In this episode of the Politics in Question podcast, the team discusses thermostatic politics to explain what it means and how it works.
Podcast: What is thermostatic politics?


In this episode of the Politics in Question podcast, the team discusses thermostatic politics to explain what it means and how it works.

New Hampshire Republican Senate candidate John Sununu accompanied by his wife Kitty, speaks to supporters at his primary election night watch party on September 8, 2026 in Manchester, New Hampshire
A familiar surname lets a candidate begin a campaign with part of the introduction already done. The difficult question is which introduction voters have heard. They may know the candidate’s record, trust a relative’s judgment, or have a different person in mind. Those possibilities can produce the same answer to a pollster while describing very different political choices.
New Hampshire’s Senate race makes the distinction unusually visible. John E. Sununu is a former senator whose father, John H. Sununu, and brother Chris both served as governor. Several careers enter a contest for one office through the same surname. The voters must decide how much of that accumulated reputation belongs to the man seeking their vote.
In CNN’s October 4 broadcast, Democratic opponent Chris Pappas alleged that signs omitting Sununu’s first name encouraged confusion with his brother. Sununu denied trying to confuse voters, saying he had used the same signs before and that his advertisements featured his face and voice. The exchange establishes a campaign dispute. It supplies no estimate of how many people mistake one brother for the other, or whether such an error changes their votes.
That distinction matters because the democratic objection to inherited advantage is broader than an accusation of confusion. A name can be recognized accurately and still give its bearer opportunities that a newcomer must spend years acquiring.
Familiarity can suggest that a candidate is viable before a voter knows much about the candidate’s positions. Political scientists Cindy Kam and Elizabeth Zechmeister found support for that mechanism in their 2013 study of name recognition. The effect diminished when voters received a more relevant cue, incumbency. The study identifies conditions under which recognition matters; it does not establish the electoral value of a particular family.
Other research cautions against assuming a universal effect. Experiments reported in a 2025 study by Costas Panagopoulos, Donald P. Green, and Philip Moniz, using actual challengers’ names, found little evidence that greater exposure increased support. Neither study directly measures the transfer of a family’s reputation between offices or generations.
A surname can carry substantive associations as well as familiarity. It may evoke constituent service, connections in a community, or a style of governing. A voter who understands the relationship and uses it to judge a candidate is making an inference. Whether that inference is sensible depends on how reliably the family connection predicts the candidate’s own conduct.
Mistaken identity is different. Crediting a former senator with his brother’s governorship attributes a record to the wrong person. Correcting the error improves the information available, even if it does not change the vote. The voter may still prefer the candidate’s party or actual positions. Describing every favorable family association as confusion would misunderstand the choice being made.
Journalists can help by asking what recognition contains. Has the respondent heard of the candidate? Which offices does the respondent believe he held? What decisions does the respondent expect him to make? A single recognition score compresses these questions into a number that cannot answer any of them adequately.
The larger issue is how political careers become available. In their research on political dynasties in Congress, Ernesto Dal Bó, Pedro Dal Bó, and Jason Snyder find that a longer period in power increases the likelihood of a legislator having a relative enter Congress later. Their analysis supports the conclusion that holding office can help reproduce political power within families. It does not identify which resource matters most in a particular contemporary race.
The possible resources are easy to recognize without treating their value as identical everywhere. A family may supply introductions to donors, experienced advisers, and local organizations. It can also convey knowledge of how to run. These advantages affect who can become a credible candidate before voters assess the final choices on the ballot.
This creates a problem that cannot be resolved by asking whether a particular descendant is talented. A capable heir may still enter a competition whose costs exclude equally capable people. Someone with no political relatives may need to earn a living while building the network that another person inherits. Formal permission to stand for office does not equalize those starting conditions.
The remedy should expand meaningful competition rather than make ancestry a disqualification. Parties can recruit beyond familiar networks, make their selection processes intelligible, and provide routes through which less connected candidates can acquire experience. News organizations can devote attention to what newcomers would do, rather than require prior fame as the price of coverage. Each measure has costs and cannot guarantee a more representative field, but it addresses the point at which inherited advantages become consequential.
Inherited reputation also creates an obligation for its beneficiary. A candidate invoking a family tradition of independence should explain what it would mean in the office being sought. A governor’s approach to state administration cannot determine a senator’s vote on a presidential nomination or an oversight inquiry. The family resemblance needs to be connected to an actual choice.
That obligation applies to candidates without famous relatives as well. Pappas also asks voters to trust a record and a claim to independent judgment. Both candidates should identify decisions on which citizens can test those claims. Disagreeing with party leaders becomes informative when a politician explains the action that follows and the costs he is prepared to accept.
These questions are more demanding than asking a candidate to promise independence in the abstract. They might reveal that a politician’s judgment differs from a relative’s in a way voters welcome. They might also show that an appealing family image obscures positions that deserve closer scrutiny. The purpose is to let voters make that assessment with the correct record before them.
Political families can carry useful experience across generations. Democracy needs room for that continuity and for people outside the family to compete. It also needs to keep credit and responsibility attached to the person exercising power. When several careers merge into one reputation, a candidate can inherit approval without inheriting responsibility for the decisions that produced it.
A surname can help voters recognize a political tradition. The candidate still owes them an account of the government he would help make.
Percy Yixuanchen Yu is the Inaugural Visiting Fellow at the School of International Studies, Nanjing University; a Visiting Scholar at the Huazhi Institute for Global Governance; and a Non-resident Fellow at the Institute of Campaign Finance.

U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche at the Robert F. Kennedy Department of Justice building on September 30, 2026 in Washington, DC.
The dust from the November 2026 midterm elections has barely settled, yet a familiar, toxic chorus of political warfare is already drowning out the clear message from American voters.
With Democrats securing majorities in both the House and Senate, voters signaled a desire for checks, balances, and a focused effort on the pressing economic issues squeezing everyday families. Instead, President Donald Trump has chosen to meet the incoming legislative branch not with an open hand, but with a weaponized Department of Justice.
Following the election, Trump issued a series of directives ordering the DOJ to investigate Democratic lawmakers, accusing them of "criminal acts" and "extortion" for simply fulfilling their constitutional duty of congressional oversight. Without offering any supporting evidence, Trump alleged in his post that Democrats were distributing "threatening letters to many people, all innocent."
Meanwhile, congressional members have publicly released several letters requesting documentation on issues like tech company contributions intended for the new White House ballroom project.
Attorney General Todd Blanche quickly fell in line, saying, “What we've seen over the past several days and even over the past several weeks are outright threats,” on CNN’s “State of the Union.” Blanche used the national television appearance to validate counter-investigations against political opponents whose rhetoric he deemed "vile and dangerous."The hypocrisy here is as blinding as it is dangerous.
For years, Trump and his supporters have weaponized the term "lawfare," crying foul at every legal proceeding, impeachment, and investigation, labeling them as partisan witch hunts. Yet, the moment the American electorate votes to shift the balance of power, the administration turns around and uses the literal apparatus of federal law enforcement to intimidate the incoming majority. When incoming House Oversight Chairman Robert Garcia tells the White House to "lawyer up" regarding administration activities, federal contracts, and mass firings, he is not committing a crime—he is doing the job the Constitution mandates and voters just demanded.
The leading Democrat on the House Oversight Committee promised Sunday to launch multiple investigations into Trump administration officials, saying Democratic leadership would no longer “take the high road.”
“When Republicans go low, what we’re not going to do anymore is just take that, take the high road, and turn the other cheek,” Garcia declared. “The days of us not fighting back are over.”This retaliatory escalation fundamentally rejects how a democratic government is supposed to function. Oversight is not extortion. Checks and balances are not criminal acts.
More importantly, this playground retaliation completely ignores the mandate of the midterm elections. Voters did not go to the polls demanding a never-ending cycle of mutual legal destruction. They went to the polls looking for solutions to economic anxieties, inflation, healthcare, and governance that actually functions.
Governing requires collaboration, especially in a divided Washington. It requires a willingness to sit across the table from political rivals, find common ground, and pass legislation that helps the American people. By using the DOJ as a personal shield and sword, Trump is poisoning the well before the new Congress is even sworn in.
If the Trump administration spends the next two years consumed by vengeance and retaliatory investigations, ordinary Americans will pay the price. It is time to drop the threats of prosecution, respect the constitutional role of congressional oversight, and get to work on the issues that actually matter to the people who cast their ballots last Tuesday.
Hugo Balta is the executive editor of The Fulcrum and the publisher of the Latino News Network

A lobbyist who worked for both Bernie Sanders and Fortune 500 clients explains what democratic socialist wins mean for business, and how to prepare.
In 2016, my political outreach company, Firehouse Phones, worked on the presidential campaign of a democratic socialist. It was one of many campaigns my firm touched, but that one stays on my resume for a reason: it taught me more about how persuasion actually works than any client engagement before or since.
Today I run Ohio River South, a government affairs firm focused on the nation's fastest-growing region — the American South. Over the past decade we've advocated for nearly two dozen Fortune 500 companies — Amazon in my earlier lobbying years, and later growing a client roster that included Alphabet, Microsoft, General Motors, United Healthcare, and Capital One.
During last week’s historic night for the Democratic Socialists of America, a record number of candidates endorsed by the DSA and its local chapters were elected to the House of Representatives. Socialists now count at least 6 members of Congress among their ranks, not including DSA-aligned candidates. Also, the newly-elected mayors of DC, LA,NYC and Seattle all identify with the party. In the aftermath of their wins across the country, I’m being asked by executives what it means for their future since I've been an advisor on the other team.
Here is the read I give corporate leadership — and the to-do list that follows from it.
Start with a clear-eyed definition, because the confusion is doing half the damage. Democratic socialists are not proposing that the government seize your company. They want the basics working people struggle to buy on the market — housing, health care, child care, transit, utilities — provided or guaranteed publicly, and they want to get there by winning elections. That's the descriptive half. Here's the other half, and boardrooms should take it seriously: the program includes rent freezes and expanded rent regulation, campaigns for publicly owned power, higher taxes on corporations and high earners, aggressive labor standards, and open hostility to the incentive packages that anchor corporate site selection. Mamdani's first hundred days show both the capacity and the limits — a childcare deal struck with Albany, a signature fare-free bus plan stalled for lack of state funding. No, this is not the Comintern, and companies that treat it that way end up negotiating with a caricature while the actual organizers register voters in their host county. But it is a disciplined movement whose agenda touches your rate base, your rent rolls, your labor costs, and your next incentive vote.
Next, size the exposure precisely — it's operational, not existential. The agenda lands on specific line items: rent regulation where you hold residential assets, public-power campaigns where you're the utility — or the data center driving its load growth — state-level corporate tax proposals, labor standards, and organized opposition to the subsidy deals that used to sail through commissions on a Tuesday afternoon. What changes for most companies is process. Entitlements take longer. Incentive votes draw opposition that shows up with spreadsheets. Community benefits agreements move from exotic to expected. None of that is fatal to a project — all of it is priceable, the way you price currency or interest-rate risk. The companies that fall behind in this moment aren't the ones facing the strongest opposition; they're the ones that mistook a priceable operating condition for an existential threat, and either overpaid in panic or stalled in denial.
Then run the affirmative playbook. What this movement does well reduces to a discipline any company can copy: show up, listen, and give people a way to say yes. In practice, five moves. Map political exposure the way you map rate exposure — every jurisdiction where a permit, variance, rate decision, or incentive vote is coming in the next twenty-four months, and who organizes there. Build presence before you need it: fund the rec league, join the community development corporation, be a known quantity two years before you're an applicant. When opposition forms, engage early and without lawyers, and send an operator with authority to trade rather than a spokesperson with talking points. Price a community benefits agreement honestly against the alternative — eighteen months of entitlement war, a moratorium, a ballot question with your project's name on it — and treat signing one as procurement, not surrender. And look inside your own walls: the under-35 cohort that now tells Gallup it prefers socialism to capitalism is also your junior workforce and your customer base. Build the same listening discipline internally — the company that hears its own people early is rarely ambushed in public. One more, for the board: political risk belongs on the enterprise risk register next to cyber and currency — reviewed quarterly, owned by an executive, not delegated to a PR retainer.
Finally, expect this everywhere you operate — not just where the headlines are. The temptation is to file this as a coastal story. It isn't. The energy travels wherever affordability bites, and it has already arrived in the region absorbing the corporate migration: the South — hundreds of relocated headquarters, the Battery Belt, a data-center buildout worth tens of billions in Georgia alone, in what my firm's new report, Accelerating South, documents as the country's largest economy and its least settled electorate. Atlanta seated its first democratic-socialist council member in January. Carrboro, North Carolina elected another. And the same energy shows up in Southern county commissions without the label — data-center moratoria, utility-rate revolts, anti-subsidy backlashes that cross party lines. A company could once dismiss a Brooklyn assembly race as somebody else's politics. It cannot dismiss the city council seating its next zoning vote.
People ask how I square the two halves of my resume. Honestly: I've stopped treating them as halves. The Bernie campaign fell short of the nomination — but it reached people the system had stopped hearing, and the organizing craft it modeled is exactly what's winning elections today. My corporate practice is, at its best, the discipline of making institutions listen before they're forced to. The failure mode on both sides is the same — mistaking your own talking points for the public's actual concerns — and so is the fix.
The democratic socialists are having their moment because they mastered a discipline the rest of American politics let atrophy. The companies that navigate it best won't be the loudest critics or the quietest bystanders. They'll be the ones that learned the same discipline — before the next rate case, the next site-selection fight, the next election in a county where they just bet a billion dollars. The people across the table learned to organize. The question is whether you did.
Howard Franklin is the founder and CEO of Ohio River South, a government affairs and political-risk firm that works across the South from offices in Atlanta and Washington, D.C.
On a Sunday night in August, Senator Jon Ossoff told a campaign rally in Atlanta that President Trump would rather build his ballroom and “travel with Natalie” than do his job. He never used her last name. He did not need to. Natalie Harp, the White House aide known to colleagues as Trump’s “human printer” for trailing him with a portable printer and transcribing his social-media dictation, had become a punchline before most Americans knew who she was.
The backlash arrived within hours. White House officials accused Ossoff of insinuating an affair; Republican Rep. Brandon Gill noted that Harp survived bone cancer only because the Right to Try Act, which Trump signed in 2018, let her seek an experimental treatment outside the normal approval process, and dismissed any other reading of the moment as unfair. Weeks earlier, Harp had been at the center of a far more consequential story: in July, she was one of a handful of aides, alongside the defense secretary and two senior staffers, chosen to accompany Trump on a covert switch of aircraft as he left a security summit in Turkey after officials detected a credible Iranian threat, while most of the traveling delegation stayed behind on a decoy plane. That is the real proximity Ossoff's line was needling. Then came a detail that complicated the story further: Trump had personally given Harp and several other aides cash gifts of $45,000 apiece, which a former federal ethics official called troublesome, since money on that scale can leave a recipient feeling indebted to whoever signs the check.
It would be a mistake to treat this as a story about one senator's bad night, or one aide's unusual devotion. It is a small, sharp example of something larger: a political culture that has grown almost incapable of processing loyalty that is not for sale.
A life interrupted, then rerouted
Harp has said publicly, including at the 2020 Republican convention, that she exhausted approved cancer treatments before the Right to Try Act let her request an experimental drug directly from a manufacturer. Whether the law has actually helped many people is genuinely disputed; a year after passage, only two patients had come forward to say they used it, and the FDA already approved more than ninety-nine percent of similar compassionate-use requests before the law existed. For one patient out of options, though, the statistics are beside the point. Her gratitude is the plain reaction of someone who believes a specific law kept her alive. Her own estranged brother, asked in a television interview about the intensity of her devotion, traced it back to values their mother instilled in the family, a small domestic echo of the same instinct now debated in the White House press room.
The pardon czar's complicated second act
Alice Johnson’s story runs on a similar track, with a more honest twist. Johnson served twenty-one years of a life sentence for a nonviolent drug offense before Trump commuted it in 2018 and later pardoned her outright; in February 2025 he made her his “pardon czar.” When Johnson helped secure this year’s pardons of reality-television stars Todd and Julie Chrisley, convicted of fraud and tax evasion, some of her own longtime allies in criminal-justice reform accused her of becoming a political token, lending her moral authority to pardons that had little to do with the nonviolent drug cases that made her famous. That criticism came from people who once considered her one of their own, which shows that unpriced gratitude can alienate even the community it is meant to represent.
The market price of leaving
Compare that with how Washington treats the opposite choice. Cassidy Hutchinson earned roughly seventy to ninety thousand dollars a year in the West Wing before testifying against her former boss's inner circle; within a year she had a book deal reportedly worth two hundred fifty to five hundred thousand dollars, and by 2026 her estimated net worth ran between three and five million dollars. Staff turnover itself is not the scandal; Brookings data shows Trump's senior staff turnover reached fifty-four percent by late August, close to Biden's forty-three percent and Reagan's fifty-seven percent at similar points in their terms. What is unusual is which departures pay off. A quiet exit earns nothing. A damaging story can out-earn years of government salary within months of publication. Loyalty that survives the paycheck carries none of that market value, so to a press fluent in tell-alls, it can look like a performance rather than the truth.
A reflex older than this administration
This is not one party’s habit. In 2012, conservatives mocked the Obama campaign’s “Life of Julia” slideshow, which followed a fictional woman benefiting from federal programs at each stage of her life; Paul Ryan called it creepy, and one prominent columnist labeled the government in it a “Sugar Daddy.” The target differed, a composite illustration rather than a real aide, but the reflex was the same one now aimed at Harp: suspicion toward any story in which a policy visibly improves a life, as if gratitude itself were proof of manipulation.
The trust deficit underneath it
That reflex has a measurable foundation. Pew Research has tracked a long collapse in Americans' trust in the federal government, from a peak of seventy-seven percent in the early 1960s to roughly one in five today. When trust in institutions falls that far, personal devotion to any single leader stops reading as ordinary human gratitude and starts reading as either naiveté or a transaction, because the press and the public have settled on no third category for it. Harp's printer, Johnson's place at the president's side, Hutchinson's book advance, all get sorted into one of those two bins, whether or not either one actually fits.
What the attacks actually signal
Targeting a low-level aide on a rally stage, or mocking a slideshow, is usually a tell about what a campaign would rather not discuss. The Ossoff-Harp exchange dominated coverage for days, far longer than his substantive criticism of the administration's Iran policy or the economy. Personal mockery travels faster than argument, and it costs a candidate nothing to deliver.
Harp, Johnson, Hutchinson, and Julia trace one line across two decades and both parties: a capital that prices almost everything struggles to believe in a debt that is not for sale. Repairing that blind spot will not fix Washington's polarization on its own, but it would remove one of its pettiest tics, the reflex to turn gratitude into a punchline before anyone has to reckon with whether it is sincere.
Meda Parameswara Reddy, Ph.D., is the Director of the Reddy Center for Critical and Integrated Thinking.