Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

The ideal democracy: An orchestra in harmony

Blurred image of an orchestra
Melpomenem/Getty Images

Frazier is an assistant professor at the Crump College of Law at St. Thomas University. Starting this summer, he will serve as a Tarbell fellow.

In the symphony of our democracy, we can find a compelling analogy with an orchestra. The interplay of musicians trained in different instruments, each contributing to the grand musical tapestry, offers lessons for our democratic system. As we navigate the complexities of governance, let us draw inspiration from the orchestra's structure, dynamics and philosophy.


At the heart of an orchestra lies the recognition that every member brings unique strengths, skills and interests. The violinist's nimble fingers, the trumpeter's powerful breath and the percussionist's precise timing each add a distinct flavor to the collective performance. Similarly, our democracy thrives on the diversity of its citizens. Each individual, with their unique perspective and expertise, enriches the democratic process. Whether it's the seasoned politician, the passionate activist or the engaged citizen, everyone has a role to play.

Embracing this diversity not only strengthens our democracy but also ensures that a wide array of voices is heard and valued. This is precisely why we should all be concerned with the fact that young voters are far less likely than their more seasoned neighbors to head to the polls. Our democracy is currently like a symphony without the strings section — we’re missing a lot of verve.

Sign up for The Fulcrum newsletter

In an orchestra, every member is given the opportunity to contribute to the whole. The clarinet's solo, the cello's harmony and the timpani's beat all weave together to create a unified sound. This principle is equally vital in a democracy. A functioning democracy provides platforms for all citizens to participate, be it through voting, community organizing or public discourse. Just as each instrument's contribution is essential to the orchestra's performance, every citizen's participation is crucial to the health of our democracy. Encouraging active engagement ensures that our democratic process remains vibrant and responsive to the needs of the people. Yet, many Americans miss opportunities to lend a hand in whichever way best aligns with their skills. Rates of volunteerism have been on the decline for more than a decade. We can and must make it easier for folks to get involved in their communities.

A good orchestra is characterized by frequent practice, mutual trust and adherence to the conductor's guidance. Musicians must trust their colleagues to play their parts with precision and commitment. Similarly, democracy requires continuous engagement, trust among citizens and respect for leadership. Elected officials must earn the trust of their constituents through transparency, accountability and effective governance. In return, citizens must actively participate and hold their leaders accountable.

Just as an orchestra depends on the conductor to lead with vision and skill, a democracy relies on leaders who can inspire and guide the collective towards common goals. This is another area for improvement. According to the Pew Research Center, just 37 percent of voters turned out for the 2018, 2020, and 2022 elections. Imagine listening to an orchestra in which 63 percent of the musicians missed one or more practices. You would likely notice some instruments out of tune and sections out of sync. The same goes for our democracy. We need citizens to take every “practice” seriously.

Finally, the best orchestras do not strictly adhere to the sheet music but find innovative ways to adapt songs to modern ears. They infuse classical pieces with contemporary interpretations, making the music relevant and engaging for today's audiences. Our democracy, too, must evolve and adapt to the changing times. This requires a willingness to innovate, to challenge outdated practices and to embrace new ideas. By fostering a culture of innovation, we can ensure that our democratic institutions remain robust and responsive in an ever-changing world.

Let us strive to build a democracy that resonates with the same beauty and complexity as a symphony. By learning from the orchestra's example, we can create a society where every voice is heard, every contribution is valued, and every individual is empowered to participate. In this way, our democracy can truly become a harmonious ensemble, working together to create a brighter and more inclusive future for all.

Read More

View over Harvard Yard of Harvard University.

View over Harvard Yard of Harvard University.

Getty Images, SBWorldphotography

Why Harvard’s Fight Is Everyone’s

The great American historian, Richard Hofstadter, author of the prophetic, “The Paranoid Style in American Politics,” (1964) wrote, “A university's essential character is that of being a center of free inquiry and criticism—a thing not to be sacrificed for anything else." Unfortunately, up until now, no great university has heeded these words when it came to challenging the Trump administration’s war on higher education and other key social institutions.

Harvard is finally standing its ground. As Trump escalates his campaign against higher education, President Alan Garber’s rejection of the White House’s outrageous demands is both overdue and essential. His defiance could mark the beginning of broader resistance to an agenda determined to reshape—or dismantle—America’s leading universities. This bold move could inspire other institutions to defend their autonomy and uphold the principles of academic freedom. But one question remains: why didn’t Columbia, or powerful institutions like the Paul Weiss law firm, take a similar stand?

Keep ReadingShow less
The African American Mayors Association holds its 11th annual conference, this year in Washington, D.C.

The African American Mayors Association holds its 11th annual conference, this year in Washington, D.C.

Imagine Photography, Heaven Brown

Job Cuts, Climate Threats, and the Power of Now: Black Mayors Seek Strength in Solidarity

WASHINGTON – Black mayors from across the country gathered in the nation’s capital for the annual African American Mayors Association Conference last week and strategized ways to govern their cities despite ongoing federal job cuts and recent actions coming from the Trump administration.

At the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, President Donald Trump conducted his second round of mass firings. Those who were not fired were told to go back to in-person work the same week in late March.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pope Francis and Democracy: Navigating Beliefs and Political Systems
person wearing white cap looking down under cloudy sky during daytime

Pope Francis and Democracy: Navigating Beliefs and Political Systems

Pope Francis is being remembered for his reformist stance that both challenged conservative elements within the Catholic Church and resonated with progressive movements. The 88-year-old Argentina-born pontiff passed away on Monday following a series of health complications.

The leader of the Roman Catholic Church often shared his perspectives on various societal issues, including the relationship between faith and democracy. His tenure as pope was marked by a commitment to social justice, human rights, and the dignity of all individuals, which naturally intersects with democratic ideals.

Keep ReadingShow less
Public Perspectives: Trump Presidency

U.S. President Donald Trump prepares to watch the Ultimate Fighting Championship at the Kaseya Center on April 12, 2025 in Miami, Florida.

(Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

Public Perspectives: Trump Presidency

Ahead of Election Day 2024, the Fulcrum launched We the People, a series elevating the voices and visibility of the persons most affected by the decisions of elected officials.

Now, we continue the series to learn if the Donald Trump administration is meeting the voters' motivations for voting in the 2024 presidential election.

Keep ReadingShow less