Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

A Constitutional Provision We Ignored for 150 Years

Opinion

Voter registration in Wisconsin

Voter registration in Wisconsin

Michael Newman

Imagine there was a way to discourage states from passing photo voter ID laws, restricting early voting, purging voter registration rolls, or otherwise suppressing voter turnout. What if any state that did so risked losing seats in the House of Representatives?

Surprisingly, this is not merely an idle fantasy of voting rights activists, but an actual plan envisioned in Section 2 of the 14th Amendment, which was ratified in 1868 – but never enforced.


Constitutional rights often exist without clear enforcement mechanisms, but attorney Jared Pettinato thinks he’s found one. He’s filed a lawsuit against the United States Census Bureau, aiming to require it to enforce Section 2. I follow the case in my documentary, FOURTEEN SECTION TWO, now in post-production. Check out the trailer below.

As you can tell, Pettinato wants to make Section 2 an active part of the Constitution. But why did it become inactive in the first place? To answer that question, we need some additional historical context.

Most of us know about the 14th Amendment because of Section 1, which enshrined birthright citizenship, due process, and equal protection within the Constitution. But for the framers, Section 2 was potentially more important because it aimed to ensure that newly emancipated Black men in the South would be able to vote – and by doing so, keep in power the Republican party that won the Civil War.

Section 2 begins by stating, “Representatives shall be apportioned among the several States according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each State.” It’s not obvious from the text, but this provision abolished the notorious Three-fifths Compromise from the original Constitution. With the adoption of the 14th Amendment, Black people would be counted in full for the purposes of Congressional apportionment.

The framers had a problem, though. Because the South’s full Black population would now be counted, the Confederate states would re-enter the Union with more representation in the House than they had before the Civil War. If former Confederates remained in power in those states, they would suppress the Black vote and then reassert their dominance over the national government.

The Republicans could not abide this possibility, but at the time, they didn’t have the votes for the obvious solution — prohibiting states from denying citizens the right to vote on the basis of race. That would come later in the 15th Amendment.

Instead, they developed a rather convoluted solution in the rest of Section 2. The states would be allowed to abridge or deny the vote as they wished, but there would be a penalty for doing so. If, say, 10% of potential voters could not vote, then the state’s population would be reduced by that same 10% when seats were apportioned in the House. A state could therefore wind up with fewer seats than it would normally be entitled to.

No state would risk such a penalty, which would make Section 2 a strong safeguard of voting rights. But when Congress attempted to enforce Section 2 in the 1870 census, it quickly became clear that it was nearly impossible to gather reliable data about voter denials and abridgements. As enthusiasm for Reconstruction waned, Congress made even less effort to enforce Section 2. It remained in the Constitution as a dead letter. And it mostly stayed that way until 2022, when Jared Pettinato brought his lawsuit.

The lawsuit and the Section 2 background raise many questions. Most obviously, how does a section of the 14th Amendment, a part of “the highest law in the land,” go unenforced for more than 150 years? Is the strange history of Section 2 a quirk or a canary in a coal mine, warning us that something has gone wrong with our Constitutional order?

This is perhaps a more relevant question than I would like it to be. But there’s no denying that much of what we took for granted in the Constitution is up for debate. Everything from freedom of speech to the right to bear arms to birthright citizenship to due process seems less certain than it was not long ago. Perhaps we’ve believed that the Constitution guaranteed us rights because of the words on the page or the orders of a court. But it’s now clearer than ever that the words and the orders relied on a system that may be breaking down.

With so much at stake, why make a film about a part of the Constitution that everyone had pretty much agreed to forget? I think reviving a debate about Section 2 of the 14th Amendment is good for us. It forces us to think about what rights we really want to have and what we need to do to secure them. Clearly, just writing them down is not enough.

When our current crises pass, we cannot simply return to the status quo ante. There are moments in our history that force a rupture in and reimagination of the Constitution. Reconstruction was one. Now may well be another. I hope that studying the history of Section 2 might help us learn from the past, navigate this moment, and find something better on the other side.

A film is a unique way to make that effort. It takes Constitutional questions out of the abstract and makes them real for a wider audience. If you’d like to be a part of the journey, you can subscribe to my newsletter.

A Constitutional Provision We Ignored for 150 Years was first published on the Substack channel, Expand Democracy and was republished with permission.

Todd Drezner is a documentarian, producer, and writer.


Read More

two cars on a highway
Cars drive on a highway next to a river

Why Your Town’s Roads Run Through Washington: Unpacking Transportation Infrastructure Funding

Introduction

Access to reliable transportation is a critical part of most Americans’ daily lives. In 2022, Americans took an average of 2.28 trips per day, traveling 28.55 miles on average — figures including every mode of transportation and every purpose, for the full population. However, little attention is paid to transportation infrastructure until there are obvious problems like potholes or broken sidewalks linked to sharp decreases in road safety and quality of life for nearby residents. Given widespread reliance on transportation infrastructure makes examination of the governance structures underpinning its funding an important area of consideration.

Process-Shaping Priorities and the Federal Level

At the federal level, transportation infrastructure is primarily governed by the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT), an executive branch agency split into nine main operating administrations overseeing a specific part of the national transit system. USDOT then uses this oversight to distribute federal funding and ensure that individual transit outlets comply with national policy and safety standards. Distributed federal funding is drawn from the Highway Trust Fund, a dedicated federal fund financed through taxes on gas and other transportation costs, and distributed to states through formula-based approaches or competitive grant programs based on spending caps established by Congress. While federal funding plays an important role in transportation infrastructure, it only represents one-quarter of all public spending on roads and highways. The remaining three-quarters of long-term financing and associated maintenance is provided by state and local governments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol Building in Washington, DC
white concrete building under blue sky during daytime

The Public Is Demanding Ethics Reform. Will Congress Listen?

At the end of the 2026 midterm elections, “corruption” emerged as a central issue in the campaign. The public outrage had been building for years. In a September 2026 Gallup poll, 89 percent of Americans agreed that corruption is “widespread throughout the government,” an all-time high. Allegations that members of Congress use insider information for stock trading have become a common belief. Additionally, a raft of sexual harassment and sexual assault scandals has shed light on the inadequate protections in place for congressional employees. As the 120th Congress convenes in January, Congress must respond to this national cry for ethics reform in the legislative and executive branches.

Historically, Congress has always needed a scandal to act. The Honest Government and Open Leadership Act of 2007 – famously proclaimed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi as an act to “drain the swamp” – was passed as a result of the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal involving illegal gifts and favors to members of Congress. It appears the swamp was harder to drain than anticipated.

Keep ReadingShow less
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

America Adrift—Our Future Depends on Returning to American Principles and Standards

The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.

It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Getty Images

Who Benefits When the Process Fails?

In my previous article, I wrote about TK, a lawful permanent resident who has lived in the US for 61 years and now faces possible deportation. I questioned whether immigration enforcement could coexist with fairness, compassion, and respect for the lives people have built in this country.

Since then, I have learned something equally troubling. The legal proceedings are only part of the ordeal. What happens outside the courtroom can be just as devastating.

Keep ReadingShow less