Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Concerns Rise as States Opt In to National Voucher Plan

News

Concerns Rise as States Opt In to National Voucher Plan
boy in green sweater writing on white paper
Photo by CDC on Unsplash

WASHINGTON — Cris Gulacy-Worrell used to call herself a “public school purist,” openly advocating against school voucher programs in the early 2010s. Then she founded Oakmont Education, a network of charter schools in Ohio, Iowa and Michigan, designed to help students who have dropped out of high school earn their diplomas and secure jobs.

Now she describes herself as “pro-school choice” and wants to see change in the K-12 education system.


“I think, for far too long, we've treated students and families like they are not in the driver's seat and we've told them to wait,” Gulacy-Worrell said. “A lot of our students have been given the ugly side of what education's supposed to be about, the intolerance side, the side that was designed to fail them. The system is really broken, and we can’t band-aid it.”

Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, the Trump administration made sweeping changes to K-12 education, which is now playing out across the nation as governors in 27 states have opted into the first national school voucher policy, the Educational Choice for Children Act (ECCA).

Beginning in 2027, the policy, structured as a federal tax-credit program, will allow private donors to write off up to $1,700 in donations to scholarship-granting organizations per year, funding private school tuition for qualifying families.

The scholarships will be available to families earning up to 300% of their area’s gross median income, a threshold that can reach $300,000 in higher income regions. Families who already send their children to private schools are also eligible for the voucher.

Sasha Pudelski, the director of advocacy for AASA, the school superintendents association, which represents public school district leaders, said the school voucher program would have a tremendous impact on public schools across the nation, leaving them underfunded and with the most disadvantaged students.

“We’re funding two different systems,” Pudelski said. “We’re simply subsidizing the kids that are already, for the most part, attending private school, and now just paying a tuition discount essentially for them.”

Of the states that have opted into the ECCA program thus far, they are primarily run by Republican governors, Pudelski said. She said that AASA is fighting to defend public schools from the effects of routing public dollars to private schools, which causes public schools to lose funding and students.

“Our advocacy has to be focused particularly for states that have never had any kind of funding going towards private schools before, keeping the funding out of those places because opening the door can lead to a lot of serious financial impacts for public education,” she said.

Several of the states that have accepted ECCA already have school voucher programs in place. Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) operate in over 15 states, giving state education dollars directly to families to pay tuition to a school of their choice.

Pudelski said that the two states with the largest ESA programs, Arizona and Florida, have shown that voucher programs divert funding from public schools. She said that roughly 80% of the students receiving ESA vouchers were already paying for private school tuition.

Geneva Fuentes, of the Arizona Education Association, the state's largest public school educators' union, said the ESA program has caused Arizona to sink to 48th in the nation in per-pupil spending on public schools. She said the program has led to schools across the state closing and students going without the resources they need.

“We've seen that outreach from the proponents of the ESA program has been primarily targeted at wealthier and whiter families, and that's primarily because you have schools here in the Phoenix area that cost $20,000 a year, and the average voucher is a little bit more than $7,000 and so they're targeting families that have enough wealth to fill that $13,000 gap,” Fuentes said.

Bill Mattox, senior director for the Marshall Center for Education Freedom at The James Madison Institute in Tallahassee, Fla., is a proponent of ESA and said the program’s success inspired the creation of ECCA.

“Our experiment in this, along with that of a number of other states, has caught the attention of national leaders, and they're saying, ‘Hey, we really ought to try to do something like this nationwide,” said Mattox. “With ESA, families can take the pot of money that would have otherwise been spent on their student in the public schools and break it up and use it however they see fit for educational purposes. That gives them a lot more flexibility.”

Mattox said that for states with existing ESA programs, the ECCA would “stack on top of them.”

Both advocates for and against voucher programs tout representing voters' interests. Approximately 65% of voters repealed Arizona’s legislature’s first attempt to enact a universal voucher in 2018.

“Four years later, Arizona lawmakers then went ahead and overrode the will of the voters and established a universal voucher program, which is now costing the state more than a billion dollars a year in taxpayer funds,” Fuentes said.

Gulacy-Worrell said polls show that 84% of parents are “pro-school choice.”

Educators and school administrators not only disagree on whether American families support school vouchers, but also clash over competition in the education sector and whether public tax dollars should be used to fund private and parochial schools that are not subject to the same federal regulations as public schools.

Kyle Smitley is the founder and executive director of the Detroit Achievement Academy and Detroit Prep, both small non-profit public charter schools. She said that, generally speaking, public charters oppose the ECCA because they fear their students would receive scholarship dollars to attend a private school and leave their public charter model.

Smitley said she hasn’t seen the quality of K-12 education improve with increased competition.

“I'm not sure that I've seen that, a random third-grade teacher at DPSCD (Detroit Public Schools Community District) teaching harder because she heard that there was a good school opening up a couple of blocks away. Like, that teacher was still teaching hard. And there are other systemic things, maybe in that teacher's way and in the family's way of the people who go there,” Smitley said. “Getting it right for kids is definitely deeper than the concept of a McDonald's versus Burger King competition economic study.”

Pudelski said that she didn’t think the goal of ECCA was to create competition.

“I think it's coming from billionaires who want to fund primarily religious education,” she said.

The only way to stop “publicly funding discrimination in private schools,” she said, would be to prohibit discrimination on the basis of religion, disability, sexual orientation, and more, in all schools receiving taxpayers' money.

Gulacy-Worrell said concerns with voucher programs allowing discrimination are distractions from the real issue of students not receiving an adequate education to begin with.

“These districts that are failing kids were drawn to fail them,” she said. “We know it, we admit it, and school choice, particularly public charter schools, is the antidote to those red lines.”

She said that the new school voucher programs get “something moving for outcomes” for students and families, particularly those who’ve been historically excluded or marginalized.

However, Pudelski said that ECCA could be particularly harmful for rural students who rely on their area’s public school.

“It would lead to rural school closures in some cases, if suddenly they went from a school with 200 kids in it, K through 8, to 170,” she said. “That could be enough to make it financially nonviable for them to keep their school open.”

An alternative to school voucher programs is allocating more money to publicly accountable public schools, Pudelski said. She emphasized the need to fund public schools' special education programs, especially because private schools can turn away students with disabilities.

The effects of the ECCA on K-12 education in America, including academic outcomes, admission discrimination, public school closures and more, remain to be seen. Both Republican and Democratic governors will continue to announce their states' decisions to adopt or reject the program until it begins to take effect on Jan. 1, 2027.

“There has been a nationwide school choice movement that has a lot of money behind it, that has pressured lawmakers to override the will of voters, not just in Arizona, but in other states,” Fuentes said. ”We should have concerns anytime money that could go to support the majority of children who attend public schools is instead diverted to private hands.”

Cate Bouvet covers education for Medill on the Hill.


Read More

A person reaches for a book on a shelf in a library.

A daughter of Cultural Revolution survivors argues U.S. school book bans are about power, not protection, and how a freedom-to-read law offers a way forward.

LAW Ho Ming/Getty Images

My Parents Lived through a Book Ban. Americans Should Demand the Freedom to Read.

At the start of this school year, a Texas schoolteacher from my home school district went nationally viral. In a video, Darius Williams sobbed as he explained that after he “gave them the answers,” his high school seniors still could not complete an exercise comprising two sentences to read and one to write. Reading scores in the country currently languish at a twenty-year low. In the new year, a historic set of new state lawmakers around the country should prioritize reversing ineffective policies that have kept critical reading materials out of school libraries.

Since 2021, book bans have reached a level “never before seen in the life of any living American” (34,000 total in public schools across the country, according to PEN America). Some institutions are even preemptively removing materials to avoid controversy, a phenomenon termed “soft censorship.”

Keep ReadingShow less
U.S. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth stands for anthems at the Pentagon on October 15, 2026 in Arlington, Virginia. The two defense officials discussed NATO financial commitments by European countries.

Hegseth’s order ending tenure at the service academies punishes scholars and leaves future officers less prepared for war. Here’s why Congress should step in.

Finn Gomez/Getty Images

Secretary Hegseth's Tenure Ban Fails Our Officers and the Academy

Yesterday, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth fired another round of shots in his war on higher education, and once again he fought it in his own backyard. After pulling books off the shelves of the Naval Academy and cutting the Pentagon’s ties to graduate programs at Harvard and Princeton, he signed a memo ordering the service academies to stop granting tenure to civilian professors, effective immediately. Tenure, he wrote, breeds “academic stagnation, faculty complacency,” and belongs to a broader academic structure that serves to “dilute our focus on lethality.” This assault on the academy is a mistake, both wronging the scholars who teach at the academies, and leaving the cadets and midshipmen who learn from them less prepared for war.

In his depiction of the tenure system's shortcomings, Hegseth mischaracterizes it as a finish line, where receiving tenure marks the moment a professor stops running. Granted, there is a grain of truth here: a study of over 12,000 American faculty members published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that in non-lab-based fields like political science and sociology, publication rates do fall once tenure is secured. Lab-based fields, meanwhile, sustain high research output. More importantly, however, the same study found that after receiving tenure, scholars turn toward newer, riskier questions, also known as the kind that occasionally transforms a field.

Keep ReadingShow less
Students in a classroom.​

Civics is a practice, not a quiz. See how immigrant and Indigenous communities are teaching schools to build, not blend in, as America turns 250.

Getty Images, andresr

Schools Can’t Teach Democracy Without Valuing Students’ Lived Experiences

Recently, I gathered with a group of dads outside Philadelphia to clear out a neighborhood park through Dads for All, the organization I co-founded. Some of us grew up in that neighborhood, some had never set foot in it, and plenty of us had no idea what we were doing. Our kids, ages three to seventeen, hauled branches and swung tools nearly as long as they were tall — and they were delighted.

Here's what I watched them figure out: A park is where a kid gets to be free. It's where you run, where you pretend to be a superhero, where the ground belongs to you. And you assume it just shows up. That morning, our children learned that it doesn't. Somebody has to see what it could be. Somebody has to partner with the people who own it and the people who use it. And then somebody has to pick up the loppers. That was the most honest civics lesson my son has ever had, and unfortunately, that is where the problem is.

Keep ReadingShow less
The Window to Safely Managing the Education Freedom Tax Credit is Closing Fast
Empty wooden tables and chairs in a library with shelves of books
Photo by Tuyen Vo on Unsplash

The Window to Safely Managing the Education Freedom Tax Credit is Closing Fast

There is a major change in how students, schools, and educational programs can be funded, taking effect on January 1, 2027, with a small window of time to ensure the program is well managed. We have to move fast.

The Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC) creates a new federal tax credit for taxpayers who make qualified contributions to approved nonprofit Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs). SGOs, in turn, use that money to award scholarships for tutoring, tuition, or other qualified education expenses for students, regardless of whether they attend public, private, or charter schools. The money is contributed directly to SGOs by taxpayers, who can receive a dollar-for-dollar tax credit on their 2027 tax filing, up to $1,700 for individuals and $3,400 for married taxpayers filing jointly.

Keep ReadingShow less