The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.
It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.
Look at the numbers: Nationally, 43% of all voters voted Republican; 48% of males; 51% of Whites; 48% of all voters over 45; 59% of all White non-college-educated voters. These numbers are shocking—a very significant portion of the American public continues to back Trump (this was a referendum on Trump) despite the economic problems, Iran, and his personality.
Given these numbers, the big question for the Democratic Party is not just how we prove our merit to the American people, but how we restore our democracy—not just structurally, but by connecting a broad base of people to our founding principles.
How did we get here? There are two major causes. First, government let middle-class workers and their families down by acting in ways that hurt their well-being. The second is that every 4 years, Democrats have presented a grab-bag of policies they call a platform but devoid of a cohesive vision that connects these policies to our founding principles.
Democrats used to be the stalwart party of the People. But after Ronald Reagan's election, the Democratic Party adopted a more transactional approach because it wanted to appeal to both a broader group of voters and corporations. As a result, it strayed from being the party of the People to being a liberal party that also supports the interests of corporate America. Because corporate interests often oppose the interests of the American worker—for example, free trade agreements and globalization—supporting corporate interests meant the Party sold out the American worker. The result has been 50 years of increasing worker demoralization caused by the perfect storm of lost jobs, wage stagnation, and inflation—which resulted in first the Tea Party and then the Trump phenomenon.
In contrast, it has been Trump that has stood on principle—unfortunately that principle was disgust with the Federal government, its liberal policies, and the fundamental structure of our democracy. His aim was to smash it to pieces, and masses of people loved him for it because they had no faith in the government and saw it, in Ronald Reagan's words, "not as the solution, but the problem." That his supporters have mostly stayed with him, even when that support ran counter to their self-interest, shows the power of principled politics, even when the principles are dangerous.
In the days after the midterm election, there has been no shortage of advice from pundits and politicians about what Democrats should do with their majorities in Congress. And for the most part, I would agree with what they are saying.
But there is a major difference between what they are saying and what I said in my article, "A Democratic Manifesto - The First 100 Days of the Democratic Congress." The plans of pundits and politicians are all examples of transactional politics—they address the problems people are concerned about right now. And that's important. But there is no mission, no cohesive vision that connects these policies, let alone connects them to our founding principles and so provide people with an understanding of why these principles are important to their well-being.
At the moment, transactional politics favors government action that would be classified as "liberal." That's great. But all too recently, transactional politics and Trump's principles favored government action that was far right. If policy is not anchored by democratic principle, there is no safe harbor from the winds of change that routinely alter the politics of the moment.
Principled politics is also important because by focusing on principles that are larger than their own self-interest, people feel that they are a part of something; they have a grounding. In the hands of a leader like JFK or Winston Churchill, principles can drive people to greatness. But in the hands of someone like Trump—whose principles were the destruction of democracy and nativism—the mass of his supporters became unthinking adherents of his philosophy.
For 20 years, I have urged the Democratic Party to have as its principle the implementation of the words of the Declaration of Independence. In 2004 I wrote, "We STILL Hold These Truths: An American Manifesto." That book used the words of the Declaration as a touchstone for looking at all areas of government activity and defining the policies that the Democratic Party should promote. Whether it's education, health care, civil rights, security, the economy, the environment, and taxation—the Declaration provides a perspective to view what American government policy should be.
But despite James Fallows', National Correspondent, The Atlantic, endorsing the book in 2004, saying, "Ron Hirsch's We Still Hold These Truths is a systematic and serious effort to make [the presidential] debate as clear and valuable as it can be. Agree or disagree with his specific conclusions, the questions he is asking are the right ones for the public this year," my thoughts have remained a proverbial voice in the wilderness. The idea of a mission based on the Declaration seems, for some reason, to be anathema to the Democratic Party.
Most recently in the Fulcrum article noted above, I proposed again a mission statement for the Party and policies that would flow from that mission.
"Our mission shall be to build a country of greater opportunity where:
- each and every American has a real chance to experience the promises made in the Declaration of Independence: 'that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness' ;
- government meets its responsibility as set forth in the Declaration—‘to secure these rights’; and
- all citizens have a shared responsibility to support the government’s efforts to secure these rights and promote the public good, each according to his ability.”
The greatness of America lies not just in our economic and military strength, but in the values it has stood for since our independence—democracy, equality, the rights of all—despite the fact that the reality of life in the United States often has not lived up to these principles. Our nation will be stronger when each person, regardless of background, is encouraged to make the most of themselves, their skills and talent, and thus contribute both to their own and the nation's wellbeing.
This American ideal is what the Democratic Party should stand for. Donald Trump is dangerous because he has sought to change the very essence of America. Democrats must take the lead in helping America get back to that essence.
Ronald L. Hirsch is a teacher, legal aid lawyer, survey researcher, nonprofit executive, consultant, composer, author, and volunteer. He is a graduate of Brown University and the University of Chicago Law School and the author of We Still Hold These Truths. Read more of his writing at www.PreservingAmericanValues.com




















