Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

What HBO’s The Pitt Gets Wrong About AI — and What Medicine Misses

Opinion

What HBO’s The Pitt Gets Wrong About AI — and What Medicine Misses

Actor Noah Wyle plays Dr. Michael "Robby" Robinavitch in the HBO drama: The Pitt

Generative artificial intelligence has already reshaped industries such as computer programming, retail, and manufacturing. In medicine, however, fears of clinical error have slowed adoption.

At present, two-thirds of doctors report using GenAI tools in practice, though half insist that stronger safeguards are needed.


This split — between physicians eager to adopt AI and those wary of its risks — took center stage in a recent episode of HBO’s The Pitt, set in a fictional Pittsburgh emergency department.

In the episode (titled “8:00 A.M.”), protagonist Dr. Michael “Robby” Rabinovitch is a veteran emergency physician wary of new technology. Dr. Baran Al-Hashimi, his temporary replacement, is more enthusiastic.

She introduces an AI documentation tool called Ambient Listening to streamline charting. The application saves time and impresses residents. Then it misidentifies a medication, an error that could have had serious consequences had another physician not caught it.

I’ve written extensively about generative AI’s impact on medicine and found the episode riveting. While the show accurately captured the tension between AI’s advocates and skeptics in medicine, what it left out was even more significant than what it portrayed.

What The Pitt gets right about AI in medicine

The Pitt correctly depicts that many clinicians remain fearful of this powerful, new technology.

In addition to fears that AI will make a mistake that injures a patient, doctors also worry that it will grow too powerful, eventually overriding clinical judgment and diminishing the physician’s role. Both anxieties are reasonable, and together they’ve slowed the adoption of generative AI.

In most hospitals, generative AI has been limited to administrative work: listening to patient encounters, drafting notes for the electronic medical record, summarizing charts, and assisting with billing and coding tasks. Despite the hype, only the most advanced health systems are deploying AI to help doctors and patients diagnose and develop treatment plans.

In that sense, the show gets the central dynamic right. Generative AI in medicine is neither universally embraced as perfect nor completely dismissed as useless. Instead, it has been adopted cautiously in areas unlikely to affect clinical outcomes.

What The Pitt gets wrong about AI in medicine

In one scene, Dr. Al-Hashimi assures her colleagues that the AI system is “98% accurate.” But without context, that figure is deeply misleading.

Accuracy depends on what’s being measured. If Al-Hashimi meant that AI avoids 98% of minor documentation errors, then that figure grossly overstates its performance. But if that statistic means AI makes dangerous errors 2% of the time, there’s no evidence to support that assertion either.

The episode’s biggest error is overstating human performance compared to technological outcomes. When Al-Hashimi tells her colleagues the technology is “excellent, but not perfect” and therefore must always be overseen by a human, she implies clinicians rarely make mistakes. That assumption is grossly inaccurate.

Misdiagnoses contribute to nearly 400,000 American deaths annually, with another 250,000 fatalities linked to preventable medical errors. Studies show that at least half of electronic health records contain at least one mistake, and many are perpetuated when busy physicians copy and paste prior patient notes.

The key question isn’t whether generative AI is flawless. It’s whether it outperforms clinicians working alone. Even a modest drop in misdiagnoses and preventable harm would save tens of thousands of lives each year.

What The Pitt leaves out entirely

The episode focuses on current tensions with GenAI. What it omits is where this technology is headed.

Already, in head-to-head diagnostic comparisons, generative AI performs at levels comparable to human clinicians.

And as tools improve rapidly, the debate will soon shift. The question will no longer be whether GenAI belongs in medicine, but how to deploy it most effectively.

Its greatest impact is unlikely to be in emergency rooms and hospitals. It will be in helping to manage tens of millions of Americans living with chronic disease.

CDC data show that better control of hypertension and diabetes could prevent up to half of heart attacks, strokes, and kidney failure. Today, patients with these illnesses are seen only a few times a year, which helps explain why hypertension is effectively controlled in only half of Americans. Diabetes control rates are even lower.

GenAI can analyze data from home blood pressure cuffs, glucose monitors, and wearables, enabling earlier medication adjustments and timelier treatments. Instead of waiting for a patient’s next office appointment or crisis, clinicians will be able to intervene when warning signs appear. More continuous monitoring has allowed some U.S. health systems to achieve control rates near 90%.

Superior quality at lower costs is the desired future that The Pitt does not explore. The central debate going forward will not be doctors versus machines. It will be how doctors and technology partner for the benefit of patients. Ultimately, the combination of dedicated clinicians, empowered patients, and generative AI will yield clinical outcomes exponentially better than any one of the three alone.

Robert Pearl, the author of “ChatGPT, MD,” teaches at both the Stanford University School of Medicine and the Stanford Graduate School of Business. He is a former CEO of The Permanente Medical Group.


Read More

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez

Photo provided

Edwin Martinez: Latino Muralist Brings Color to Rural Nevada

Vibrant murals with warm, sunlit colors scatter the Reno, Nevada landscape.

Mexican muralist Edwin Martinez brings his heritage and Latinidad to his murals through recognizable, bright colors. One such piece is “Raíces Brillantes,” a mural painted outside the Latino Research Center at the University of Nevada, Reno.

Keep ReadingShow less
​People hold signs supporting Salvadoran community

People hold signs supporting Salvadoran community

Photo provided

Two Months in Limbo: Salvadoran TPS Holders Await Clarity on Their Future

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Trump administration has quietly paused its plan to terminate Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for roughly 200,000 Salvadorans, opting instead to leave the program in an unresolved state of limbo past the September 9, 2026, expiration deadline.

- YouTube youtu.be

Keep ReadingShow less
A pair of scissors cutting one hundred dollar bills
A pair of scissors cutting a continuous strip of one hundred dollar bills
Photo by Igor Omilaev on Unsplash

The Lion's Share of National Debt, Traceable to Supply-Side Economics

Tax Cut Eras (1982–2025)

From 1982 through 2025, the United States fundamentally shifted its fiscal structure through four massive, era-defining waves of tax cuts. Quantifying these legislative packages through data from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) reveals a cumulative primary revenue reduction exceeding $11.5 Trillion in direct nominal costs. When accounting for the compounding interest of $4.5 Trillion required to service, the resulting federal debt, the total fiscal impact rises to $15 Trillion. Since , between fiscal years 1982 and 2025, the U.S. federal government spent a total of approximately $13.5 trillion in gross interest on the national debt, approximately 1/3 of this gross interest was attributable to supply-side tax cuts.

Keep ReadingShow less
San Francisco skyline
city buildings under blue sky during daytime
Photo by Shen Pan on Unsplash

The Razing of the Fillmore

San Francisco called itself “the City That Knows How.” The razing of the Fillmore asks what officials knew about the people whose neighborhood they were changing. Federal money helped finance local redevelopment, while families and businesses bore displacement. We should trace that money and preserve residents’ accounts before another promise of improvement escapes scrutiny.

The Fillmore remains a center of Black cultural life. Black, Japanese and Jewish communities helped shape the neighborhood, its businesses and music. People remain, and people remember. Redevelopment damaged relationships that a construction budget could neither measure nor replace. Its history belongs to surviving residents and their descendants as well as official archives.

Keep ReadingShow less