Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Top Stories

Say a prayer for the pretender

Say a prayer for the pretender

Jackson Browne


Gijsbert Hanekroot
/ Contributor /Getty Images

It has been two months since we launched The (New) Fulcrum. At that time we committed to continuing coverage of news, politics, policy and public affairs as they relate to democracy and bridge building. We also committed to new coverage of culture, deepening and discovering our shared interests and common destinies, highlighting our similarities.

The response to our writings and videos that include all the creative arts has been overwhelmingly positive. Thank you.


As we continue to explore the connection of the arts to democracy, we realize that it is also an exploration of ourselves, of our dreams, of the changes that happen as the years pass by, of our place in our community, our nation and the world.

Yet so much of politics today is about competing narratives of the truth and alternate interpretations of how policies will be implemented. Those in power resort to intense lobbying to win the war of ideas; for the heart and soul of America. We are all caught up in a never ending cycle of dysfunction and tribalism that threatens our democracy.

But perhaps the most important thing we can do is to look away from the political circus and instead turn inward. It's vital to ask ourselves: What is our role in shaping the destiny for our children, our grandchildren and, yes, perhaps even our country? As I recently listened to "The Pretender," a song written over 45 years ago by American rocker Jackson Browne, I started this exploration for myself.

In a 1997 interview, Browne said of "The Pretender":

"It is two things at once. It's that person in all of us that has a higher ideal, and the part that has settled for compromise — like Truffaut says, there's the movie you set out to make, and there's the one you settle for."

Browne goes on to say:

"The Pretender is about '60s idealism, the idea of life being about love and brotherhood, justice, social change and enlightenment, those concepts we were flooded with as our generation hit its stride; and how, later, we settled for something quite different. So when I say 'say a prayer for the pretender,' I'm talking about those people who are trying to convince themselves that there really was nothing to that idealism."

These reflections by Browne from the Pretender ring true in this refrain:

I want to know what became of the changes

We waited for love to bring

Were they only the fitful dreams

Of some greater awakening?

I've been aware of the time going by

They say, in the end, it's the wink of an eye.

As you listen to Browne's The Pretender ask yourself if our nation is a macrocosm of what inevitably happens to us as individuals. Are the dreams of our nation fading away similarly to the fading away of our personal idealism? Has a national ethos of democracy, rights, liberty, opportunity and equality for all vanished as the realities of the political circus consume us all?

Or perhaps the idealism of E Pluribus Unum (out of many, one) has been replaced by belief in demagoguery. This adherence to political dogma demonizes our differences and causes us to refuse to believe people acting and deliberating in good faith could rationally differ from their vision of who we are as Americans, and make room for us all.

"Are you there? Say a prayer for the pretender, who started out so young and strong only to surrender"

Please share with us your ideas by writing to us at pop-culture@fulcrum.us.

Read More

Don’t Be a Working Class Hero — Just Imagine!

John Lennon’s “Imagine” comforts, but his forgotten songs like “Working Class Hero” and “Gimme Some Truth” confront power — and that’s why they’ve been buried.

Getty Images, New York Times Co.

Don’t Be a Working Class Hero — Just Imagine!

Everyone knows John Lennon’s “Imagine.”

It floats through Times Square on New Year’s Eve, plays during Olympic ceremonies, and fills the air at corporate galas meant to celebrate “unity.” Its melody is tender, its message is simple, and its premise is seductive: If only we could imagine a world without possessions, borders, or religion, we would live in peace.

Keep ReadingShow less
The Elephant in the Room’ Is a Rom-Com for Our Political Moment

The Elephant in the Room is available now to rent or buy on major streaming platforms.

Picture Provided

The Elephant in the Room’ Is a Rom-Com for Our Political Moment

Discerning how to connect with people who hold political views in opposition to our own is one of the Gordian knots of our time. This seemingly insurmountable predicament, centered in the new film The Elephant in the Room, hits close to home for all of us in the broad mainline Protestant family. We often get labeled “progressive Christians” — but 57% of White non-evangelical Protestants report voting for Donald Trump. So this is something we can’t just ignore, no matter how uncomfortable it is.

While the topic seems like a natural fit for a drama, writer and director Erik Bork (Emmy-winning writer and supervising producer of Band of Brothers) had the novel idea to bake it into a romantic comedy. And as strange as it might sound, it works. Set during the early days of COVID-19, the movie stars Alyssa Limperis (What We Do in the Shadows), Dominic Burgess (The Good Place), and Sean Kleier (Ant-Man and the Wasp).

Keep ReadingShow less
The Life of a Showgirl Bodes Unwell for Popular Feminism

Taylor Swift

Michael Campanella/TAS24/Getty Images

The Life of a Showgirl Bodes Unwell for Popular Feminism

Our post-civil-rights society is rapidly sliding backwards. For an artist to make a claim to any progressive ideology, they require some intersectional legs. Taylor Swift’s newest album, The Life of a Showgirl, disappoints by proudly touting an intentionally ignorant perspective of feminism-as-hero-worship. It is no longer enough for young women to see Swift’s success and imagine it for themselves. While that access is unattainable for most people, the artists who position themselves as thoughtful contributors to public consciousness through their art must be held accountable to their positionality.

After the release of Midnights (2022), Alex Petridis wrote an excellent article for The Guardian, where he said of the album, “There’s an appealing confidence about this approach, a sense that Swift no longer feels she has to compete on the same terms as her peers.” The Life of a Showgirl dismantles this approach. At the top of the show business world, it feels like Taylor is punching down and rewriting feminism away from a critical lens into a cheap personal narrative.

Keep ReadingShow less
Iguanas on the Tombstones: A Poet's Metaphor for Colonialism​
Photo illustration by Yunuen Bonaparte for palabra

Iguanas on the Tombstones: A Poet's Metaphor for Colonialism​

Iguanas may seem like an unconventional subject for verse. Yet their ubiquitous presence caught the attention of Puerto Rican poet Martín Espada when he visited a historic cemetery in Old San Juan, the burial place of pro-independence voices from political leader Pedro Albizu Campos to poet and political activist José de Diego.

“It was quite a sight to witness these iguanas sunning themselves on a wall of that cemetery, or slithering from one tomb to the next, or squatting on the tomb of Albizu Campos, or staring up at the bust of José de Diego, with a total lack of comprehension, being iguanas,” Espada told palabra from his home in the western Massachusetts town of Shelburne Falls.

Keep ReadingShow less