Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Florida felon voting rights expansion put on hold

Former Florida felon Michael Monfluery

Michael Monfluery is among the released felons advocating to reclaims voting rights in Florida.

Zak Bennett/Getty Images

The on-again, off-again political rights of people released from prison in the nation's biggest purple state has been one of the most prominent democracy reform stories of the past two years. For now, they're off again.

A federal appeals court has put on hold a lower court's ruling that had opened up registration and voting to upwards of a million Florida felons.

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday granted a request from Gov. Ron DeSantis to stay the trial judge's decision — which for a month stood as the year's biggest victory for voting rights — and have the entire appeals panel hear the case in August, bypassing the usual practice of starting with just three judges.


The governor is hoping to reverse a decision from Judge Robert Hinkle, who in May struck down as an unconstitutional "pay-to-vote system" the new state requirement that felons pay all their fines, fees and court costs before getting to vote again.

The outcome, which seems destined to be decided in the Supreme Court after the presidential election, has enormous national significance. That's not only because the voting rights of felons has become a main cause of the civil rights movement but also because hundreds of thousands of new, probably Democratic voters could start tipping outcomes in a state where extremely narrow margins in major elections have been the norm for two decades.

A law enacted last year by a GOP-majority Legislature and signed by DeSantis, also a Republican, requires felons to pay all their court-ordered financial obligations before registering. It was based on the rationale that those payments constituted completion of a criminal sentence.

The measure was written after nearly two-thirds of the state's voters in 2018 approved a state constitutional amendment restoring voting rights to almost all felons (except murderers and sex offenders) who had completed "all terms of their sentence including parole or probation."

Opponents of the law argue the financial requirements amounted to the sort of poll taxes that were barred by constitutional amendment in the 1960s after they were used across the South to suppress the votes of Black people.

Law professor Richard Hasen with the University of California at Irvine wrote in his Election Law blog that the 11th Circuit's decision to stay the lower court ruling and expedite the appeal may signal the coming reversal of the ruling.

How much of an impact restoring felon voting rights would have in the Aug. 18 congressional and legislative primaries and the fall presidential race in Florida (where the state's 29 electoral votes are the third-biggest prize) is uncertain because it is not clear how many would actually register and vote.

Research has shown that felons who get their franchise back after their release from prison are far more likely to register as Democrats but also are less likely to vote at all.

In seeking to put the judge's decision on hold, the governor's lawyers argued that allowing even one felon to vote while there's a chance Hinkle's ruling would be overturned "would inflict irreparable harm on the state."

"Indeed, if the district court's order is in place during the elections, but is later vacated, the integrity of the elections will have been corrupted and their results possibly opened to challenge," they argued.

The consensus view is that about 750,000 Floridians would need to come up with money before voting again if the state law is upheld.

Read More

Why Doing Immigration the “White Way” Is Wrong

A close up of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement badge.

Getty Images, Tennessee Witney

Why Doing Immigration the “White Way” Is Wrong

The president is granting refugee status to white South Africans. Meanwhile, he is issuing travel bans, unsure about his duty to uphold due process, fighting birthright citizenship, and backing massive human rights breaches against people of color, including deporting citizens and people authorized to be here.

The administration’s escalating immigration enforcement—marked by “fast-track” deportations or disappearances without due process—signal a dangerous leveling-up of aggressive anti-immigration policies and authoritarian tactics. In the face of the immigration chaos that we are now in, we could—and should—turn our efforts toward making immigration policies less racist, more efficient, and more humane because America’s promise is built on freedom and democracy, not terror. As social scientists, we know that in America, thinking people can and should “just get documented” ignores the very real and large barriers embedded in our systems.

Keep ReadingShow less
Insider trading in Washington, DC

U.S. senators and representatives with access to non-public information are permitted to buy and sell individual stocks. It’s not just unethical; it sends the message that the game is rigged.

Getty Images, Greggory DiSalvo

Insider Trading: If CEOs Can’t Do It, Why Can Congress?

Ivan Boesky. Martha Stewart. Jeffrey Skilling.

Each became infamous for using privileged, non-public information to profit unfairly from the stock market. They were prosecuted. They served time. Because insider trading is a crime that threatens public trust and distorts free markets.

Keep ReadingShow less
Supreme Court Changes the Game on Federal Environmental Reviews

A pump jack seen in a southeast New Mexico oilfield.

Getty Images, Daniel A. Leifheit

Supreme Court Changes the Game on Federal Environmental Reviews

Getting federal approval for permits to build bridges, wind farms, highways and other major infrastructure projects has long been a complicated and time-consuming process. Despite growing calls from both parties for Congress and federal agencies to reform that process, there had been few significant revisions – until now.

In one fell swoop, the U.S. Supreme Court has changed a big part of the game.

Keep ReadingShow less