Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Partisan Loyalty Now Drives Americans’ Trust in Justice

Equal treatment and clear rules can still revive confidence in the justice system

Opinion

Statue of justice, gavel, and open book on table
Statue of justice, gavel, and open book on table

Americans have rarely trusted their institutions less. In June, Gallup found average confidence in the 14 institutions it tracks was near a record low. Some 9% of the public trusted Congress, 27% trusted the Supreme Court, and 45% trusted the police. The criminal justice system, as a whole, ranked near the bottom.

Below those totals, however, lies a more telling story of divergence. Trust increasingly depends not on how an institution behaves, but on whether your side happens to run it. Republicans and Democrats each only have even a modest degree of confidence in Congress when their party is in control.


Some of that swing is inevitable in an elected body that translates political majorities into policy. But a floor exists beneath which partisan-contingent trust curdles into something more dangerous. And no institution is closer to that floor than the criminal justice system, which determines when a person loses their liberty and, in some cases, their life.

A voter whose candidate loses at the polls can gear up for a better result in the next election. But a defendant gets no do-over on an arrest, a bail hearing, or a sentencing. And a crime victim whose case is ignored or botched never gets justice. What the criminal justice system is supposed to answer, case by case, is a simple question: Will the same rules apply to me, no matter who is in power?

Increasingly, Americans are answering that question by team. In 2013, the year before an officer’s fatal shooting of a young Black man caused an uprising in Ferguson, MO, Republicans and Democrats were separated by just 9 points in their confidence in the police. That means Republicans were more likely to trust police, but not by a large margin. This year, however, Gallup put the gap at 45 percentage points, the widest ever recorded for a non-elected institution, and larger than the partisan gaps on the Supreme Court, big business, or the church.

The same lens now warps how Americans assess crime itself. Ninety percent of Republicans said crime had risen the year before Donald Trump returned to office even though it had declined; roughly half said the same the year after. Democrats moved in the opposite direction over the same 12 months, even as crime continued to fall.

Once justice starts to look like a team sport, the country loses something it will not easily rebuild: the shared conviction that the process is fair even when your side does not like the outcome. Two bulwarks undergird the system: the formal rules are largely fixed, and the informal rules are the fulcrum. Due process, the formal constitutional promise that the same procedures apply in every American courtroom regardless of who is in charge, is reasonably robust on paper. What varies far more, and what shapes whether the guarantee feels real, is procedural justice: how a person is actually treated by the officer who stops them, the deputy who books them, the parole officer who supervises their release. When the daily practice matches the paper guarantee, legitimacy holds. When it does not, even the strongest formal protections begin to look like scenery.

Decades of research on procedural justice converge on a core finding: How a case is handled matters to public confidence about as much as how it turns out. Americans who perceive the police and courts as fair are more likely to obey the law without the threat of force, report crimes, and cooperate as witnesses — the last of which is among the strongest predictors of whether a crime will ever be solved. One evaluation of a procedural justice training program at the Chicago Police Department found that it reduced both complaints against officers and use-of-force incidents.

Fair process depends on playing by the rules even when it costs you. Consider the exclusionary rule. Evidence obtained in violation of the Constitution may be relevant to a case, even damning, but the courts will — and should — throw it out anyway. The reason goes well beyond any particular case: The credibility of every future stop, arrest, and prosecution depends on the public believing the same process is used for every individual, regardless of the circumstances. When an officer explains why a person is being detained, follows the rules through a tense encounter, and treats that person with dignity, the person is more likely to see the outcome as legitimate, even if he or she disputes it.

Recent history in policing shows both the fragility and the promise of building that kind of trust. After George Floyd was murdered by a Minneapolis police officer in 2020, confidence in the police dropped to a record low of 43% in 2023 before rebounding to 51% in 2024 — the largest one-year jump Gallup has measured. Although causality is difficult to establish, over those years states passed hundreds of policing laws, and many departments banned chokeholds, required officers to step in when colleagues use excessive force, and joined shared online registries that flag officers who have lost their credentials for misconduct. Many of those policies were endorsed by the Council on Criminal Justice Task Force on Policing, which called for a national database of decertified officers, increased oversight, and formal training of officers in the principles of procedural justice that studies say can build public trust.

Research in jails and prisons documents a similar pattern. Facilities become safer, and rule-breaking decreases, when people behind bars perceive that grievances are addressed through clear, consistent procedures and when decisions are explained rather than just announced. Procedural justice inside those walls protects the people held there. It also protects everyone outside the prison gate by maintaining the system's credibility for anyone who might one day end up on the wrong side of a case.

The argument for reinforcing due process through procedural justice is never stronger than when confidence in the system largely depends on whether one’s own team is in power. A democracy can live with a Congress that many see as tribal; after all, voters get to hire and fire that group every two years. It has much less room to spare when Americans come to believe that whether they get equal treatment from a police officer, a prosecutor, or a judge depends on which side is holding the gavel.

Politics may continue to be about red and blue teams, but all Americans win when the justice system is a neutral zone where fairness prevails.

Marc Levin is Chief Policy Counsel for the Council on Criminal Justice. He previously developed the concept for the Right on Crime initiative at the Texas Public Policy Foundation.

Khalil Cumberbatch is Director of Engagement and Partnerships at the Council on Criminal Justice and a formerly incarcerated advocate who, as Associate V.P. of The Fortune Society in New York City, spearheaded efforts to help other former prisoners rebuild their lives.


Read More

​People hold signs supporting Salvadoran community

People hold signs supporting Salvadoran community

Photo provided

Two Months in Limbo: Salvadoran TPS Holders Await Clarity on Their Future

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Trump administration has quietly paused its plan to terminate Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for roughly 200,000 Salvadorans, opting instead to leave the program in an unresolved state of limbo past the September 9, 2026, expiration deadline.

- YouTube youtu.be

Keep ReadingShow less
​Protesters listen to speakers at a rally in support of a former Cornell University student known as Jane Doe

Protesters listen to speakers at a rally in support of a former Cornell University student known as Jane Doe at the Ithaca Commons on October 13, 2026 in Ithaca, New York.

(Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Sexual Violence Requires More Than Legal Accountability

In the wake of public attention to the Cornell fraternity alleged gang-rape, headlines resound with statements of concern and calls for greater accountability. These calls are not new. They have followed countless incidents of sexual violence, whether on a college campus, in connection with work, or within an intimate relationship. Despite decades of law and policy reform, sexual violence continues to run rampant. While law and policy reform are sorely needed, we will not see long-lasting change unless we address what accountability truly means. Our collective response should aim for a world where no one would ever think it was ok to commit, condone, or be a passive witness to sexual violence, never mind that it would be ok to send the kind of text messages that were allegedly exchanged at the Cornell fraternity where the rape allegedly took place.

As policymakers consider reform, a comprehensive approach to accountability should consider the known limitations of criminal and civil justice systems. Problems with the criminal legal system are legion, both within and beyond sexual violence cases. These include racially discriminatory application of laws criminalizing sexual violence, that, for example, have led to harsher punishment when the accused is a person of color and lesser punishment when the survivor is a person of color. Survivors continue to be doubted and subjected to biases and stereotypes, including that survivors lie about their experience, that they somehow invited the violence, or act with self-interest or ulterior motive when coming forward.

Keep ReadingShow less
A gavel.

From the Gilded Age to Citizens United, discover how recent Supreme Court rulings empower mega-donors, reshape party spending, and impact American democracy.

Getty Images, David Talukdar

Supreme Court’s Campaign Finance Rulings Help the GOP

American elections have always been dominated by moneyed interests. For instance, during America’s last Gilded Age, in the presidential election of 1896, William McKinley, the Republican candidate, outspent his Democratic challenger by $3.5 million (roughly $140 million in today's dollars) to $400,000 (approximately $16 million today). McKinley went on to win the election with the help of robber baron J.P. Morgan and monopoly Standard Oil. As the example shows, powerful special interests have often translated their vast economic power into political influence. But recent court decisions threaten to permanently entrench the financial imbalance between the Republican and Democratic parties.

In this light, the Republican National Committee’s (RNC) decision to transfer more than $50 million to beleaguered congressional campaigns across the country must be judged. The impact of this massive infusion of cash into the otherwise struggling Senate campaigns cannot be overemphasized. On the other side, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) cannot match the GOP’s deep pockets filled by the likes of Elon Musk. The Republicans, even before this deluge of special interest money, enjoyed financial advantages. The money is coming at a particularly pivotal moment in the campaign as Republicans find themselves electorally underwater due to Trump’s unpopularity.

Keep ReadingShow less
Close up of a judge hammering a gavel

Investigations, indictments, dismissals, convictions: what each means and the questions to ask before judging claims of political weaponization of the law.

Chris Collins/Getty Images

Just the Facts: Trump, DOJ and the Legal Process

The Fulcrum approaches news stories with an open mind and skepticism, presenting our readers with a broad spectrum of viewpoints through diligent research and critical thinking. As best we can, we remove personal bias from our reporting and seek a variety of perspectives in both our news gathering and selection of opinion pieces. However, before our readers can analyze varying viewpoints, they must have the facts.


The legal battles involving the Trump administration have become a constant feature of American politics and governance. Supporters often argue that many lawsuits and investigations are politically motivated attempts to block the administration's agenda. Critics contend that certain actions by the administration and the Department of Justice are themselves politically motivated or represent an improper use of government power.

Keep ReadingShow less