean for business, and how to prepare.

VIEW press/Getty Images

I Campaigned for Bernie Sanders Then Lobbied for Amazon

In 2016, my political outreach company, Firehouse Phones, worked on the presidential campaign of a democratic socialist. It was one of many campaigns my firm touched, but that one stays on my resume for a reason: it taught me more about how persuasion actually works than any client engagement before or since.

Today I run Ohio River South, a government affairs firm focused on the nation's fastest-growing region — the American South. Over the past decade we've advocated for nearly two dozen Fortune 500 companies — Amazon in my earlier lobbying years, and later growing a client roster that included Alphabet, Microsoft, General Motors, United Healthcare, and Capital One.

Keep ReadingShow less