Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Follow Us:
Top Stories

Safe Spaces vs. Free Speech: Rethinking Campus Safety

Why defining ‘safe’ matters more than debating safe spaces themselves

Opinion

students walking, college campus
a group of people walking on a sidewalk

“I really want to be able to discuss polarizing topics,” she said. “But as long as it’s a safe space.”

This common sentiment reflects recent data on students’ attitudes toward speech on campus: a 2024 Knight Foundation study found that 91% of students value free speech as “very important” or "important," while 64% of students believe colleges should offer “safe spaces” on campus, with only 15% opposed.


But what do students really mean by “safe spaces”? Some students use the term to refer to spaces that are physically safe, especially amid growing fears about ICE on campus. Other students use the term to refer to emotional safety, reflecting spaces where authentic conversation on controversial topics is expected, but with rules: no slurs, for example, or no dehumanizing others. Still others feel that, in safe spaces, certain ideas or viewpoints should be forbidden, because of the harm that they cause.

With such a range of definitions, it’s no wonder that the phrase itself has become polarizing. Some view safe spaces as a must, while others view them as a reflection of weakness or lack of resiliency in my generation. Some have proposed “brave spaces” instead, where students are encouraged to speak with courage about controversial issues. As a 2025 college graduate, I often felt intellectual whiplash on Harvard’s campus, between the promotion and decrying of spaces as “safe,” the introduction of new “brave” spaces, and trying to sort out which was which and what meant what.

As someone who spends my new professional career engaged with speech on college campuses, I propose clarifying the term “safety” in this context, with historical precedent.

In 1958, philosopher Isaiah Berlin gave a speech at Oxford entitled “Two Concepts of Liberty.” At the time, Berlin responded to increasingly intense clashes between liberalism, socialism, communism, and other ideologies, each claiming to champion “freedom.” In response, Berlin proposed two frameworks of liberty —negative and positive — aiming to add nuance to the term.

Negative freedom can be described as “freedom from,” as in freedom from restriction. It’s the freedom to do whatever you want, whenever you want, because you are a free person. In contrast, positive freedom is described as “freedom to,” as in, the freedom to have certain entitlements or rights, the retention of which may require some limitations on your negative freedom. For example, because everyone has the right to life, you are not free to murder, and because everyone has the right to free movement, you are not free to evade paying the taxes which fund highways.

This distinction helps resolve conflict between those who view freedom differently. If John were to accuse Sally of being “anti-freedom” for supporting taxes, and Sally in turn called John “anti-freedom” for refusing to contribute to the roads she had the right to travel on, a third party could remind them that in fact they were both “pro-freedom,” but just defined it differently. When someone speaks casually of freedom, they could reasonably be asked, “Do you mean freedom from, or freedom to?”

So how does this all relate to safe spaces? I suggest that the same question, “from, or to?” when applied to the term “safe space,” could have a similarly clarifying and depolarizing effect. When students ask about a safe space, we could ask, “Safe for what?” or “Safe from what?” In doing so, we could better understand their expectations and see how they align with our values. Similarly, when offering “safe spaces,” we could clarify, “This space is safe from non-campus affiliates,” or “This space is safe from slurs.” To step it up a notch, we could even say, “While this space is safe from hateful speech, it is safe for competing viewpoints to be heard and considered.”

Certainly, we cannot 100% control what will be said in a space. But debating whether we should have safe spaces is so ambiguous that it's unproductive. Instead, defining what we mean by them can move the term from a political buzzword to a clarifying statement about what a space is meant to be.

Shira Hoffer is the founding Executive Director of The Viewpoints Project. A 2025 graduate in Social Studies and Religion, she served on Harvard’s Intellectual Vitality Committee for two years, advising and presenting on new strategies for promoting constructive disagreement on campus, and is a practicing mediator in Massachusetts courts. Her senior thesis explored differing campus speech behaviors between religious and secular college students.


Read More

A person reaches for a book on a shelf in a library.

A daughter of Cultural Revolution survivors argues U.S. school book bans are about power, not protection, and how a freedom-to-read law offers a way forward.

LAW Ho Ming/Getty Images

My Parents Lived through a Book Ban. Americans Should Demand the Freedom to Read.

At the start of this school year, a Texas schoolteacher from my home school district went nationally viral. In a video, Darius Williams sobbed as he explained that after he “gave them the answers,” his high school seniors still could not complete an exercise comprising two sentences to read and one to write. Reading scores in the country currently languish at a twenty-year low. In the new year, a historic set of new state lawmakers around the country should prioritize reversing ineffective policies that have kept critical reading materials out of school libraries.

Since 2021, book bans have reached a level “never before seen in the life of any living American” (34,000 total in public schools across the country, according to PEN America). Some institutions are even preemptively removing materials to avoid controversy, a phenomenon termed “soft censorship.”

Keep ReadingShow less
U.S. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth stands for anthems at the Pentagon on October 15, 2026 in Arlington, Virginia. The two defense officials discussed NATO financial commitments by European countries.

Hegseth’s order ending tenure at the service academies punishes scholars and leaves future officers less prepared for war. Here’s why Congress should step in.

Finn Gomez/Getty Images

Secretary Hegseth's Tenure Ban Fails Our Officers and the Academy

Yesterday, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth fired another round of shots in his war on higher education, and once again he fought it in his own backyard. After pulling books off the shelves of the Naval Academy and cutting the Pentagon’s ties to graduate programs at Harvard and Princeton, he signed a memo ordering the service academies to stop granting tenure to civilian professors, effective immediately. Tenure, he wrote, breeds “academic stagnation, faculty complacency,” and belongs to a broader academic structure that serves to “dilute our focus on lethality.” This assault on the academy is a mistake, both wronging the scholars who teach at the academies, and leaving the cadets and midshipmen who learn from them less prepared for war.

In his depiction of the tenure system's shortcomings, Hegseth mischaracterizes it as a finish line, where receiving tenure marks the moment a professor stops running. Granted, there is a grain of truth here: a study of over 12,000 American faculty members published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that in non-lab-based fields like political science and sociology, publication rates do fall once tenure is secured. Lab-based fields, meanwhile, sustain high research output. More importantly, however, the same study found that after receiving tenure, scholars turn toward newer, riskier questions, also known as the kind that occasionally transforms a field.

Keep ReadingShow less
Students in a classroom.​

Civics is a practice, not a quiz. See how immigrant and Indigenous communities are teaching schools to build, not blend in, as America turns 250.

Getty Images, andresr

Schools Can’t Teach Democracy Without Valuing Students’ Lived Experiences

Recently, I gathered with a group of dads outside Philadelphia to clear out a neighborhood park through Dads for All, the organization I co-founded. Some of us grew up in that neighborhood, some had never set foot in it, and plenty of us had no idea what we were doing. Our kids, ages three to seventeen, hauled branches and swung tools nearly as long as they were tall — and they were delighted.

Here's what I watched them figure out: A park is where a kid gets to be free. It's where you run, where you pretend to be a superhero, where the ground belongs to you. And you assume it just shows up. That morning, our children learned that it doesn't. Somebody has to see what it could be. Somebody has to partner with the people who own it and the people who use it. And then somebody has to pick up the loppers. That was the most honest civics lesson my son has ever had, and unfortunately, that is where the problem is.

Keep ReadingShow less
The Window to Safely Managing the Education Freedom Tax Credit is Closing Fast
Empty wooden tables and chairs in a library with shelves of books
Photo by Tuyen Vo on Unsplash

The Window to Safely Managing the Education Freedom Tax Credit is Closing Fast

There is a major change in how students, schools, and educational programs can be funded, taking effect on January 1, 2027, with a small window of time to ensure the program is well managed. We have to move fast.

The Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC) creates a new federal tax credit for taxpayers who make qualified contributions to approved nonprofit Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs). SGOs, in turn, use that money to award scholarships for tutoring, tuition, or other qualified education expenses for students, regardless of whether they attend public, private, or charter schools. The money is contributed directly to SGOs by taxpayers, who can receive a dollar-for-dollar tax credit on their 2027 tax filing, up to $1,700 for individuals and $3,400 for married taxpayers filing jointly.

Keep ReadingShow less