Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Beyond Campaign Promises, Congress Must Lower Healthcare Costs

Prevention, AI, and competition offer a path to more affordable care.

Opinion

Stethoscope lying on a pile of money

Medicare for All and price caps won’t fix healthcare costs. Two paths, better chronic disease control and more insurer competition, could.

Big Joe/Getty Images

Healthcare affordability has been a top issue heading into the midterms, with 62% of adults worried about affording medical care for themselves and their families, according to data from Kaiser Family Foundation.

On the campaign trail, candidates from both parties have promised relief. But come January, when the newly elected winners are sworn in, they’ll discover firsthand how much harder it is to enact change than to talk about it.


Why Popular Healthcare Solutions Fall Short

Progressive Democrats championed Medicare for All. Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed advocated replacing private insurance with government-financed coverage. KFF polling found two-thirds of American adults support the concept.

But expanding coverage through Medicare for All isn’t the same as making medical care more efficient or effective.

Currently, Congress authorizes the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to set Medicare reimbursement rates without negotiating with doctors or hospitals. Congress also limits how quickly those rates can rise. As a result, Medicare payments now average roughly 10% below hospitals’ reported expenses. To compensate for these federal underpayments, hospitals charge private insurers an average of 254% of Medicare rates, according to RAND.

If Medicare paid for all Americans' medical care at Medicare rates, hospital revenue would plummet while demand for medical services would remain unchanged. With 43% of hospitals already operating at a loss, these facilities would have to cut services or close.

Republicans generally prefer less government control, but several, including Senator Susan Collins (Maine), have also called for price caps. Recently, she championed bipartisan legislation that would limit privately insured patients’ monthly insulin costs to $35.

Price and spending caps have been tried before, with mixed results. Neither has addressed the underlying problems in how medical care is delivered. When reimbursement rates were capped in the past, providers increased service volume to maintain income. And when overall healthcare spending is capped without improving efficiency, backlogs develop and patients face longer waits for nonemergency care, as seen in Canada and the UK.

Two Ways To Improve The Economics

Annual U.S. healthcare spending now totals $5.7 trillion, more than the entire economy of Germany or Japan. In 2026, employer-sponsored family insurance premiums rose 5%, while inflation was 2.7% and wages grew 3.7%.

For a challenge of this magnitude, no simple, short-term solutions exist. Meaningful progress will require congressional action, with two promising paths forward. One would improve Americans’ health to reduce expensive, avoidable complications. The other would increase competition, encouraging insurers and providers to deliver better care at lower cost.

1. Reducing Costs By Improving Health

The biggest contributors to life-threatening, expensive inpatient care are complications from chronic diseases and obesity-related illnesses. Together they account for millions of heart attacks, strokes, cancers, and kidney failures each year.

Preventing chronic diseases and better controlling them when they develop would reduce the need for costly treatment by hundreds of billions of dollars. Two recent advances offer significant opportunities.

Affordable GLP-1 medications

After decades of disappointing weight-loss efforts, newer medications have produced impressive results. In major trials, semaglutide and tirzepatide produced average weight losses of approximately 15% to 21%, depending on the specific medication and dose.

But GLP-1 prices limit access. To make these medications more affordable for the 40% of Americans who are obese, Congress could amend the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act to allow lower-cost compounded versions when FDA-approved drugs are unaffordable. The change would extend certain drug-shortage exceptions to medications that are financially inaccessible, even when supplies are adequate.

Generative AI for chronic disease control

Prevention is paramount, but tens of millions of Americans will still develop chronic conditions. Today, fewer than half of Americans with hypertension or diabetes achieve recommended blood pressure or blood glucose targets, according to CDC data. More frequent monitoring and medication adjustments would help improve control.

A patient-facing GenAI system connected to home blood-pressure or blood-glucose monitors could track the data, identify inadequate responses to treatment and alert clinicians. Physicians could then adjust medications months before the next scheduled appointment, improving disease control and reducing the risk of costly complications, including heart attacks, strokes and kidney failure.

To provide this type of clinical support to all Americans, Congress and the Trump administration should launch an Operation Warp Speed-style initiative involving NIH, FDA, CMS, AI developers and clinicians. Together, they would build, validate, deploy, and monitor these affordable patient-facing tools for safety, reliability, and clinical effectiveness.

2. Lowering Costs Through Greater Competition And Improved Care

About 166 million Americans receive health insurance through employers, often with limited plan choices. The government can expand competition through an existing federal program.

Established in 2020, Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRAs) let employers fund coverage while workers choose the best plans for their families, including those on ACA exchanges. This option would give employers greater cost predictability and let them avoid selecting insurance plans for their employees.

Congress could strengthen the program with two changes.

First, give employees more options. Suppose a family receives a $20,000 employer allowance and chooses a qualifying $15,000 plan. New legislation could allow the remaining $5,000, subject to applicable limits, to go into an employee-owned, tax-advantaged Health Savings Account.

Second, require independently verified information on premiums, out-of-pocket costs, clinical outcomes, and access, so families can compare overall value between plans. Bringing more working Americans into individual insurance markets would attract more insurers and increase competition. Regional insurers could partner with local hospitals or capitated physician groups to offer affordable coverage built around coordinated care and better outcomes.

Greater competition would drive insurers to negotiate lower prices and reward efficient providers. Results would vary by market, but nationwide, the incentives would encourage more innovation and better value.

Both programs, one to improve health and one to increase competition, would lower medical costs. When the campaign ends, Congress must move beyond its promises and take steps to make American healthcare more affordable.


Robert Pearl, the author of “ChatGPT, MD,” teaches at both the Stanford University School of Medicine and the Stanford Graduate School of Business. He is a former CEO of The Permanente Medical Group.


Read More

a doctor showing a patient something on the tablet

Americans die younger than people in most wealthy nations. A new study says the cure is political will, and polarization may be what’s blocking it.

Photo by Nappy on Unsplash

America's Cold Civil War Is Shortening American Lives

Americans die younger than people in nearly every other wealthy democracy.

A study published in September by Steven Woolf of Virginia Commonwealth University traces America's mortality crisis. In 1980, only 13 countries with populations over one million had longer life expectancy than the United States. By 2023, 37 did. People in 60 countries now have a better chance of surviving to age 40.

Keep Reading Show less
Experienced nutritionist filling out a clients dietary questionnaire during consultations and meal plan presentation

HHS and the American Heart Association gave opposite dietary advice. Here’s a three-step test to separate real skepticism from cynicism.

J_art/Getty Images

Skepticism Isn't Cynicism. The Diet Wars Show the Difference.

This year, Americans got two opposite sets of instructions for the same dinner plate. Many of us responded the way we now respond to almost everything: we picked a team.

In January, the Department of Health and Human Services released new federal dietary guidelines built around red meat and full-fat dairy. Less than three months later, the American Heart Association issued guidance pointing close to the opposite way: build meals around plants and plant protein, choose unsaturated fats over saturated ones, and cut back on red meat and full-fat dairy.

Keep Reading Show less
Family at dinner table
A family eating chicken nuggets and watermelon at a table in a home
Photo by Tyson on Unsplash

Skepticism Isn't Cynicism. The Diet Wars Show the Difference.

This year, Americans got two opposite sets of instructions for the same dinner plate. Many of us responded the way we now respond to almost everything: we picked a team.

In January, the Department of Health and Human Services released new federal dietary guidelines built around red meat and full-fat dairy. Less than three months later, the American Heart Association issued guidance pointing close to the opposite way: build meals around plants and plant protein, choose unsaturated fats over saturated ones, and cut back on red meat and full-fat dairy.

Keep Reading Show less
Remote health
Doctor consulting patient via video call on laptop
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

AI Agents Could Save Lives—If We Let Them

The warnings about artificial intelligence keep getting louder.

The companies building the world’s most powerful AI systems are reporting troubling behavior from their own creations. And some of the researchers closest to frontier AI development warn that powerful new systems could “cause human extinction.”

Keep Reading Show less