Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

What ‘America First’ Really Looks Like

Flags of the United States hanging in front of the facade of a building
Colors Hunter - Chasseur de Couleurs/Getty Images

"Your flag flyin' over the courthouse

Means certain things are set in stone


Who we are, what we'll do, and what we won't"

–Bruce Springsteen from the Song “Long Walk Home”

In a time when we hear “America First!” or “Make America Great Again!” as a mantra, the question goes to the lyrics above. For a long time, certain things were set in stone. That seems to have radically changed.

So, what does “America First” and the greatness of America look like?

The greatness of America is not found at the end of a baton being swung by an officer in riot gear attacking peaceful protesters. It was not found in the National Guard troops marching on the protestors at Kent State. It is not found in deploying our own military to the streets of our own cities to provide a sideshow for political gain.

The greatness of America was found in the bravery of women and men whose jaws were set firmly into a more just future as the fire hoses and attack dogs were set loose upon them in Selma. It was found in marches for women’s suffrage, for workers’ rights, or for voting rights.

That history is part of the soul, the strength of America.

We cede part of our soul when petty people remove the names of past leaders from ships because they supposedly represent an aspect of “DEI” they find offensive. We lose part of our strength when small people seethe with anger because others choose to celebrate Pride Month or observe a month dedicated to honoring the unique history of certain individuals.

We dishonor the sacrifice of our soldiers when we name military bases to honor men who took arms against the Union. We dishonor freedom’s price paid across time when we whitewash unpleasant truths and history from our libraries and history books.

But some would have you believe that is the basis of our American exceptionalism.

The greatness of America is not a nation retreating from loyal allies who joined to defend Ukraine. The greatness of America was found in unity with those allies who stood with us after 9/11 and stood united as a bulwark against the aggression of the USSR, or standing together to turn back ethnic cleansing in the Balkans.

The greatness of America is a nation confident in ourselves that we are a true land of opportunity open to all people, no matter their race, religion, where they come from, who they choose to be, or who they choose to love. The greatness is in leaders who welcome freedom of speech and hope to be challenged in the marketplace of ideas to see if they are truly worthy of this nation and its people.

But look at the images of what we are seeing in this country. Masked agents are raiding and disappearing people. Free speech is being stifled on campus, in our streets, and on social media.

The greatness of America is in retreat. The things that have made America first are waning.

America is retreating from leadership in education, research, and science. America is retreating from fighting hunger and disease in poor nations around the world. America is closing its doors to the world in various areas, including trade and international student enrollment. America is retreating from being a bulwark against aggression against people callously disregarded as “collateral” damage against the onslaught of powerful war machines.

A nation in retreat surrenders greatness.

America first and American greatness came in moments like the Berlin Airlift, the Marshall Plan, the international AIDS initiatives of George W Bush, and the response to the Ebola outbreak that saved countless lives here and around the world.

That is when we and the world could see America first and foremost as the world’s indispensable nation.

However, our preeminence is also evident in the education of our people and those around the world. It is found in research and scientific breakthroughs benefiting all humanity. It is found in the programs that extend the blessings of our nation to the most vulnerable among us. The vulnerable among us don’t fit one anecdotal stereotype from those other people.

The people who need help may be a disabled man in rural Kentucky or a tornado victim in Oklahoma. They may be a single mother in Los Angeles working to support her family, or someone fleeing political persecution abroad seeking safe haven in the land of the free and the home of the brave.

In the land of the free and the home of the brave, it seems the attempts to curb freedom to voice dissent, or the rule of law, seem to be coming from those lacking bravery.

Bravery is not false bravado, spewing venom, and using the power of the office to browbeat anyone opposing your agenda.

Bravery is not having a self-aggrandizing military parade. Those kinds of military shows are the domain of weak nations. They are a show of powerful missiles and armaments that signify a type of “over-compensation” for the men leading those nations.

A nation putting its people first could take the tens of millions of dollars spent on a parade and direct those dollars to benefit veterans’ health care or find homes for homeless veterans that this nation has left behind.

All of us want to live in a great nation, one standing as a beacon of hope and stability as the world’s shining city on the hill that Reagan spoke about decades ago. He was a man who believed in one of our most powerful symbols, the Statue of Liberty, standing in New York Harbor.

Holding high her lamp, lighting the way for the huddled masses yearning to breathe free, she is the embodiment of America’s aspirational and inspirational example to the world.

That image of Lady Liberty’s Golden Torch rings hollow now. Armed thugs bully people on the orders of wannabe tough guys sitting behind a desk, retreating into hate and xenophobia.

America has been governed by confident people who could stand up to defend the rule of law and support the Constitution and the values that we have for this nation. The oath of office was not to serve a man or an agenda by circumventing centuries of precedent. The leader who imagines he is uniquely more intelligent or more important than all who came before him is certain to fail.

Every President should enter office humbled by a long arc of history before them and cognizant that they are entrusted to make decisions ensuring the legacy of our founding documents.

With the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, we set an example that was seen around the world. Now the world sees us backing away from our founding principles.

America first and American greatness is a nation that leads the world’s advance of those inalienable rights written about in 1776. America First is leading the world towards a brighter future for all people.

It is a nation where all people have lives free from fear and full of hope.

Right now, many are living in fear of our government. That is the kind of thing we never thought possible here. We are still called to be a government of the people by the people and for the people that recognizes that ALL men are created equal with certain inalienable rights. Not just citizens or “some” people of “certain” ethnicity, but ALL people.

The people who govern by fear reveal far more about their own insecurities and failings than they do about our nation. We, the people, must resist the appeal to our fears and divisions. We the people are the ones who hold the keys towards American greatness.

Until we can all aspire to our founding principles, we are not first in anything, and we fall short of the standards set for us by founders so visionary that their blueprints for our nation have lasted for centuries.

Jay Paterno is a former quarterbacks coach for Penn State University, ran for lieutenant governor of Pennsylvania in 2014 and consults on a variety of issues.

Read More

Hope, Champagne, and the Courage To Celebrate in Turbulent Times
Getty Images, wilatlak villette

Hope, Champagne, and the Courage To Celebrate in Turbulent Times

“There is hope, a way forward, however unpredictable. We can dance around the petulant games of powerful men. But, as ever, we are at the mercy of the seasons.” - Widow Clicquot

“Widow Clicquot,” adapted from a book by Tilar J. Mazzeo, is the story of Barbe Nicole Clicquot Ponsardin, widowed in 1805 at the age of 27, who inherited her husband’s debt-ridden vineyards. Against all odds, particularly as women had virtually no economic “value” or power in the early 19th century, she, and her vineyards, eventually prospered. It was she who created the Veuve Clicquot champagne dynasty.

Keep ReadingShow less
Defining The Democracy Movement: Ben Bain
- YouTube

Defining The Democracy Movement: Ben Bain

The Fulcrum presents The Path Forward: Defining the Democracy Reform Movement. Scott Warren's interview series engages diverse thought leaders to elevate the conversation about building a thriving and healthy democratic republic that fulfills its potential as a national social and political game-changer. This initiative is the start of focused collaborations and dialogue led by The Bridge Alliance and The Fulcrum teams to help the movement find a path forward.

The latest interview in this series features Ben Bain, Director of State Capacity at the Niskanen Institute and Volunteer Coordinator in Washington, DC, for More Perfect Union, a bridging organization—where we originally met.

Keep ReadingShow less

Angelica Salas’s Journey From Undocumented Immigrant to Community Leader at CHIRLA

Angelica Salas has long been a leading advocate for immigrant rights in Los Angeles. Since becoming Executive Director of the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles (CHIRLA) in 1999, she has transformed the organization into one of the most powerful immigrant-led advocacy groups in the country. Her leadership has redefined what grassroots organizing can look like, mobilizing communities around issues ranging from Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) to voter outreach and legal services.

Salas’s journey into activism is deeply personal. Born in Durango, Mexico, she arrived in the United States at the age of five, undocumented, to reunite with her parents who had migrated for work. Growing up in Pasadena, California, her family lived in the shadows of deportation until they were able to legalize their status. In 2008, Salas became a U.S. citizen, adding a powerful chapter to a story she shares with many of the people CHIRLA serves. Her own experience navigating the U.S. immigration system informs her commitment to building dignity, not dependency, in the immigrant rights movement. After graduating from Occidental College with a degree in history and sociology, Salas joined CHIRLA in 1995 and became its executive director just four years later.

Keep ReadingShow less
This Isn’t My Story. But It’s One I’ll Never Forget.

Children with American flags

This Isn’t My Story. But It’s One I’ll Never Forget.

My colleague, Meghan Monroe, a former teacher and trainer in the Dignity Index, went out to lunch with a friend on the 4th of July. Her friend was late and Meghan found herself waiting outside the restaurant where, to her surprise, a protest march approached. It wasn’t big and it wasn’t immediately clear what the protest was about. There were families and children marching—some flags, and some signs about America being free.

One group of children caught Meghan’s eye as they tugged at their mother while marching down the street. The mom paused and crouched down to speak to the children. Somehow, Meghan could read the situation and realized that the mom was explaining to the children about America—about what it is, about all the different people who make up America, about freedom, about dignity.

“I could just tell that the Mom wanted her children to understand something important, something big. I couldn’t tell anything about her politics. I could just tell that she wanted her children to understand what America can be. I could tell she wanted dignity for her children and for people in this country. It was beautiful.”

As Meghan told me this story, I realized something: that Mom at the protest is a role model for me. The 4th may be over now, but the need to explain to each other what we want for ourselves and our country isn’t.

My wife, Linda, and I celebrated America at the wedding of my godson, Alexander, and his new wife, Hannah. They want America to be a place of love. Dozens of my cousins, siblings, and children celebrated America on Cape Cod.

For them and our extended family, America is a place where families create an enduring link from one generation to the next despite loss and pain.

Thousands of Americans in central Texas confronted the most unimaginable horrors on July 4th. For them, I hope and pray America is a place where we hold on to each other in the face of unbearable pain and inexplicable loss.

Yes. It’s complicated. There were celebrations of all kinds on July 4th—celebrations of gratitude to our military, celebrations of gratitude for nature and her blessings, and sadly, celebrations of hatred too. There are a million more examples of our hopes and fears and visions, and they’re not all happy.

I bet that’s one of the lessons that mom was explaining to her children. I imagine her saying, “America is a place where everyone matters equally. No one’s dignity matters more than anyone else’s. Sometimes we get it wrong. But in our country, we always keep trying and we never give up.”

For the next 12 months as we lead up to the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, we’re going to be hearing a lot about what we want America to be. But maybe the more important question is what we the people are willing to do to fulfill our vision of what we can be. The answer to that question is hiding in plain sight and is as old as the country itself: join with others and do your part, and no part is too small to matter.

At our best, our country is a country of people who serve one another. Some may say that’s out of fashion, but not me. Someone is waiting for each of us—to talk, to share, to join, to care, to lead, to love. And in our time, the superpower we need is the capacity to treat each other with dignity, even when we disagree. Differences of opinion aren’t the problem; in fact, they’re the solution. As we love to say, “There’s no America without democracy and there’s no democracy without healthy debate and there’s no healthy debate without dignity.”

Keep ReadingShow less