Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Hollywood Gets Congress Wrong—and It’s Costing America Trust in Democracy

Opinion

Hollywood Gets Congress Wrong—and It’s Costing America Trust in Democracy

Hollywood sign and The Capitol

AI generated picture

The following article is excerpted from "Citizen’s Handbook for Influencing Elected Officials."

Since the 1970s, public trust in American institutions—including Congress—has steadily declined. Approval ratings for the House and Senate usually hover in the teens. Certainly, some misdeeds by our elected leaders have contributed to this decline, and mainstream national media can claim its fair share of “credit” in portraying Congress in a negative light. Yet another major ingredient in the ugly formula poisoning public opinion of Congress is Hollywood. Movies and TV shows routinely portray Congress as craven, corrupt, selfish, and completely indifferent to the public interest. Regrettably, this is a wholly incorrect portrayal of our nation’s legislators.


Some years ago, Amazon premiered a TV show, Alpha House, loosely based on the true story of four male members of Congress living as roommates in a Washington, DC home. In one scene, a freshman senator agrees to provide a ride to a colleague to visit the home as a prospective new roommate. The senator arrives at the Senate office building in a limousine, drinking champagne with his mistress at his elbow. The truth is, the only people who would ride in a limo in Washington are Hollywood types, visiting for some black-tie dinner. Members of Congress are scrupulous about appearances and would never be caught on camera emerging from a fancy car.

There are many things Hollywood gets wrong about Washington; here are a few.

What Motivates Congress? While there are certainly self-interested jerks who attain public office, most of Congress is comprised of decent, hardworking public servants. A few years ago, a national polling firm asked Americans if they agreed with this sentence: “Most members of Congress care what their constituents think.” Only 11 percent of Americans agreed with that statement (which is probably a scarier number than Congress’s low approval rating, since the governing class listening to those they govern is pretty much the bedrock of our democracy). However, in a survey in which members of the U.S. House were asked to rate the most important aspects of their job, 95 percent said “staying in touch with constituents.” Members of Congress view it as both their political and moral responsibility to be accountable to their constituents.

How Members of Congress Live. In 1994, not long before he was about to make history as the first speaker of the House of Representatives in 130 years to be ousted in a re-election bid in his home congressional district, Speaker Thomas S. Foley (D-WA) watched a focus group of constituents. The facilitator asked voters in eastern Washington about their congressman's life. An ironworker described what he thought dinner would be like at a congressman’s house: a limousine would take him to a mansion in Georgetown, and he would be served a sumptuous meal, eating foods the constituent would not recognize and using utensils the average person would not know how to use.

Foley was stunned. The gap between the constituents’ perception and the reality of his daily routine was shocking. He was probably remembering the tuna sandwich he wolfed down for lunch earlier that day, snuck in between 13 meetings over a 14-hour stretch—a common schedule for him and for most members of Congress. While members of Congress are paid more than the average American family, they must maintain two households. Some even sleep in their offices because they cannot afford the steep rent in metropolitan Washington. I once had a most amicable conversation with the House Minority Leader as he was shopping for vegetables at a Washington grocery store. Most members of Congress are a lot more like the head of a typical American family, just trying to balance the challenges of an incredibly hard job with raising a family.

While some fictional portrayals of Congress have captured Washington accurately, most get it wrong. Former Washington Post White House correspondent Juliet Eilperin penned a wonderful rebuttal to the cynics who revel in distorting Washington. “Many journalists and the officials they cover moved to this town because they care about the ideas and the policies that help shape the world we live in. … It’s why my parents moved here nearly half a century ago, and it’s why I have stayed.” I’m not saying that the American public does not occasionally send a Frank Underwood to Congress (the devious politician from House of Cards). That doesn’t change the perhaps boring truth: the vast majority of members of Congress are solid public servants who sacrifice much for their districts, states, and nation.

Bradford Fitch is the former CEO of the Congressional Management Foundation, a former congressional staffer, and author of “The Citizen’s Handbook for Influencing Elected Officials."


Read More

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez

Photo provided

Edwin Martinez: Latino Muralist Brings Color to Rural Nevada

Vibrant murals with warm, sunlit colors scatter the Reno, Nevada landscape.

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez brings his heritage and Latinidad to his murals through recognizable, bright colors. One such piece is “Raíces Brillantes,” a mural painted outside the Latino Research Center at the University of Nevada, Reno.

Keep ReadingShow less
Dolly Parton performs on stage, holding a white, bedazzled guitar.

Dolly Parton performs on The Pyramid Stage on Day 3 of the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm on June 29, 2014.

Shirlaine Forrest/Getty Images

Dolly Parton and the America We Keep Forgetting We Can Be

At a time when many Americans are retreating into rigid identities, Dolly Parton has been one of the few public figures able to speak to every corner of America. She had appeal across the board, no matter whether people were from the rural areas, the cities, the evangelical groups, or the gay community. She was not simply loved; she was trusted too. And in these deeply polarized times we are living in, trust is in desperately short supply.

For sixty years, Dolly Parton has stood as an example of the kind of pluralism based on dignity that our politics has lost and that many people have sadly rejected. She never preached her beliefs and seldom, if at all, talked about politics. Instead, she showed through her life how one can respect one's roots without using them as weapons. Dolly welcomed diversity without fear, and built bridges without ever giving a speech on bridge-building. Because she lived out the beliefs she sang about, she became one of America's most effective advocates for dignity.

Keep ReadingShow less