Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

The Election-Litigation Complex

Opinion

The Election-Litigation Complex
person holding white and red box

Since Bush v. Gore in 2000, election litigation has become a routine feature of American democracy. A few months ago, the Supreme Court made our litigious habit easier to indulge.

In Bost v. Illinois State Board of Elections, the Court expanded who could sue to challenge election procedures (candidates no longer had to demonstrate individualized harm to bring a case). This ruling, likely to stoke litigation, lands in a country already losing faith in its electoral system and amid increasing pressure on the judiciary.


More lawsuits, plus less trust in institutions, are not a reassuring trajectory for American democracy. Many election lawsuits concern ordinary administrative issues, such as questions concerning voting machines or list maintenance. In most democracies, such concerns are seen for what they are: technical complaints that can be quickly and cheaply resolved or responded to by people who understand how elections work.

There is a term for this process (though admittedly dull): administrative election dispute resolution, or AEDR, in which those with knowledge about how elections are run address legitimate concerns, dismiss frivolous ones, and create a clear record for cases that genuinely require a judicial decision. Most democracies worldwide have incorporated AEDR into their elections. U.S. states do too, but in a scattershot way and largely under the radar. While no system is perfect, comparative experience indicates that, with robust, structured AEDR mechanisms in place, fewer disputes escalate into lengthy litigation, and election administrators can demonstrate the ability to self-correct—thereby building citizen trust in the process.

The United States Congress chose to follow this path after the 2000 election debacle. The Help America Vote Act of 2002 (HAVA) requires every state to establish an administrative complaint process for certain types of election disputes. Twenty years later, some states have developed detailed AEDR procedures, forms, deadlines, and hearing rules, while others simply copied HAVA’s language into law and left the rest to improvisation. Most Americans (and election attorneys) are unaware that such a process even exists.

The effects of inadequate AEDR are clear in the form of needless litigation. To provide a recent example, in Kramer v. Hoskins, a self-represented plaintiff sued the Missouri Secretary of State to request an administrative hearing regarding her concerns about voter list maintenance, a process mandated by HAVA. Missouri’s election commission dismissed her complaint, citing timing issues (Missouri‘s AEDR law imposes a 30-day deadline to use its AEDR process following an election’s certification). The court issued an injunction requiring the state to hold the hearing, highlighting the failure of Missouri’s HAVA AEDR in practice: a voter had a procedural concern; Missouri offered no effective administrative channel to address it. The federal court was the voter’s only recourse.

This might seem like a boring procedural drama. But it is more than that. It reveals a structural problem in American democracy that gets very little attention. When people have legitimate questions or concerns about an election and lack a clear, accessible, and technically-In an

informed place to ask those questions, they turn to social media and conspiracy narratives. Sometimes they go to court if they can afford it, or they give up. None of these options helps strengthen the system or increase public trust. The current setup overwhelms court dockets, perpetuates legal uncertainties, disrupts election planning, and wastes resources that could be used more productively.

International experience demonstrates it doesn't have to be this way. Democracies across legal traditions have developed administrative systems to handle large numbers of complaints about how elections are run, while courts serve as safety nets rather than first responders.

Based on decades of comparative electoral work, our recent research identifies five principles that distinguish effective AEDR systems from ineffective ones. First, not all election disputes belong in the same forum; administrative bodies can address process issues, while constitutional challenges and claims of disenfranchisement belong in court. Second, complaint processes must be simple and accessible to serve all election stakeholders. Third, impartiality should be built into institutional design, as in New Hampshire’s bipartisan Ballot Law Commission. Fourth, AEDR must be transparent to build public trust. Finally, AEDR supplements rather than replaces courts by developing factual records, narrowing disputes, and resolving routine cases so judges can focus on harder questions of law.

No constitutional change or new legislation is needed to achieve this; indeed, federal law already mandates it. What’s missing is the political will to fund AEDR, train adjudicators, ensure quick and transparent decisions, and set timelines aligned with election schedules.

American democracy currently faces a barrage of election complaints, ranging from minor issues to serious, fact-based claims. The country needs a trustworthy system to handle these complaints before they escalate into lawsuits and conspiracy theories. More lawsuits deepen divisions, erode public trust in elections, and threaten judicial independence. Other democracies have faced electoral crises and found solutions through effective AEDR.

We can too.

Chad Vickery is Founding Partner of Vickery Law LLP and Board Chair of The Concord Project.

Katherine Ellena is CEO of The Concord Project and Co-Founder of Partnerships for Integrity.

Rebecca Green is Professor of Law and Co-Director of the Election Law Program at William & Mary Law School.

They are co-authors of "Comparative Administrative Election Dispute Resolution," forthcoming in the Review of Litigation, and Professor Green is the author of “Administering Election Disputes” in the University of Miami Law Review (2026).

.


Read More

Hand placing VOTE sticker on shirt

Hand placing VOTE sticker on shirt

Photo provided

The Latino Vote Keeps Changing. Why Do We Keep Calling It a Realignment?

After the 2024 presidential election, the headlines suggested that Latino voters were moving toward the Republican Party. Donald Trump’s gains were interpreted as evidence of a possible political realignment, particularly among working-class Latino voters and younger men.

Two years later, the story has reversed. Latino voters, we are told, are returning to the Democrats.

Keep ReadingShow less
Voters in Alaska

Voters cast their ballots at a polling station at Midtown Mall on October 31, 2026 in Anchorage, Alaska.

(Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

What To Know About Alaska’s Election System

This year’s midterm elections have put a spotlight on Alaska’s “top-four” election system – which includes an open, all-candidate primary and a ranked-choice voting (RCV) general election.

Alaskans voted to adopt this system in 2020 and again to keep it in 2024. It was on the ballot again this November; voters in my home state will likely vote for reform for the third time in six years.

Keep ReadingShow less
James Talarico

U.S. Sen.-elect James Talarico speaks during a midterm election night event at the Long Center for the Performing Arts on Nov. 3, 2026, in Austin, Texas.

(Getty Images)

Gravity Sends Trump Tumbling Back Down

For many Americans, the last decade of politics has tested their patience — and the laws of physics.

Donald Trump’s rise from reality star to president has been marked by jaw-dropping moments that seemed to bend the conventions long-held not only by conservatives and Republicans, but by the world as we know it.

Keep ReadingShow less
midterm election voters

Voters cast their ballots on Election Day at the Cross Insurance Center polling location on November 03, 2026, in Bangor, Maine.

(Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

The Voter as Estimate: What Commercial Profiles Miss About Independent Citizens

In the late 1980s, when my firm, Price Research, prepared a voter survey for the Bakersfield City School District, we began with a basic administrative record from the Kern County elections office. To clean up addresses and append phone numbers, we turned to Political Data Inc. (PDI)—then a young company operating out of two converted dressing-room trailers on the Warner Bros. lot in Burbank. PDI helped us find and organize voters. But to learn what those citizens actually thought about school facilities, taxes, and local bonds, we still had to do something simple: we had to ask them.

Today, that basic administrative list has become the foundation of a multi-million-dollar commercial enterprise. Major vendors such as L2, TargetSmart, Aristotle, i360, and Data Trust assemble public records into vast dossiers, appending anywhere from 600 to over 2,500 individual data points per record—income estimates, housing specifications, vehicle makes, magazine readership, firearm licensing, travel habits, and predictive behavioral scores. What began as a tool for locating voters has evolved into a system for estimating them.

Keep ReadingShow less