Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

What I tell my law students reversing Roe would mean for the rule of law

Opinion

Students protest for abortion rights

Students in New York City participate in a school walk-out and march to show their support for abortion rights and gun control on May 26.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Lawrence is an associate professor at the Emory University School of Law.

The leaked opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization has brought to mind Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s haunting question about what reversing Roe v. Wade would mean for the rule of law: “Will this institution survive the stench that this creates in the public perception — that the Constitution and its reading are just political acts?”

As a law professor, it was my job to try to answer this question for my students this semester. My short answer was “maybe.” My long answer comes through a series of eight things I tell my students when I teach the case.


First, I tell my students they can sit out if they need to and that abortion will not be on our exam. The underlying issue is so deeply personal and the analytical tools of legal analysis struggle to capture those stakes.

Second, I tell my students that what makes the abortion debate so fraught is that:

  • It puts important values in conflict (especially women’s equality and autonomy, on the one hand, and religious beliefs that life begins at conception, on the other).
  • It puts two underlying histories of oppression in conflict (the history of subordination of women and the history of religious intolerance).
  • We sometimes assume the worst in those who disagree with us (for example we might assume, rightly or wrongly, that a pro-life advocate does not care about women’s equality, or that a pro-choice advocate does not respect religious belief).

Third, I tell my students that the question for courts is not whether abortion should be a right or not, let alone whether it should be legal. Instead there are two legal questions before the courts: 1) Whether Roe and Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey were correct that women have a fundamental constitutional right to choose to have an abortion, and 2) if not, whether to reverse them despite stare decisis.

Fourth, I tell my students those two legal questions are difficult ones on which reasonable lawyers can probably disagree. How one sees those questions depends on how one sees hard underlying questions of legal philosophy and constitutional interpretation, and because the precedent (especially on stare decisis) is foggy. I also tell my students that this is just my judgment and that they should read the opinions in Casey to form their own.

Fifth, I tell my students that when justices and judges say that their views on the legal questions are determined by their views on the law, I believe them. I tell them that in my years of practice, clerking for a judge, and talking to many other lawyers, I have come to believe that almost all of the time, almost all judges are sincerely motivated by their good-faith view of what the law says. In other words, the rule of law is real and it really does constrain courts.

Sixth, I tell my students that abortion politics will probably determine the future of Roe even though jurists are individually guided by their good-faith reading of the law. This is because justices are picked by presidents and senators who have for decades chosen which lawyers to nominate to the Supreme Court with a laser focus on how they would rule on Roe. They have sifted through potential nominees’ writings and backgrounds for hints that their approach to reading the Constitution — motivated by good faith though it may be — would produce the outcome the presidents and senators want on Roe. Moreover, law school classrooms, legal scholarship, and the legal profession are also susceptible to external influence and biases in developing legal philosophies.

Seventh, I tell my students the potential success of presidents’ and senators’ effort to put jurists in place whose legal philosophy would lead them to overrule Roe would not mean that the rule of law is a farce. Yes, today’s justices may be pawns in a political game when it comes to abortion, making the good-faith legal judgments about Roe that presidents and senators predicted they would make when they nominated them. But this is an awkward mechanism by which politics may come to influence law in Dobbs.

Selecting jurists over time for the fit between their legal philosophies and politicians’ policy goals is a clumsy, hard to use, and slow tool of influence. In the case of Roe, it would have taken 50 years. Is it an important tool? Yes, incredibly important, especially from the perspective of a person suddenly deprived of a long-cherished right. But it is also a far cry from the court’s rulings being purely about partisan politics, or even being more about politics than about law.

This leads us back to Sotomayor’s question. The long version of my answer: Sotomayor is right to be worried that Dobbs could create the “perception … that the Constitution and its reading are just political acts.” If this view takes root then it could become self-fulfilling, even if initially mistaken, because the rule of law is like Tinkerbell — its strength depends on our belief in it. On the other hand, if people come to understand Dobbs as evidence only that with a lot of time, sustained attention and energy law can be influenced by politics in targeted ways, the blow need not be fatal. The answer to Sotomayor’s question depends in part, then, on whether we exaggerate the connection between law and politics at play in Dobbs.

For those focused on the profound personal stakes of Dobbs — for those worried about what the decision may mean for their bodies, and their rights — these questions about courts and norms may seem abstract and unimportant. Fair enough. I believe they are still worth time, energy and reflection. What the Supreme Court rules in Dobbs may now be beyond our control, but all of us can influence what the case comes to mean for the rule of law through the way we understand and talk about it.


Read More

two cars on a highway
Cars drive on a highway next to a river

Why Your Town’s Roads Run Through Washington: Unpacking Transportation Infrastructure Funding

Introduction

Access to reliable transportation is a critical part of most Americans’ daily lives. In 2022, Americans took an average of 2.28 trips per day, traveling 28.55 miles on average — figures including every mode of transportation and every purpose, for the full population. However, little attention is paid to transportation infrastructure until there are obvious problems like potholes or broken sidewalks linked to sharp decreases in road safety and quality of life for nearby residents. Given widespread reliance on transportation infrastructure makes examination of the governance structures underpinning its funding an important area of consideration.

Process-Shaping Priorities and the Federal Level

At the federal level, transportation infrastructure is primarily governed by the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT), an executive branch agency split into nine main operating administrations overseeing a specific part of the national transit system. USDOT then uses this oversight to distribute federal funding and ensure that individual transit outlets comply with national policy and safety standards. Distributed federal funding is drawn from the Highway Trust Fund, a dedicated federal fund financed through taxes on gas and other transportation costs, and distributed to states through formula-based approaches or competitive grant programs based on spending caps established by Congress. While federal funding plays an important role in transportation infrastructure, it only represents one-quarter of all public spending on roads and highways. The remaining three-quarters of long-term financing and associated maintenance is provided by state and local governments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol Building in Washington, DC
white concrete building under blue sky during daytime

The Public Is Demanding Ethics Reform. Will Congress Listen?

At the end of the 2026 midterm elections, “corruption” emerged as a central issue in the campaign. The public outrage had been building for years. In a September 2026 Gallup poll, 89 percent of Americans agreed that corruption is “widespread throughout the government,” an all-time high. Allegations that members of Congress use insider information for stock trading have become a common belief. Additionally, a raft of sexual harassment and sexual assault scandals has shed light on the inadequate protections in place for congressional employees. As the 120th Congress convenes in January, Congress must respond to this national cry for ethics reform in the legislative and executive branches.

Historically, Congress has always needed a scandal to act. The Honest Government and Open Leadership Act of 2007 – famously proclaimed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi as an act to “drain the swamp” – was passed as a result of the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal involving illegal gifts and favors to members of Congress. It appears the swamp was harder to drain than anticipated.

Keep ReadingShow less
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

America Adrift—Our Future Depends on Returning to American Principles and Standards

The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.

It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Getty Images

Who Benefits When the Process Fails?

In my previous article, I wrote about TK, a lawful permanent resident who has lived in the US for 61 years and now faces possible deportation. I questioned whether immigration enforcement could coexist with fairness, compassion, and respect for the lives people have built in this country.

Since then, I have learned something equally troubling. The legal proceedings are only part of the ordeal. What happens outside the courtroom can be just as devastating.

Keep ReadingShow less