Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

How the Latest in AI Threatens Democracy

Opinion

Technology and Presidential Election

Anthropic’s Mythos AI raises alarms about surveillance, deepfakes, and democracy. Why urgent AI regulation is needed as U.S. policy struggles to keep pace.

Getty Images, Douglas Rissing

On April 24, America got a wake-up call from Anthropic, one of the nation’s leading artificial intelligence companies. It announced a new AI tool, called Mythos, that can identify flaws in computer networks and software systems that, as Politico puts it, “Even the brightest human minds have been unable to identify.”

A machine smarter than the “brightest human minds” sounds like a line from a dystopian science fiction movie. And if that weren’t scary enough, we now have a government populated by people who seem oblivious to the risks AI poses to democracy and humanity itself.


Until now, the Trump Administration has been determined to let its tech bro supporters do whatever they want and to blackball AI companies like Anthropic that aren’t willing to let the administration use their AI tools however it wants. The release of Mythos makes the need for smart AI regulation more urgent than ever.

The administration seems to lack the will or capacity to provide what is needed. If the administration won’t provide it, Congress must.

America cannot afford to bury its head in the sand as the developments in AI proceed at warp speed, and neither can the rest of the world. As the American Civil Liberties Union explained last February, those developments have “begun to demolish the foundations for ensuring that artificial intelligence (AI) in the U.S. is safe and responsible. The president is not only set to completely roll back the fledgling protections Joe Biden’s administration instituted, but also to further accelerate the spread of unchecked AI across American life.”

Maybe Mythos has gotten through to the Trump Administration, which has previously sought to make Anthropic pay for its refusal to knuckle under to its outrageous desire to use AI irresponsibly. Recall that the Department of Defense retaliated by declaring Anthropic “a Supply-Chain Risk to National Security” and that “no contractor, supplier, or partner that does business with the United States military may conduct any commercial activity with Anthropic.”

For the first time, that designation, which had been applied only to foreign companies, was directed at one based in the United States. The government did so when the company refused to go along when the Department of Defense demanded that Anthropic “not prevent its technology from being used both for domestic mass surveillance of Americans and for fully autonomous lethal weapons.”

At the time, Dario Amodei, Anthropic CEO, pointed out that “AI can undermine, rather than defend, democratic values. Some uses are also simply outside the bounds of what today’s technology can safely and reliably do.” He went on to say that “AI-driven mass surveillance presents serious, novel risks to our fundamental liberties.”

He explained that “to the extent that such surveillance is currently legal, this is only because the law has not yet caught up with the rapidly growing capabilities of AI…. Powerful AI makes it possible to assemble… scattered, individually innocuous data into a comprehensive picture of any person’s life—automatically and at massive scale.”

Not surprisingly, the Trump Administration was not moved by Amodei’s appeal to democratic values or fundamental liberties. In fact, the president upped the ante when he posted to Truth Social the following: “THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA WILL NEVER ALLOW A RADICAL LEFT, WOKE COMPANY TO DICTATE HOW OUR GREAT MILITARY FIGHTS AND WINS WARS! The Leftwing nut jobs at Anthropic have made a DISASTROUS MISTAKE trying to STRONG-ARM the Department of War….”

“Therefore,” Trump continued, “I am directing EVERY Federal Agency in the United States Government to IMMEDIATELY CEASE all use of Anthropic’s technology. We don’t need it, we don’t want it, and will not do business with them again! …WE will decide the fate of our Country — NOT some out-of-control, Radical Left AI company run by people who have no idea what the real World is all about.”

As CNBC notes, “Before the conflict erupted in late February, Anthropic was one of the first AI companies to partner with many federal agencies as the government sought to rapidly upgrade its systems and capabilities with cutting-edge AI tech.”

In March, Rita Lin, a federal judge in San Francisco, granted Anthropic’s request for a temporary restraining order against the government. But she did more.

Lin called out the administration for punishing Anthropic because it “criticiz(ed) the government’s contracting position in the press. … Punishing Anthropic for bringing public scrutiny to the government’s contracting position is classic illegal First Amendment retaliation.” She wanted no part of “the Orwellian notion that an American company may be branded a potential adversary and saboteur of the U.S. for expressing disagreement with the government.”

Now it seems the Trump Administration is willing to deal with Anthropic’s “nut jobs.” Amodei was even invited to the White House to meet with Chief of Staff Susie Wiles on April 17.

That is one indication that, as a former White House AI advisor told the Washington Post, "'Mythos has activated a lot of people in D.C.‘…For the Trump administration.” The Post adds, “The arrival of Mythos has led to a reckoning with some of the technology’s potential downsides.”

Those downsides include the threat AI poses to democracy and rights and the capacity of democratic governance to keep up with its rapid development. AI can threaten democracy and rights in a variety of ways.

One, its use as a surveillance tool, was highlighted in the dispute between the Defense Department and Anthropic. But there are others.

AI’s capacity to produce convincing “deepfake” content may turn the world of campaigning and electioneering on its head. It can be used to convince voters that one or another political leader or party has said or done something reprehensible.

Combined with social media’s capacity to rapidly amplify such content, we will increasingly live in a world where seeing is not believing. And the Westminster Foundation for Democracy warns, “Deep fakes also enable a ‘liar’s dividend’ whereby political actors claim real content is fake to avoid sanction.”

AI may also be used by government officials to make consequential decisions. We have yet to think about what democratic accountability means in that situation.

The list could go on, but these examples illustrate a few ways that AI may jeopardize democratic processes. And it is not clear that democracies will be adequate to the challenge of adapting to those challenges.

Constitutional democracy in the United States is, even at its best, notoriously slow. And when government is paralyzed by partisan rancor as ours is, what scholars call the “pacing problem” just gets worse.

Simply put, the pacing problem “refers to technological advances outpacing laws and regulations.”

Arizona State University Law Professor Gary Merchant is right to say that “it is in the common interest of all concerned, including government, industry, civil society, and the general public, to try to prevent proactively significant harms from emerging technologies which will…be contrary to public well-being… ‘Rapid change demands foresight, vision, adaptability, and creativity, all combined with a healthy degree of prudence.’”

Those are not words that one would generally associate with the Trump Administration. Even as it may now realize it can’t ignore Anthropic or the growing potency of AI, it seems clear that the president would rather post than think more about AI.

That is a luxury that neither he nor we can afford. The fate of democracy hangs in the balance.


Austin Sarat is the William Nelson Cromwell professor of jurisprudence and political science at Amherst College.


Read More

Young Programmer Analyzing Code on Multiple Computer Screens in Office Environment

Automation makes government faster, but citizens need a right to escalation: a clear path to a human with the authority to review and reverse outcomes.

Witthaya Prasongsin/Getty Images

Better Government Requires Knowing When the System Should Stop

A digital public service can work perfectly for thousands of people and still fail the one person standing in front of an exceptional problem. That is the uncomfortable part of government automation. We tend to measure success by speed, completion rates and how many transactions no longer require a counter or a phone call. Those gains matter. But citizens usually discover the limits of a system at a very different moment: when the answer on the screen is wrong for their circumstances and there is no obvious person with the authority to stop, review or correct what happens next.

I have spent years thinking about operations, risk and control rooms, where automation is valuable precisely because time matters. Good systems reduce noise, organize information and help people act faster. Yet high-reliability environments also teach another lesson: speed is not the same as control. A process becomes safer not only because it can move quickly, but because someone knows when to interrupt it. Government should take that lesson seriously as more public decisions are supported, filtered or executed through digital systems.

Keep ReadingShow less
Written on a whiteboard: AI?
The letters AI and a question mark written in black marker on a whiteboard

A Democracy That Uses AI Agents Needs Permission Receipts

An organization can correct a faulty AI-generated paragraph in minutes. Repairing the damage after an automated system impersonates a trusted source, emails thousands of people, or changes public records can take much longer. As AI tools gain permission to act, civic institutions need to govern the authority they delegate with the same seriousness they give to the accuracy of an answer.

On October 8, OpenAI reported disrupting covert influence operations linked to Iran and Russia. One operation used seven fabricated journalist identities to place material in outside publications. OpenAI investigators identified almost 100 articles published or syndicated under those bylines across roughly a dozen outlets. The operators were humans using AI to refine articles and pitches. That distinction matters: this was deceptive human direction amplified by technology, rather than evidence of independent machine intentions.

Keep ReadingShow less
classroom, learning, teaching, class, students

AI literacy isn’t just about jobs. Learn why schools should teach students to question AI outputs, verify claims, and think critically as citizens.

Getty Images, Rafa Fernandez Torres

AI Is Shaping Democracy. Are We Preparing Students?

Almost everyone I know is talking about artificial intelligence. Teacher friends say it helps with administrative tasks, then describe their frustration when students use it to complete assignments. Principals wonder whether teachers are using it effectively. Colleagues past and present worry about how it will shape their students’ lives. And among parents in my kids’ circles, the chatter is mostly about jobs: Do we need AI literacy to stay relevant at work? What does AI mean for our children’s future careers? How much should we trust it?

These questions matter, but I worry we’re missing the plot. AI literacy isn’t only about preparing students to work with AI. It’s about preparing them to live in a democracy increasingly shaped by it.

Keep ReadingShow less
Judge's Gavel Hammer as a Symbol of Law and Order with Processor CPU AI Chip.

Anthropic warns of AI botnets seizing the web. A veteran trial attorney argues the solution is simple: unplug the internet and bring back an analog society.

Getty Images, Alexander Sikov

Let the Bots Have the Internet!

Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has warned "that a swarm of AI agents soon ‘could be capable of taking over the entire internet with a persistent botnet.’”

Oh, perish the thought! I say, let’s unplug from and discontinue use of the internet. Let the bots roam uselessly on an unused internet and perhaps die a natural death there!

Keep ReadingShow less