Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

The Quiet Rise of Employee Surveillance

Opinion

Sketch collage image of businessman it specialist coding programming app protection security website web isolated on drawing background.

Amazon’s court loss over Just Walk Out highlights a deeper issue: employers are increasingly collecting workers’ biometric data without meaningful consent. Explore the growing conflict between workplace surveillance, privacy rights, and outdated U.S. laws.

Getty Images, Deagreez

Amazon’s loss in court over its attempt to shield the source code behind its Just Walk Out technology is a small win for shoppers, but the bigger story is how employers are quietly collecting biometric data from their own workers.

From factories to Fortune 500 companies, employers are demanding fingerprints, palmprints, retinal scans, facial scans, or even voice prints. These biometric technologies are eroding the boundary between workplace oversight and employee autonomy, often without consent or meaningful regulation.


Everyone has to weigh data privacy decisions. Delete social media accounts for data privacy or be isolated from friends and family? Do a retina scan at the airport or risk being the uptight person who slows down security check?

But the questions are becoming way more existential, particularly as they invade the workplace. Workers now have to ask a totally different question: Forfeit data or forfeit income?

Because there’s no federal employment law that gives people the option to consent to biometric collection and use, employers can require employees to undergo scanning systems and other biometric applications.

This legal gap exists because, out of the 20 states with privacy laws that regulate private data collection, some still exclude data collected in employment contexts. So, biometric data protection is largely based on where employees live and work, workers’ rights firm Outten & Golden says.

This patchwork of legal protections is worsened by minimal regulation on corporate data collectors. Right now, companies only provide notices about their data collection and use of personal information: Notice and Choice. In this paradigm, people are shown tons of company privacy terms, but the density and legal jargon of those documents leave people bewildered.

And notices do not wholly cover the frontier of consent. As former Director of the Federal Trade Commission’s Bureau of Consumer Protection Samuel Levine stated back in 2019, “Even if we read the policies and understood them, we can hardly exercise choice given how much we rely on digital services, and the lack of competition in many markets.”

A 2023 Pew study backed up Levine’s statements, showing that 67% of Americans don’t understand and 73% believe they have little to no control over what companies do with their data. Clearly, most Americans are making uninformed decisions about the data they give up just to earn a living.

Now, combine that with no option to consent at all, and workers are being strong-armed into funneling their biometric data into a black box. Faced against the risk of being fired or staying unemployed, it becomes a no-brainer decision. Yet the ease of that decision is not a reflection of how much people actually value their personal data.

In a 2025 IPSOS poll, biometric data ranked fourth (32%) in the types of data believed to be most important to keep private. Only financial, health, and credit card usage data ranked higher.

Given this, employers should allow workers the option to indicate these privacy values through choice. Instead, the only two exceptions to bypass surrendering biometrics are religion or disability. That these are the only “outs” tells us that legislators either aren’t aware of, or don’t care about, the privacy preferences of everyday people.

Employers’ reasons for mandating biometrics include building security, tracking employee time and attendance, machine activation, and authenticating users. Because of this, privacy statutes have carveout defenses tied to security, fraud, and crime prevention.

Ironically, corporations’ interest in security stomps out employees’ right to secure their own data. As noted by the Wyoming Law Review in 2024, current case law ignores how an intrusion or breach of employee biometric data opens people up to limitless invasions of privacy in their personal lives.

This should not be the case. States and the federal government should enact laws that eliminate employment contracts that make biometric data a condition of employment. Given existing dubious consent practices, a new form of choice should become normalized: opt in or opt out.


Faith Wilson is a Public Voices Fellow on Technology in the Public Interest with the OpEd Project.


Read More

 Vintage Computer with AI Text on Screen and Neon Lighting, figures of people standing around it.

Calling AI “super” makes it sound omniscient. A faith leader coalition explains why the word “artificial” matters and what to do instead.

Royalty-free/Getty Images

Reject the Sand God. Call AI by Its True Name

President Trump recently signed an executive order telling federal agencies to replace the term "artificial intelligence" with "Super Intelligence." He said the word "artificial" makes the technology sound fake.

Many Americans already treat AI as a “super intelligence” that knows better and that they should confide in. Many already assign it the role of spiritual counsel, close confidante, or even romantic partner. In a Common Sense Media survey, one-third of teenagers claimed they had discussed serious personal matters with an AI instead of a person, and 31 percent said talking with an AI companion was as satisfying as talking with friends, or even more so. Bible Chat, an app that offers scripture-based advice and prayers, has been downloaded more than 30 million times.

Keep ReadingShow less
news video camera
black video camera
Photo by Matt C on Unsplash

When the Cameras Went Dark: What a Press Ban Reveals About American Journalism

When I came to the United States from India in 1982, I did not trust newspapers. Back home, everyone knew which party a paper favored before reading a line. American television felt different. My family watched Peter Jennings every evening, and later I found Larry King on CNN, who let his guests talk instead of telling viewers what to think. That habit of holding everyone to one standard has mostly faded.

On Sept. 18, President Trump announced he was banning CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House, saying their reporting was fake news. The next morning the Secret Service took reporters’ badges at the gate. The outlets sued on Monday, and Fox, ABC, NBC and CBS declined to take CNN’s turn in the television pool. On Sept. 24, Judge Timothy Kelly, whom Trump appointed, blocked the ban for 14 days. He found the outlets likely to win on due process, because reporters got no notice and no chance to respond, and he doubted the government’s national security explanation. Trump’s answer was to call the judge “totally disloyal.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman sitting and typing on laptop on her lap.

AI chatbots are always guessing, even when they sound sure. Experts and Claude itself explain the AI trust gap, bias and why to check sources.

Oscar Wong/Getty Images

AI’s Information Crisis: Why Trust Is Harder to Sustain Than Ever

In all the debates about human and machine intelligence, one thing has become clear: We humans love to talk about AI. We’ve speculated whether AI will create or eliminate jobs, revolutionize or destroy science, comfort or torment us, entertain us brilliantly or rot our brains, or some combination of all these things. But amid the noise, we may have paid too little attention to a subtler impact: how AI is disrupting our relationship to information and making it harder to know what to believe.

The problem isn’t just deepfakes, the malicious manipulation of images, video, and audio. Even benign, well-intentioned AI applications can be profoundly misleading. The nature of the large language models that power chatbots means that they are always guessing, however confident they seem. How can we use AI to produce reliable information that improves public discourse rather than distorting it?

Keep ReadingShow less
Digital illustration of robot's hand holding and supporting man who is working on his desk using computer, represent themes of artificial intelligence (AI), the future of work, and the intersection of humanity and technology.

Universal basic income would cost trillions. Wage insurance, a bigger child tax credit, and a tax break for work could help workers left behind by AI at a fraction of the price.

Andriy Onufriyenko / Getty Images

AI’s Costs: The Human Element & the Response

The age of AI will be a revolutionary age. In medicine, engineering, and more, there is the possibility of great benefit to humanity. Consider some Wall Street Journal headlines: “The Quest to Use AI to Help Find New Drugs,” and “Fusion Startup Gets an AI Boost.” Already, AI is a substantial portion of GDP growth.

Yet a rising tide will not lift the boats with holes in their hulls, as Jack Kemp once said. Artificial intelligence is challenging our leaders to think about those possibly left behind. Within the AI community itself, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei expresses concern that we could see 5-10% GDP growth with 10% unemployment.

Keep ReadingShow less