Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

America’s Cold Civil War Has a Body Count

Opinion

An illustration of a large speech bubble on the ground with people standing in it shaking hands with each other.

Violent crime in the U.S. fell to historic lows in 2025, yet homicide rates trail peer nations. Explore how social trust and an "American Union" could help.

Klaus Vedfelt/Getty Images

America is safer than it has been in decades.

The FBI reported this summer that violent crime fell 9.3 percent in 2025, the largest one-year decline since it began national estimates in 1936. Murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault all fell. The murder rate dropped to 4.1 per 100,000, tying the lowest rate on record.


But even at historic lows, America remains a relatively violent society. Why?

Guns are a big part of the answer. In a study comparing 2015 mortality data from the United States and 28 other high-income countries, Erin Grinshteyn and David Hemenway found our overall homicide rate 7.5 times higher and our firearm homicide rate 24.9 times higher. Even our non-firearm homicide rate was more than twice as high. Guns explain much of America’s homicide gap, but not all of it. Poverty, inequality, drugs, policing and local conditions matter too.

But another part of the story gets much less attention. How much do we trust one another? Criminologists have been studying that question for decades.

In a landmark study of 343 Chicago neighborhoods, Robert Sampson, Stephen Raudenbush and Felton Earls identified what they called “collective efficacy”: social cohesion among neighbors combined with a willingness to act for the common good. Where collective efficacy was stronger, violence was lower.

The idea is straightforward. People behave differently when they believe they live in a community rather than among potentially dangerous strangers. Neighbors look out for one another. Adults intervene when kids are getting into trouble. Witnesses cooperate. Victims call the police.

Social trust helps keep people safe. And America is running short of it. Pew Research Center has documented a long decline in Americans’ trust in one another. In its 2023–24 survey, just 34 percent said most people can be trusted. The General Social Survey recorded 46 percent in 1972. On October 13, 2026, Gallup reported that just 51 percent trust their fellow citizens to make judgments under our democratic system, down from 86 percent in 1976.

Trust in government is even worse. In September 2025, only 17 percent of Americans said they trusted the federal government to do what is right always or most of the time.

Our politics works against both kinds of trust. We have organized a country of more than 340 million people into two enormous political coalitions that increasingly define themselves against each other. Red America fears Blue America and vice versa. Each presidential election determines which side gets the power to make national policy on guns, abortion, immigration, religion, education, environmental regulation, policing and other questions millions of Americans regard as fundamental.

Cable news and social media reinforce the conflict every day. The other side is not simply wrong. It is dangerous. Its voters threaten your rights, your values and your way of life. Hear that message often enough and political distrust becomes social distrust.

People who increasingly view one another as threats are less likely to act like members of a shared community. They are less likely to trust public institutions, less likely to rely on one another, and more likely to believe they must protect themselves.

Distrust of institutions can have concrete consequences for public safety. Economists studying the federal Secure Communities program, which involved local police in immigration enforcement, found Hispanic victims 30 percent less likely to report crimes after the program took effect. Victimization of Hispanics rose about 16 percent, mostly from property crimes. When people fear the authorities, they are less likely to help those authorities protect them.

Reorganizing the United States into an American Union — two semi-autonomous democratic republics, one predominantly Red and one predominantly Blue, joined by a common defense, common currency, integrated markets and freedom of movement — would address that distrust at its root.

Red and Blue Americans would no longer spend every four years fighting over which side gets to control the other. A conservative in Red America would not have to worry that voters in Blue America would determine his republic’s gun laws, schools or social policies. A progressive in Blue America would not have to worry that voters in Red America would determine abortion policy, environmental rules or the relationship between religion and government.

That changes the nature of political conflict. The person who disagrees with you is no longer necessarily part of a competing national tribe threatening to impose an unwanted way of life on yours. That person is simply another member of your political community arguing about how that community should be governed.

While political conflict would remain, its stakes would change. Instead of asking, “How do we stop those people from governing us?” politics would increasingly ask, “How should we govern ourselves?”

And that change could make gun policy easier.

Americans disagree sharply about guns, but not as much as our politics suggests. Pew found that 88 percent of Republicans and 89 percent of Democrats supported preventing people with mental illnesses from purchasing guns. Majorities in both parties — 69 percent of Republicans and 90 percent of Democrats — supported raising the minimum purchase age to 21.

Yet even broadly supported measures enter a national political system in which guns have become part of Red-Blue identity: A gun owner in Red America can see a safety regulation as the first step toward Blue America taking away his rights. A gun-control supporter in Blue America can see protections for lawful ownership as surrender to Red America.

An American Union changes that calculation. Each republic could set its own balance between gun rights and public safety, matching the genuine preferences of its citizens — without fearing that the other side will impose its own.

But public safety extends far beyond firearms. And other developed democracies show that ethnic diversity, immigration and federalism can coexist with stronger social trust and far less violence.

Canada is vast, federal and multiethnic; its homicide rate was 1.91 per 100,000 in 2024 — less than half ours. Australia is highly diverse and heavily immigration-driven, with a homicide rate around 1.0 per 100,000. England and Wales are densely urban and multiethnic, yet their homicide rate dropped to 0.86 per 100,000 in the year ending March 2025 — the lowest since 1977. New Zealand combines substantial Māori, Asian and Pacific populations with a murder rate far below our own. And Switzerland combines four national languages, strong regional identities, decentralized government and relatively high civilian gun ownership — an estimated 27.6 civilian firearms per 100 residents in 2017 — with a homicide rate of about 0.6 per 100,000 in 2025.

While these countries differ in many ways, together they make a simple point. Ethnic diversity does not require high violence. Neither does immigration, federalism or regional difference. Switzerland shows that even substantial civilian gun ownership can coexist with very low homicide.

The trust comparison points in the same direction. The Integrated Values Surveys, combining European Values Study and World Values Survey data, allow us to compare the share of people who say most people can be trusted. Switzerland: 59 percent; New Zealand: 57; Australia: 49; Canada: 47; Britain: 43. And the United States, on this internationally comparable measure: 37 percent.

Each of these countries has both greater social trust and a far lower homicide rate than the United States. Together with the research on collective efficacy, that pattern supports a straightforward conclusion: more cohesive societies tend to be safer. Building more cohesive political communities through an American Union offers a way to reduce violence here.

American social trust, meanwhile, has been moving in the opposite direction. Our political structure did not create that decline, but it continually reinforces it. That is America’s cold civil war: Two enormous political coalitions locked in a permanent fight for control of one national government powerful enough to govern both sides on questions they regard as fundamental.

We keep asking Americans to trust one another while giving them powerful reasons not to. An American Union changes those incentives. While each republic would still contain political minorities whose rights must be protected, each would have more room to develop policies on guns, policing and criminal justice that its citizens regard as legitimate.

America’s violent-crime rate is falling. But our level of violence is not inevitable, and it is certainly not enviable. Other diverse democracies live with far less of it. Research into collective efficacy points to one part of the explanation: communities are safer when neighbors trust one another and work together.

An American Union would not make Red and Blue Americans agree, but it would give them less reason to fear one another, and less reason to treat every election as a struggle for control. That shift opens the door to more cohesive communities, deeper institutional trust, and governments that citizens genuinely experience as their own.

And, ultimately, fewer Americans hurting one another.


Jordan Karp is a lawyer and writer based in New York with a keen interest in American political culture, institutional reform, and civic life.


Read More

US Flag
us a flag on pole under cloudy sky

This Country ’Tis of Thee Calls America to Unite Again

In July 2024, before the presidential election, I was deeply moved by a song written by New York/Nashville recording artist and songwriter Candace Asher. It’s called “This Country ’Tis of Thee.” Asher is internationally and critically acclaimed for several top‑five hits and airplay in 12 countries in the early 2000s.

I teamed up with Candace, and together we wrote new, contemporary lyrics for “This Country ’Tis of Thee,” and together we produced the video that went live on YouTube.

Keep Reading Show less
Meeting, handshake and business people with deal in office for funding approval and success.

Four Reds and four Blues reached unanimous Points of Agreement on immigration, then presented them to Reps. Fitzpatrick and Suozzi. Here’s how it worked.

Jacob Wackerhausen/Getty Images

On Immigration, Common Ground May Be Closer Than We Think

Immigration has become one of the issues pulling Americans apart. Earlier this month, at a constituent conversation in Bristol, Pennsylvania, I watched eight Americans with very different political views offer a glimpse of how it does not have to stay that way.

Four “Reds” and four “Blues” — terms used for participants on the political right and left — sat across from Reps. Brian Fitzpatrick (R-Pa.) and Tom Suozzi (D-N.Y.), the Republican and Democratic co-chairs of the House Problem Solvers Caucus, to present something increasingly unusual in our politics: unanimous Points of Agreement on immigration developed through an earlier Common Ground Workshop.

Keep Reading Show less
Visitor at the reflecting pools to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the September 11th terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center

A visitor pauses at the reflecting pools to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the September 11th terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center at the National 9/11 Memorial & Museum on September 11, 2026, in New York City.

(Photo by Jeenah Moon - Pool/Getty Images)

The Moral Distance Between Our Dead and Theirs

Last month, I watched the ceremonies marking the 25th anniversary of September 11.

I listened as family members read the names of the dead. Children and grandchildren talked about people whose absence still shapes their lives. Nearly 3,000 people were killed that morning. At the 9/11 Memorial, they are remembered as individuals.

Keep Reading Show less