Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

The Supreme Court is broken and needs to be reformed

Opinion

The Supreme Court at sunset
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

Turberville is director of The Constitution Project as the Project on Government Oversight, a nonpartisan group that investigates corruption, misconduct and conflicts of interest in the federal government.


The Supreme Court's reputation has been sullied by deeply contentious confirmation processes and the resulting polarizing rulings by its own justices. One would hope that the commission convened by President Biden would at least acknowledge that this is a problem significant enough to warrant consideration of some transformative reform. But if the commission's first public deliberations Oct. 15 are any indication of the trajectory of this group, it has a ways to go before even agreeing on this fundamental premise.

The president perhaps hobbled the group from the beginning by not giving it a firm mandate to issue recommendations — the commission is instead tasked with "an appraisal of the merits and legality of particular reform proposals."

But if the commission does not coalesce around at least some meaningful suggestions for reform, it could entrench a broken process for decades (or more). As Commissioner Nancy Gertner noted, "the purpose of this commission is to encourage discussion as opposed to stop it." And it's not too late — the commission should make clear in its final report which specific proposed reforms could better protect the court's independence to ensure that it serves as a safeguard against abuse of power, rather than as an instrument to provide legal cover for such abuses.

To be sure, the commission's public proceedings and recent release of draft discussion documents have been a refreshingly thoughtful and civil exercise concerning some of the most difficult and polarizing issues of the day. And the group did not shy away from sussing out the challenges with implementation of particular reforms.

Its materials spend considerable time on figuring out how term limits could be practically implemented. Term limits would address the problem of justices serving for decades—too long for any individual to hold power in a democracy — and bring the court closer to the practices in the vast majority of state supreme courts, which have some sort of limit on a justices' tenure. And as the commission noted, there is bipartisan support for the reform.

But it cannot stop there.

Term limits alone will not resolve the issue at the core of the Supreme Court's politicization: the hyper-partisan process for selecting nominees in the first place. On their own, term limits could simply make conflicts more common, not less likely.

Alexander Hamilton famously called the judiciary the "least dangerous" branch. But the judiciary has been brazenly exploited by the political branches to cement power and advance partisan agendas, particularly over the last several decades. Politicians and special-interest groups — and even the American public — have come to view capturing the court as essential for securing policy victories, and as a means to ensure that their particular policy agendas become entrenched for decades to come.

The commission must therefore focus on shifting the incentives that motivate politicians to engage in partisan warfare over judicial nominees, which has obviously affected the public's perception of the fairness of the institution — and, to many, the actual fairness of its decision-making.

At present, the court's considerable power is concentrated in a small group of people with nearly unlimited discretion, who often serve for decades. As a result, the stakes are high — too high — when a vacancy occurs. This has led to political parties strategizing to appoint a majority of justices who will consistently align with their preferred outcomes.

So we need to diffuse power on the Supreme Court so each individual justice is less influential while they serve. This could take the form of having the court hear cases in smaller, randomly assigned panels like the federal appeals courts do, or even rotating members on and off the Supreme Court, which could also make it harder for partisans to create blocs of justices who routinely vote together.

The use of screening committees to vet and recommend nominees for the Supreme Court could also reduce the likelihood that partisans could stack the court with justices who would be favorable to their views. Such committees are already employed successfully at lower levels in the federal court system and in some states.

These sorts of reforms, combined with term limits, could dramatically alter the stakes of confirmation. With predictable openings, a set term of service, and less power vested in each individual, Supreme Court confirmations would no longer carry the political significance they do now.

As with any proposal, the devil is in the details: The commission seems to think that the creation of term limits or a requirement that the court sit in panels, would raise constitutional concerns. But that should not be taken for a given. There is little dispute that the Congress could, by statute, continue to expand the size of the court. It makes little sense that Congress could not implement reasonable structural reforms — like having the court sit in panels — that could help make decision-making less predictably partisan, but that Congress could, on the other hand, expand the size of the court to 200 or 2,000 people.

And here too, the commission has the chance to advance the debate. The Constitution can be amended for a reason, but ruling out any reform that requires an amendment simply ensures the status quo.

With the Supreme Court's 2021 term fully underway, we are once again reminded just how large the court looms in the political and social life of our nation. We hold our collective breath and wait for the highest court to weigh in on a slate of hot-button issues. This term alone it has decided to take on gun rights, abortion, and state secrets, with many more case selections to come. It may very well render decisions that will fundamentally shape the public and private lives of millions of Americans for worse or for better.

In short, the Supreme Court is supremely powerful. But in our democracy, it shouldn't be. The commission's next draft will come next month and we hope it will seize this opportunity to legitimize some long overdue reforms to an institution that hasn't really changed since the founding of the Republic.


Read More

two cars on a highway
Cars drive on a highway next to a river

Why Your Town’s Roads Run Through Washington: Unpacking Transportation Infrastructure Funding

Introduction

Access to reliable transportation is a critical part of most Americans’ daily lives. In 2022, Americans took an average of 2.28 trips per day, traveling 28.55 miles on average — figures including every mode of transportation and every purpose, for the full population. However, little attention is paid to transportation infrastructure until there are obvious problems like potholes or broken sidewalks linked to sharp decreases in road safety and quality of life for nearby residents. Given widespread reliance on transportation infrastructure makes examination of the governance structures underpinning its funding an important area of consideration.

Process-Shaping Priorities and the Federal Level

At the federal level, transportation infrastructure is primarily governed by the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT), an executive branch agency split into nine main operating administrations overseeing a specific part of the national transit system. USDOT then uses this oversight to distribute federal funding and ensure that individual transit outlets comply with national policy and safety standards. Distributed federal funding is drawn from the Highway Trust Fund, a dedicated federal fund financed through taxes on gas and other transportation costs, and distributed to states through formula-based approaches or competitive grant programs based on spending caps established by Congress. While federal funding plays an important role in transportation infrastructure, it only represents one-quarter of all public spending on roads and highways. The remaining three-quarters of long-term financing and associated maintenance is provided by state and local governments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol Building in Washington, DC
white concrete building under blue sky during daytime

The Public Is Demanding Ethics Reform. Will Congress Listen?

At the end of the 2026 midterm elections, “corruption” emerged as a central issue in the campaign. The public outrage had been building for years. In a September 2026 Gallup poll, 89 percent of Americans agreed that corruption is “widespread throughout the government,” an all-time high. Allegations that members of Congress use insider information for stock trading have become a common belief. Additionally, a raft of sexual harassment and sexual assault scandals has shed light on the inadequate protections in place for congressional employees. As the 120th Congress convenes in January, Congress must respond to this national cry for ethics reform in the legislative and executive branches.

Historically, Congress has always needed a scandal to act. The Honest Government and Open Leadership Act of 2007 – famously proclaimed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi as an act to “drain the swamp” – was passed as a result of the lobbyist Jack Abramoff scandal involving illegal gifts and favors to members of Congress. It appears the swamp was harder to drain than anticipated.

Keep ReadingShow less
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
a piece of paper cut out of the shape of a donkey
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

America Adrift—Our Future Depends on Returning to American Principles and Standards

The Democratic Party won the recent midterm elections overwhelmingly. But this was not because voters returned to the way people—whether Republican or Democrat— used to think about government and their relationship with it.

It was simply a matter of people being fed up with ever-increasing prices and with the Iran War. It was not a rejection of Trump's vicious, narcissistic, megalomaniac, mendacious personality nor his anti-democratic actions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Woman sleeping on the floor in a detention center

Getty Images

Who Benefits When the Process Fails?

In my previous article, I wrote about TK, a lawful permanent resident who has lived in the US for 61 years and now faces possible deportation. I questioned whether immigration enforcement could coexist with fairness, compassion, and respect for the lives people have built in this country.

Since then, I have learned something equally troubling. The legal proceedings are only part of the ordeal. What happens outside the courtroom can be just as devastating.

Keep ReadingShow less